Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in

Opportunities

Contracts ranked by their weighted stars on Pricing Accuracy measures (lowest first), then by average percentile against other contracts.

Measures at 1–2★
i
Star outlook

Chance the rating at the 2028 release is lower (red) or higher (green) than today, from 400 simulated years recomputed with CMS's arithmetic and recalibrated against past outcomes. Below: the chance of 4★ or more, which carries the quality bonus. Method and backtest.

Flags
H4676 Troy MedicareTroy Holdings, Inc. 1,65413.9% 10% pctile 1 of 1−1 30 / +0.5 3 3 37% 1 12% · 22%4★+ 1%
H2034 Community CareCareSource 310−37.1% 10% pctile 1 of 1−4 —— / — — 3 48% 2 —
R5826 HumanaHumana Inc. 4,456−12.0% 10% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / +0.5 3.5 4 16% 75% · 7%4★+ 32% · $2.8M at risk
H2463 HumanaHumana Inc. 4,303153.0% 10% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / 0 4 4 10% 58% · 17%4★+ 54% · $385K at risk
H7284 HumanaHumana Inc. 11,029−38.6% 10% pctile 1 of 10 3.50 / −0.5 3.5 3.5 12% 38% · 15%4★+ 10%
H1468 HumanaHumana Inc. 136,9375.1% 10% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / −0.5 4 4.5 12% 1 CMP 32% · 29%4★+ 78% · $16.6M at risk
H1019 CarePlus Health Plans, Inc.Humana Inc. 171,3817.5% 10% pctile 1 of 10 4−0.5 / 0 3 4.5 19% 40% · 25%4★+ 70% · $36.3M at risk
H1036 HumanaHumana Inc. 862,83633.4% 10% pctile 1 of 10 4.50 / −0.5 4.5 4 2% 1 CMP 46% · 2%4★+ 84% · $74.5M at risk
H1339 Johns Hopkins Advantage MDJohns Hopkins Healthcare LLC 601— 11% pctile 1 of 10 —— / — — — 20% —
H6622 HumanaHumana Inc. 331,6443.1% 12% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / 0 4 4 6% 1 CMP 31% · 30%4★+ 79% · $52.5M at risk
H4141 HumanaHumana Inc. 125,63643.8% 12% pctile 1 of 10 3.5−0.5 / −0.5 3.5 3.5 10% 1 CMP 11% · 53%4★+ 56% Lost 4★
R7220 HumanaHumana Inc. 2,90458.3% 12% pctile 1 of 10 3+0.5 / 0 3 3 37% 27% · 20%4★+ 1%
H5377 HumanaHumana Inc. 3,919377.3% 12% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / — 4 3.5 9% 66% · 6%4★+ 44% · $534K at risk
H5178 HumanaHumana Inc. 42232.3% 12% pctile 1 of 10 —— / — — 3.5 24% —
H0028 HumanaHumana Inc. 321,335−12.9% 12% pctile 1 of 10 4.5+1 / +0.5 4.5 4 4% 1 CMP 51% · 1%4★+ 81% · $45.7M at risk
H3533 HumanaHumana Inc. 28,35014.2% 13% pctile 1 of 10 30 / 0 3.5 3 39% 1 CMP 16% · 26%4★+ 3%
H5216 HumanaHumana Inc. 2,343,383−15.6% 13% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / −0.5 4 4 9% 1 CMP 42% · 11%4★+ 68% · $508M at risk
H5619 HumanaHumana Inc. 479,816−3.8% 13% pctile 1 of 10 4+1 / 0 4 4 7% 1 CMP 34% · 29%4★+ 76% · $79.6M at risk
H1951 HumanaHumana Inc. 195,09822.1% 13% pctile 1 of 10 4.50 / 0 4.5 4 5% 1 CMP 49% · 3%4★+ 83% · $19.1M at risk
