Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
StatesCountiesPlan year changesRoom to growMedicaid

← OH · OH counties

Butler, OH

Medicare Advantage in this county: who has the members, how that changed in a year, and what CMS pays. Enrollment for November 2026.

i
How this is counted

Members and shares come from CMS's monthly enrollment by contract, plan and county, for every MA contract including Medicare-Medicaid plans. CMS hides any plan's county count of 10 or fewer, so they use the counts it shows (709 plans here are that small). Each contract counts under its current parent in both months.

Penetration is CMS's: MA enrollees (including cost plans and PACE) over all Medicare eligibles in the county.

The benchmark is CMS's monthly Parts A&B rate per member at a 1.0 risk score before any quality bonus; the 4-star bonus is the extra a plan rated 4 stars or more earns per member per month here.

55.5%
MA penetration
43,551 of 78,530 eligibles; −0.7 pts in a year
43,283
MA members
2.1% increase in a year
14
parent organizations
concentration 1,779
$1,247
benchmark 2027
5.2% on the year before; 4★ bonus $125 (10%)

Who has the members

Parent organizationMembersShareA year agoChangeShare of eligiblesContracts here
UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 11,441 26.4% 27.3% −0.8 pts 14.6% H5253 UnitedHealthcare 6,811; H2001 UnitedHealthcare 2,723; H1285 UnitedHealthcare Community Plan 1,045; H8768 UnitedHealthcare 627 +1 more
CVS Health Corporation 8,756 20.2% 18.1% +2.2 pts 11.1% H5522 Aetna Medicare 3,639; H5521 Aetna Medicare 3,391; H0628 Aetna Medicare 1,441; H3931 Aetna Medicare 285
Elevance Health, Inc. 7,705 17.8% 25.1% −7.3 pts 9.8% H3655 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 5,215; H4036 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 1,166; H2628 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 1,139; R5941 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield 185
Humana Inc. 7,352 17.0% 15.5% +1.5 pts 9.4% H6622 Humana 4,063; H5216 Humana 1,650; H7617 Humana 1,430; H5525 Humana 153 +2 more
Health Care Service Corporation 2,607 6.0% 1.6% +4.4 pts 3.3% H0672 HealthSpring 2,573; H7849 HealthSpring 34
Trinity Health Corporation 1,332 3.1% 2.0% +1.1 pts 1.7% H3668 MediGold 1,309; H1846 MediGold 23
MEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO 1,183 2.7% 4.8% −2.1 pts 1.5% H6723 Medical Mutual of Ohio 1,090; H4497 Medical Mutual of Ohio 93
Molina Healthcare, Inc. 978 2.3% 2.4% −0.1 pts 1.2% H9955 Molina Healthcare of Ohio 978
Devoted Health, Inc. 960 2.2% 1.7% +0.5 pts 1.2% H2697 Devoted Health 781; H2526 Devoted Health 179
CareSource 527 1.2% 0.4% +0.8 pts 0.7% H6396 CareSource MyCare Ohio (HMO D-SNP) 527
Centene Corporation 283 0.7% 0.9% −0.2 pts 0.4% H0908 Wellcare 264; H4158 Wellcare 19
Perennial Consortium, LLC 78 0.2% 0.1% +0.1 pts 0.1% H8797 Perennial Advantage 78
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Mutual Ins. Co. 45 0.1% 0.1% +0 pts 0.1% H9572 Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan 45
The Schroer Group, Inc. 36 0.1% 0.1% +0 pts 0.0% H1119 Valor Health Plan 36
Lumeris Group Holdings Corporation 0 — 0.0% — —

Penetration over time
i
January figures

January points (hollow) are CMS's early January count. CMS counts January before all of the new year's enrollments are processed, so January often reads low, sometimes below December, even though most plan changes take effect then. February's count catches up. The figures are shown as CMS published them.

Benchmarks

YearNo bonusWith 4★ bonusBonus
2025$1,082.21$1,190.43$108.22 (10%)
2026$1,185.29$1,303.82$118.53 (10%)
2027$1,246.84$1,371.52$124.68 (10%)

Monthly Parts A&B rate per member at a 1.0 risk score.

Plans on sale for 2027

58 plans for everyone from 10 organizations (median premium $0 a month, 62% at $0; median out-of-pocket maximum $6,650), and 27 special needs plans from 11 organizations. Compare every plan's benefits.

