Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in

Opportunities

Contracts ranked by their weighted stars on Health Outcomes Survey measures (lowest first), then by average percentile against other contracts.

Measures at 1–2★
i
Star outlook

Chance the rating at the 2028 release is lower (red) or higher (green) than today, from 400 simulated years recomputed with CMS's arithmetic and recalibrated against past outcomes. Below: the chance of 4★ or more, which carries the quality bonus. Method and backtest.

Flags
H3080 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 9,2662.4% 12% pctile 1 of 1−2 3.50 / — 3.5 3 17% 1 41% · 29%4★+ 19%
H9888 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 16,645310.8% 13% pctile 1 of 1−2 3.50 / — 3.5 3 29% 1 40% · 22%4★+ 14%
H6813 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 2,8640.1% 13% pctile 1 of 1−2 3.50 / — 3.5 3.5 21% 1 63% · 4%4★+ 4%
H9231 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 8,089114.1% 14% pctile 1 of 10 3.50 / — 3.5 3 34% 1 57% · 8%4★+ 6%
H1664 WellcareCentene Corporation 3,614−10.5% 17% pctile 1 of 1−1 30 / 0 3 3 46% 2 CMP 27% · 17%4★+ 4%
H4676 Troy MedicareTroy Holdings, Inc. 1,65413.9% 17% pctile 1 of 10 30 / +0.5 3 3 37% 1 12% · 22%4★+ 1%
H8845 Molina Healthcare of ArizonaMolina Healthcare, Inc. 1,90898.8% 17% pctile 1 of 1— —— / — — 2.5 74% —
H3499 WellcareCentene Corporation 4,608149.1% 17% pctile 1 of 10 30 / 0 3 3 36% 46% · 7%4★+ 1%
H4544 Peoples HealthUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 8,69919.2% 18% pctile 2 of 2−2 3+0.5 / 0 3 2.5 50% 42% · 2%4★+ 1%
H9431 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 666−48.8% 18% pctile 3 of 3−4 2.5−0.5 / −0.5 3 2 58% 1 CMP 20% · 30%4★+ 1%
H8173 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 12,33175.8% 19% pctile 2 of 2−3 4+0.5 / 0 4 4 9% 11 CMP 57% · 12%4★+ 41% · $5.6M at risk
H9955 Molina Healthcare of OhioMolina Healthcare, Inc. 15,8791186.8% 110% pctile 1 of 1−2 30 / 0 3 2.5 46% 1 CMP 36% · 6%4★+ 1%
H6018 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 8,578104.8% 110% pctile 1 of 10 3−0.5 / — 3 3 33% 1 19% · 30%4★+ 6%
H4661 WellcareCentene Corporation 3,924133.8% 113% pctile 1 of 1— 2.5— / — 2.5 2.5 65% 25% · 17%4★+ 1%
H4835 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 3,69440.6% 1.310% pctile 3 of 3−1 30 / 0 3 3.5 30% 1 CMP 14% · 41%4★+ 4%
H5435 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 1,420−13.4% 1.310% pctile 3 of 3+1 2.50 / −0.5 2.5 3 44% 6% · 62%4★+ 1%
R7220 HumanaHumana Inc. 2,90458.3% 1.312% pctile 3 of 30 3+0.5 / 0 3 3 37% 27% · 20%4★+ 1%
R4182 HumanaHumana Inc. 12,033−10.0% 1.316% pctile 3 of 3−4 3.50 / 0 3.5 3.5 21% 47% · 8%4★+ 6%
H2697 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 54,55186.1% 1.59% pctile 2 of 2−2 40 / −1 3.5 3 26% 11 CMP 59% · 9%4★+ 42% · $12.9M at risk
H3975 WellcareCentene Corporation 3,494−8.3% 1.514% pctile 2 of 2+1 30 / −0.5 3 3 48% 2 CMP 30% · 21%4★+ 3%
H4537 WellcareCentene Corporation 2,251−1.4% 1.518% pctile 2 of 2— 2.5— / — 2.5 2.5 69% 29% · 21%4★+ 1%
H7389 HealthSpringHealth Care Service Corporation 0−100.0% 1.520% pctile 2 of 2+1 2.50 / — 2.5 2.5 59% 3% · 76%4★+ 1% LPI
H6586 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 7,03347.3% 1.521% pctile 2 of 2−1 3.5+0.5 / — 3.5 3.5 22% 1 38% · 15%4★+ 10%
H6316 Healthy BlueElevance Health, Inc. 3,39141.5% 1.524% pctile 2 of 2— 2.5— / — 2.5 2.5 61% 19% · 38%4★+ 1% Sanctioned
H6158 Arkansas Blue MedicareUSAble Mutual Insurance Company 4,842−57.0% 1.714% pctile 4 of 5+1 2.5−0.5 / −1 3 3 42% 1 CMP 6% · 71%4★+ 1%
H6550 WellcareCentene Corporation 2,010−49.9% 1.717% pctile 2 of 3−1 2.5−0.5 / −0.5 2.5 2.5 54% 17% · 27%4★+ 1%
H2923 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 17,156469.2% 1.718% pctile 2 of 3−2 3−0.5 / — 3 3 38% 1 32% · 7%4★+ 1%
H6595 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 29,8033.5% 1.718% pctile 3 of 30 3−0.5 / −1 3 3 44% 1 17% · 23%4★+ 2%
H0029 WellcareCentene Corporation 31,55676.9% 1.718% pctile 2 of 3— 2.5— / — 2.5 3 52% 6% · 51%4★+ 2%
