Chautauqua, NY
Medicare Advantage in this county: who has the members, how that changed in a year, and what CMS pays. Enrollment for November 2026.
Members and shares come from CMS's monthly enrollment by contract, plan and county, for every MA contract including Medicare-Medicaid plans. CMS hides any plan's county count of 10 or fewer, so they use the counts it shows (701 plans here are that small). Each contract counts under its current parent in both months. Penetration is CMS's: MA enrollees (including cost plans and PACE) over all Medicare eligibles in the county. The benchmark is CMS's monthly Parts A&B rate per member at a 1.0 risk score before any quality bonus; the 4-star bonus is the extra a plan rated 4 stars or more earns per member per month here.i
Who has the members
| Parent organization | Members | Share | A year ago | Change | Share of eligibles | Contracts here |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CVS Health Corporation | 5,474 | 25.1% | 10.9% | +14.2 pts | 16.6% | H5521 Aetna Medicare 4,697; H3312 Aetna Medicare 617; H5522 Aetna Medicare 160 |
| UnitedHealth Group, Inc. | 5,304 | 24.3% | 25.1% | −0.8 pts | 16.1% | H3379 UnitedHealthcare 2,135; H3387 UnitedHealthcare 1,962; H2001 UnitedHealthcare 556; H3418 UnitedHealthcare 555 +1 more |
| Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. | 4,871 | 22.3% | 18.2% | +4.1 pts | 14.8% | H3351 Excellus Health Plan, Inc 4,816; H3335 Excellus Health Plan, Inc 55 |
| Humana Inc. | 2,058 | 9.4% | 7.1% | +2.3 pts | 6.2% | H5970 Humana 1,789; H3533 Humana 269 |
| Highmark Health | 1,838 | 8.4% | 21.6% | −13.2 pts | 5.6% | H5526 Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield or Highmark Blue Shield 1,055; H3384 Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield or Highmark Blue Shield 732; H3916 Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield or Highmark Blue Shield 51 |
| Independent Health Association, Inc. | 1,360 | 6.2% | 12.1% | −5.8 pts | 4.1% | H3362 Independent Health 1,305; H3344 Independent Health 55 |
| Centene Corporation | 885 | 4.1% | 4.9% | −0.8 pts | 2.7% | H2775 Wellcare 872; H2816 Wellcare 13 |
| Elevance Health, Inc. | 15 | 0.1% | 0.1% | −0 pts | 0.0% | H4036 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 15 |
Penetration over timei
January figuresJanuary points (hollow) are CMS's early January count. CMS counts January before all of the new year's enrollments are processed, so January often reads low, sometimes below December, even though most plan changes take effect then. February's count catches up. The figures are shown as CMS published them.
i
January points (hollow) are CMS's early January count. CMS counts January before all of the new year's enrollments are processed, so January often reads low, sometimes below December, even though most plan changes take effect then. February's count catches up. The figures are shown as CMS published them.
Benchmarks
| Year | No bonus | With 4★ bonus | Bonus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $1,121.34 | $1,121.34 | $0.00 (0%) |
| 2026 | $1,224.11 | $1,241.80 | $17.69 (1.4%) |
| 2027 | $1,294.44 | $1,296.33 | $1.89 (0.1%) |
Monthly Parts A&B rate per member at a 1.0 risk score.
Plans on sale for 2027
36 plans for everyone from 8 organizations (median premium $0 a month, 53% at $0; median out-of-pocket maximum $7,750), and 16 special needs plans from 5 organizations. Compare every plan's benefits.
Traditional Medicare and ACOs
About 11,724 people here were in traditional Medicare in 2024, and 58% of them were in an accountable care organization.
Spending and risk score are CMS's figures for traditional Medicare beneficiaries who could be assigned to an ACO: aged and disabled people (ESRD apart) who had primary care in traditional Medicare during 2025. Spending is Parts A and B per person-year, shown per month; the risk score is CMS-HCC, weighted across enrollment types by person-years. People with no primary care visit aren't counted, so this is higher than traditional Medicare's average cost and isn't the base of the MA benchmark above. In an ACO: Shared Savings Program assigned and ACO REACH aligned beneficiaries living here in 2024, over traditional Medicare enrollees (Medicare eligibles less MA enrollees, averaged over the year). That count includes people with Part A only, who can't be assigned, so the share is slightly understated. In a few small counties the two counts don't line up (more ACO members than the count of traditional Medicare enrollees); the share is left blank there. CMS hides an ACO's county count of 10 or fewer. Source: CMS's Shared Savings Program county files and ACO REACH public use files on data.cms.gov.i
| ACO | Program | Track | Members here, 2024 | Share of traditional Medicare | Savings rate (latest year) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Collaborative ACO 30, LLC | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 3,157 | 26.9% | 2.2% (2024) |
| Honest ACO of New York LLC | REACH | Standard, Global | 1,801 | 15.4% | 9.6% (2024) |
| Optimum NY Independent Practice Association, LLC | REACH | Standard, Professional | 821 | 7.0% | 12.0% (2024) |
| Physician Partners of Western PA LLC | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 562 | 4.8% | 2.8% (2024) |
| Alliance for Integrated Care of New York, LLC | Shared Savings | Basic C | 236 | 2.0% | −10.7% (2024) |
| Catholic Medical Partners-Accountable Care IPA, INC | REACH | Standard, Global | 82 | 0.7% | 4.2% (2024) |
| CINQCARE ACO REACH LLC | REACH | Standard, Global | 52 | 0.4% | 3.6% (2024) |
| agilon health Northeastern ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 6) | REACH | Standard, Global | 29 | 0.2% | 16.5% (2024) |
| Cleveland Clinic Medicare ACO, LLC | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 22 | 0.2% | 4.5% (2024) |
| Medical Home Network Health Alliance II, LLC | Shared Savings | Basic A | 22 | 0.2% | 2.4% (2024) |
| AdvantageCare ACO (ended) | Shared Savings | Basic E | 10 or fewer | — | 0.3% (2024) |
| AdvantagePoint Health Alliance - Blue Ridge, LLC | Shared Savings | Basic E | 10 or fewer | — | 2.0% (2024) |
| Aledade 101 Northeast MSSP Enhanced | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 3.1% (2024) |
| Aledade 150 PACHC MSSP Enhanced | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 4.4% (2024) |
| Aledade 153 SC MSSP Enhanced | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 4.8% (2024) |
| Aledade 22 NC MSSP Enhanced | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 9.4% (2024) |
| Aledade 48 National MSSP Enhanced | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 7.8% (2024) |
| Aledade 59 AR MSSP Enhanced | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 6.2% (2024) |
| Aledade 91 CA MSSP Enhanced | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | −1.0% (2024) |
| Aledade A2198 MI MSSP Enhanced | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 2.5% (2024) |
| Aledade A4548 NC Legacy MSSP Enhanced | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 9.4% (2024) |
| Altais Care Alliance | Shared Savings | Basic A | 10 or fewer | — | 0.8% (2024) |
| Atlantic ACO | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 3.9% (2024) |
| Banner Health Network | Shared Savings | Enhanced | 10 or fewer | — | 4.1% (2024) |
| Baptist Health Care Partners, LLC | Shared Savings | Basic B | 10 or fewer | — | 0.3% (2024) |
The 25 ACOs with the most members here, of 73.
Traditional Medicare spending per member per month: 2023 $952 (risk 1.05); 2024 $1,086 (risk 1.06); 2025 $1,149 (risk 1.05).