Traditional Medicare and ACOs

About 32,523 people here were in traditional Medicare in 2024, and 36% of them were in an accountable care organization.

i
How this is counted

Spending and risk score are CMS's figures for traditional Medicare beneficiaries who could be assigned to an ACO: aged and disabled people (ESRD apart) who had primary care in traditional Medicare during 2025. Spending is Parts A and B per person-year, shown per month; the risk score is CMS-HCC, weighted across enrollment types by person-years. People with no primary care visit aren't counted, so this is higher than traditional Medicare's average cost and isn't the base of the MA benchmark above.

In an ACO: Shared Savings Program assigned and ACO REACH aligned beneficiaries living here in 2024, over traditional Medicare enrollees (Medicare eligibles less MA enrollees, averaged over the year). That count includes people with Part A only, who can't be assigned, so the share is slightly understated. In a few small counties the two counts don't line up (more ACO members than the count of traditional Medicare enrollees); the share is left blank there. CMS hides an ACO's county count of 10 or fewer.

Source: CMS's Shared Savings Program county files and ACO REACH public use files on data.cms.gov.

$1,187
traditional Medicare spending per member per month, 2025
$1,133 at a 1.0 risk score
1.05
traditional Medicare risk score
3% dual eligible (aged)
36%
of traditional Medicare in an ACO, 2024
11,684 members; 7,242 Shared Savings, 4,442 REACH
17
ACOs with members here
largest: Esse Health ACO, LLC
ACOProgramTrackMembers here, 2024Share of traditional MedicareSavings rate (latest year)
Esse Health ACO, LLC REACHStandard, Global 4,116 12.7% 3.5% (2024)
Mercy Health Select, LLC Shared SavingsEnhanced 3,166 9.7% 6.4% (2024)
Kettering Physician Partners Accountable Care LLC Shared SavingsBasic E 2,669 8.2% 6.8% (2024)
Healthcare Solutions Network Shared SavingsBasic B 728 2.2% 3.5% (2024)
Health Centers of Ohio ACO LLC Shared SavingsBasic A 287 0.9% 0.8% (2024)
Aledade 157 OH MSSP Enhanced Shared SavingsEnhanced 209 0.6% 5.1% (2024)
Vytalize Health REACH, LLC REACHStandard, Global 197 0.6% 0.3% (2024)
Wellvana Premier Care, LLC (ended) REACHStandard, Global 66 0.2% 2.3% (2024)
VBLTC Shared SavingsBasic A 41 0.1% −1.2% (2024)
USMM ACCOUNTABLE CARE PARTNERS, LLC Shared SavingsEnhanced 40 0.1% 18.3% (2024)
PA MSSP Legacy + Gateway Enhanced (ended) Shared SavingsEnhanced 38 0.1% 16.6% (2024)
PBACO Holding, LLC Shared SavingsEnhanced 29 0.1% 8.9% (2024)
Prime Accountable Care East LLC (ended) REACHStandard, Global 26 0.1% 0.3% (2024)
Advanced Illness Partners, LLC REACHHigh Needs Population, Global 23 0.1% 12.1% (2024)
Caravan Collaborative Pathways Shared SavingsEnhanced 18 0.1% 4.0% (2024)
Sound Physicians Long Term Care Management, LLC Shared SavingsEnhanced 17 0.1% 20.9% (2024)
agilon health Ohio ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 3) REACHStandard, Global 14 0.0% 11.0% (2024)
CenterWell Care Solutions, Inc. REACHStandard, Global 0 0.0% 12.8% (2024)
Complete Care Collaborative of the Midwest REACHHigh Needs Population, Global 0 0.0% −2.3% (2024)
HarmonyCares ACO LLC REACHHigh Needs Population, Global 0 0.0% 29.4% (2024)
MNO REACH-MI LLC (ended) REACHStandard, Global 0 0.0% 1.5% (2024)
NeueHealth Community ACO, LLC REACHStandard, Global 0 0.0% 6.0% (2024)
Oak Street Health Medicare Partners LLC REACHStandard, Global 0 0.0% 18.7% (2024)
Pearl Primary Care Network, LLC REACHStandard, Professional 0 0.0% 0.6% (2024)
Subsero Healthcare, LLC d/b/a MAX Healthcare #1 REACHStandard, Global 0 0.0% 16.4% (2024)

The 25 ACOs with the most members here, of 113.

Traditional Medicare spending per member per month: 2023 $1,075 (risk 1.06); 2024 $1,121 (risk 1.06); 2025 $1,187 (risk 1.05).