H0154 VIVA MedicareTriton Health Systems, L.L.C. 51,298−1.9% 1.718% pctile 5 of 5−6 4−0.5 / −1 4 4 16% 47% · 18%4★+ 57% · $15.7M at risk
H9699 Arkansas Blue MedicareUSAble Mutual Insurance Company 7,909277.2% 1.720% pctile 4 of 5−1 30 / −1 3.5 3.5 27% 1 CMP 12% · 53%4★+ 9%
H1862 WellcareCentene Corporation 12,758202.2% 1.721% pctile 2 of 30 2.5— / — 2.5 2.5 67% 20% · 27%4★+ 1%
H7917 BlueCross BlueShield of TennesseeBlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee 189,2677.2% 1.722% pctile 4 of 5−4 3.5−0.5 / −1 3.5 3.5 23% 1 CMP 17% · 55%4★+ 58% Lost 4★
H1215 WellcareCentene Corporation 2,84168.0% 1.723% pctile 2 of 30 2.5−0.5 / −0.5 2.5 2.5 59% 13% · 38%4★+ 1%
H3815 Alignment Health PlanAlignment Healthcare USA, LLC 227,07320.4% 1.728% pctile 3 of 5−8 3.5−0.5 / −0.5 3.5 3.5 18% 19% · 50%4★+ 54% Lost 4★
H2354 Health Alliance Plan by Henry Ford HealthHenry Ford Health System 88,27626.9% 1.730% pctile 3 of 5−3 40 / −0.5 3.5 4.5 9% 1 53% · 15%4★+ 50% · $20.5M at risk
H2563 Sentara MedicareSentara Health Care (SHC) 875−97.0% 1.733% pctile 3 of 5−1 3−0.5 / 0 2.5 4 34% 1 9% · 56%4★+ 11%
H6723 Medical Mutual of OhioMEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO 60,945−13.7% 1.825% pctile 3 of 5−5 3.5−0.5 / −1 3.5 4 15% 27% · 37%4★+ 32% Lost 4★
H2247 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 39,518−4.9% 1.828% pctile 3 of 5−1 3−0.5 / −1 3 3 38% 1 23% · 22%4★+ 2%
R0110 HumanaHumana Inc. 38,061−16.6% 1.828% pctile 3 of 5−4 3.50 / −1 3.5 4 17% 1 CMP 22% · 37%4★+ 33%
H0251 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 76,188−3.7% 1.829% pctile 4 of 50 3−0.5 / −1 3 3 47% 1 20% · 25%4★+ 6%
H1302 Blue Cross of IdahoGemstone Holdings, Inc. 3,795123.4% 1.917% pctile 5 of 5−2 —— / — 2.5 — 58% 16% · 49%4★+ 1%
R5941 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue ShieldElevance Health, Inc. 13,07782.1% 1.920% pctile 5 of 5−4 3.50 / 0 3.5 4.5 24% 22% · 33%4★+ 22% Sanctioned
H4982 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 9,288−51.1% 1.923% pctile 3 of 5−3 2.5−0.5 / −0.5 2.5 2.5 46% 1 CMP 13% · 39%4★+ 1% LPI
H3239 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 53,90240.8% 1.927% pctile 4 of 5−2 3.50 / −0.5 3.5 3 33% 1 CMP 31% · 16%4★+ 15%
H3748 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 4,321−44.8% 218% pctile 3 of 3−4 3.5+0.5 / 0 3.5 3.5 15% 1 CMP 64% · 8%4★+ 6%
H5628 Molina Healthcare of Utah & IdahoMolina Healthcare, Inc. 16,554−9.6% 218% pctile 1 of 1−1 30 / 0 3 3.5 26% 1 CMP 7% · 56%4★+ 8%
H9460 HealthSpringHealth Care Service Corporation 1,3251.6% 218% pctile 1 of 1−1 2.5−0.5 / −1 2 2.5 71% 1 54% · 3%4★+ 1%
H3668 MediGoldTrinity Health Corporation 58,57437.7% 219% pctile 5 of 50 3.5−1 / −1.5 3.5 4 18% 1 24% · 37%4★+ 32% Lost 4★
H2174 WellcareCentene Corporation 4,69392.9% 220% pctile 2 of 2+1 2.5−0.5 / −0.5 2.5 3 51% 12% · 40%4★+ 1%
Key
Sanctioned
CMS imposed an intermediate sanction (for example, a suspension of enrollment or marketing) or a termination in the last 3 years, and hasn't announced lifting it.
LPI
Low-performing icon: rated below 3 stars on its Part C or Part D summary for 3 years running. Medicare Plan Finder shows a warning, online enrollment is blocked, and members can switch to another plan mid-year.
Lost 4★
Overall rating fell below 4 stars this year after 4 or more last year, so the contract loses CMS's quality bonus payment.
Data ×N
N measures CMS reduced because it found problems with the contract's data ("CMS identified issues with this plan's data").
Sanction ded.
CMS took stars off the rating because the contract was under sanction.
Warn/ CAP · CMP
CMS warning letters and ad hoc corrective action plans, and civil money penalties, in the 2 years before the ratings came out. All CMS actions.

Click a column header to sort (headers with two or three labels sort by each value separately). Under Overall: change vs 1 and 3 years earlier.

Members = latest monthly enrollment loaded. Star changes compare to the contract's previous rated year.