Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
StatesCountiesPlan year changesRoom to growMedicaid

← NY · NY counties

Erie, NY

Medicare Advantage in this county: who has the members, how that changed in a year, and what CMS pays. Enrollment for November 2026.

i
How this is counted

Members and shares come from CMS's monthly enrollment by contract, plan and county, for every MA contract including Medicare-Medicaid plans. CMS hides any plan's county count of 10 or fewer, so they use the counts it shows (724 plans here are that small). Each contract counts under its current parent in both months.

Penetration is CMS's: MA enrollees (including cost plans and PACE) over all Medicare eligibles in the county.

The benchmark is CMS's monthly Parts A&B rate per member at a 1.0 risk score before any quality bonus; the 4-star bonus is the extra a plan rated 4 stars or more earns per member per month here.

71.7%
MA penetration
157,372 of 219,558 eligibles; +0.1 pts in a year
156,561
MA members
1.6% increase in a year
11
parent organizations
concentration 1,825
$1,305
benchmark 2027
5.6% on the year before; 4★ bonus $102 (7.8%)

Who has the members

Parent organizationMembersShareA year agoChangeShare of eligiblesContracts here
Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. 35,499 22.7% 9.4% +13.3 pts 16.2% H3351 Excellus Health Plan, Inc 35,000; H3335 Excellus Health Plan, Inc 375; H7524 Excellus Health Plan Community Care LLC 124
Independent Health Association, Inc. 35,233 22.5% 34.6% −12.1 pts 16.0% H3362 Independent Health 31,845; H3344 Independent Health 3,388
UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 32,159 20.5% 19.3% +1.2 pts 14.6% H3379 UnitedHealthcare 11,870; H3387 UnitedHealthcare 11,462; H2001 UnitedHealthcare 7,805; H3418 UnitedHealthcare 716 +1 more
CVS Health Corporation 21,624 13.8% 4.3% +9.5 pts 9.8% H5521 Aetna Medicare 16,524; H3312 Aetna Medicare 4,041; H5522 Aetna Medicare 1,059
Highmark Health 20,183 12.9% 25.1% −12.2 pts 9.2% H3384 Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield or Highmark Blue Shield 13,859; H5526 Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield or Highmark Blue Shield 5,520; H3916 Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield or Highmark Blue Shield 804
Centene Corporation 6,730 4.3% 4.9% −0.6 pts 3.1% H5599 Wellcare 2,981; H2775 Wellcare 2,394; H4868 Wellcare 1,336; H2816 Wellcare 19
Humana Inc. 4,178 2.7% 1.9% +0.8 pts 1.9% H5970 Humana 3,518; H3533 Humana 660
Visiting Nurse Service of New York 538 0.3% 0.0% +0.3 pts 0.2% H5549 VNS Health Medicare 538
Elevance Health, Inc. 315 0.2% 0.2% −0 pts 0.1% H4036 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 291; H6078 Blue Medicare Advantage 24
VISITING NURSE ASSOCIATION OF CENTRAL NEW YORK 57 0.0% 0.0% +0 pts 0.0% H9066 Nascentia Health Plus 57
MVP Health Care, Inc. 45 0.0% 0.1% −0 pts 0.0% H9615 MVP HEALTH CARE 28; H3305 MVP HEALTH CARE 17
Health Care Service Corporation 0 0.0% 0.0% −0 pts 0.0%

Penetration over time
i
January figures

January points (hollow) are CMS's early January count. CMS counts January before all of the new year's enrollments are processed, so January often reads low, sometimes below December, even though most plan changes take effect then. February's count catches up. The figures are shown as CMS published them.

Benchmarks

YearNo bonusWith 4★ bonusBonus
2025$1,136.05$1,215.49$79.44 (7%)
2026$1,235.82$1,343.29$107.47 (8.7%)
2027$1,305.03$1,406.54$101.51 (7.8%)

Monthly Parts A&B rate per member at a 1.0 risk score.

Plans on sale for 2027

36 plans for everyone from 9 organizations (median premium $0 a month, 53% at $0; median out-of-pocket maximum $8,450), and 24 special needs plans from 8 organizations. Compare every plan's benefits.

Traditional Medicare and ACOs

About 62,278 people here were in traditional Medicare in 2024, and 40% of them were in an accountable care organization.

i
How this is counted

Spending and risk score are CMS's figures for traditional Medicare beneficiaries who could be assigned to an ACO: aged and disabled people (ESRD apart) who had primary care in traditional Medicare during 2025. Spending is Parts A and B per person-year, shown per month; the risk score is CMS-HCC, weighted across enrollment types by person-years. People with no primary care visit aren't counted, so this is higher than traditional Medicare's average cost and isn't the base of the MA benchmark above.

In an ACO: Shared Savings Program assigned and ACO REACH aligned beneficiaries living here in 2024, over traditional Medicare enrollees (Medicare eligibles less MA enrollees, averaged over the year). That count includes people with Part A only, who can't be assigned, so the share is slightly understated. In a few small counties the two counts don't line up (more ACO members than the count of traditional Medicare enrollees); the share is left blank there. CMS hides an ACO's county count of 10 or fewer.

Source: CMS's Shared Savings Program county files and ACO REACH public use files on data.cms.gov.

$1,201
traditional Medicare spending per member per month, 2025
$1,103 at a 1.0 risk score
1.09
traditional Medicare risk score
13% dual eligible (aged)
40%
of traditional Medicare in an ACO, 2024
24,907 members; 2,585 Shared Savings, 22,322 REACH
13
ACOs with members here
largest: Catholic Medical Partners-Accountable Care IPA, INC
ACOProgramTrackMembers here, 2024Share of traditional MedicareSavings rate (latest year)
Catholic Medical Partners-Accountable Care IPA, INC REACHStandard, Global 7,191 11.5% 4.2% (2024)
Optimum NY Independent Practice Association, LLC REACHStandard, Professional 6,911 11.1% 12.0% (2024)
agilon health Northeastern ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 6) REACHStandard, Global 4,402 7.1% 16.5% (2024)
Honest ACO of New York LLC REACHStandard, Global 2,855 4.6% 9.6% (2024)
Medical Home Network Health Alliance II, LLC Shared SavingsBasic A 1,663 2.7% 2.4% (2024)
CINQCARE ACO REACH LLC REACHStandard, Global 963 1.5% 3.6% (2024)
Aledade 22 NC MSSP Enhanced Shared SavingsEnhanced 423 0.7% 9.4% (2024)
Collaborative ACO 30, LLC Shared SavingsEnhanced 365 0.6% 2.2% (2024)
Empire ACO LLC (ended) Shared SavingsBasic B 49 0.1% 7.9% (2024)
Rochester Regional Health ACO, Inc. (ended) Shared SavingsBasic A 47 0.1% −0.7% (2024)
Care Partners ACO, LLC Shared SavingsBasic E 16 0.0% 1.4% (2024)
BEST CARE COLLABORATIVE, LLC Shared SavingsEnhanced 11 0.0% 1.4% (2024)
Cleveland Clinic Medicare ACO, LLC Shared SavingsEnhanced 11 0.0% 4.5% (2024)
Bloom Health Network LLC (d/b/a Bloom Healthcare) REACHHigh Needs Population, Global 0 0.0% 28.4% (2024)
CenterWell Care Solutions, Inc. REACHStandard, Global 0 0.0% 12.8% (2024)
ilumed, LLC REACHStandard, Global 0 0.0% 2.6% (2024)
Provider Partners Connect Care, LLC REACHHigh Needs Population, Global 0 0.0% 12.4% (2024)
Accountable Care Organization of the North Country, LLC (ended) Shared SavingsBasic B 10 or fewer — −1.3% (2024)
Adirondacks ACO, LLC (ended) Shared SavingsBasic B 10 or fewer — 1.9% (2024)
AdvantagePoint Health Alliance - Laurel Highlands, LLC Shared SavingsBasic E 10 or fewer — 2.1% (2024)
Adventist Health Accountable Care, LLC Shared SavingsBasic B 10 or fewer — 2.6% (2024)
Advocate Health Enterprise ACO Shared SavingsEnhanced 10 or fewer — 3.9% (2024)
Aledade 101 Northeast MSSP Enhanced Shared SavingsEnhanced 10 or fewer — 3.1% (2024)
Aledade 102 NC TN CHC MSSP Enhanced Shared SavingsEnhanced 10 or fewer — 8.3% (2024)
Aledade 150 PACHC MSSP Enhanced Shared SavingsEnhanced 10 or fewer — 4.4% (2024)

The 25 ACOs with the most members here, of 162.

Traditional Medicare spending per member per month: 2023 $997 (risk 1.08); 2024 $1,112 (risk 1.08); 2025 $1,201 (risk 1.09).