R0110 HumanaHumana Inc. 38,061−16.6% 13% pctile 1 of 10 3.50 / −1 3.5 4 17% 1 CMP 22% · 37%4★+ 33%
H0473 HumanaHumana Inc. 16,154−4.8% 13% pctile 1 of 10 3−0.5 / −0.5 3 3.5 15% 7% · 48%4★+ 5%
R5361 HumanaHumana Inc. 5,4701.9% 13% pctile 1 of 10 3.5+0.5 / −0.5 3.5 3.5 24% 62% · 9%4★+ 6%
H5525 HumanaHumana Inc. 173,183−7.9% 13% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / 0 4 3.5 13% 1 CMP 44% · 15%4★+ 66% · $39.7M at risk
H8145 HumanaHumana Inc. 28,680−18.2% 13% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / 0 3.5 4 12% 58% · 7%4★+ 44% · $9.8M at risk
H5970 HumanaHumana Inc. 87,31059.4% 13% pctile 1 of 10 30 / −0.5 3.5 3 24% 17% · 29%4★+ 6%
H4461 HumanaHumana Inc. 395,777156.3% 13% pctile 1 of 10 4.5+0.5 / −0.5 4.5 4.5 8% 46% · 3%4★+ 84% · $15.5M at risk
H0292 HumanaHumana Inc. 10,67921.5% 15% pctile 1 of 10 4.5+0.5 / −0.5 4.5 5 7% 59% · 3%4★+ 67% · $2.1M at risk
H5209 Molina Healthcare of WisconsinMolina Healthcare, Inc. 2,91825.7% 15% pctile 1 of 1−4 3.5+0.5 / −0.5 3.5 3.5 20% 35% · 17%4★+ 13%
R4182 HumanaHumana Inc. 12,033−10.0% 15% pctile 1 of 10 3.50 / 0 3.5 3.5 21% 47% · 8%4★+ 6%
H2486 HumanaHumana Inc. 4,050−37.4% 15% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / +0.5 3.5 4 18% 79% · 5%4★+ 25% · $7.3M at risk
H4623 HumanaHumana Inc. 10,621−22.7% 15% pctile 1 of 10 4+0.5 / 0 4 4.5 11% 55% · 14%4★+ 44% · $4.4M at risk
H4286 Leon Health, Inc.LMC Family Holdings, LLC 40,7343.4% 16% pctile 1 of 1−3 50 / 0 5 4.5 1% 19% · 1%4★+ 99% · $282K at risk
R1532 HumanaHumana Inc. 3,639−20.8% 16% pctile 1 of 10 3.5+1 / +0.5 3.5 3.5 25% 44% · 20%4★+ 14%
H9808 HealthTeam AdvantageRisant Health, Inc. 19,13924.9% 16% pctile 1 of 1−2 3.5−1 / −0.5 4 3.5 15% 4 20% · 45%4★+ 30% Lost 4★
H8908 HumanaHumana Inc. 22,323−34.4% 16% pctile 1 of 10 3.5+0.5 / 0 3.5 3.5 19% 1 CMP 25% · 21%4★+ 19%
H1994 Select HealthIntermountain Health Care, Inc. 67,3641.2% 26% pctile 1 of 1−3 4−0.5 / −1 4 4.5 5% 3 45% · 20%4★+ 60% · $9.7M at risk
H6019 HEALTH PLAN OF SAN MATEOHealth Plan of San Mateo 8,469−0.1% 26% pctile 1 of 1−2 30 / — 3.5 3 31% 1 8% · 56%4★+ 6%
H2624 HealthTeam AdvantageRisant Health, Inc. 3,644−51.7% 26% pctile 1 of 1−1 4.50 / 0 4.5 4 6% 4 67% · 2%4★+ 68% · $533K at risk
H9690 American Health Advantage of IndianaMitchell Family Office 4836.4% 26% pctile 1 of 1— —— / — — 2.5 52% —
H5386 Sharp Health PlanSharp Healthcare 19,95713.6% 37% pctile 0 of 1−1 4+0.5 / −0.5 4 4.5 11% 48% · 22%4★+ 53% · $3.1M at risk
H2230 Blue Cross Blue Shield of MassachusettsBlue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc. 45,136−46.6% 37% pctile 0 of 1−2 4−0.5 / +0.5 4 4 11% 57% · 11%4★+ 45% · $16.6M at risk
H4937 Blue Shield of CaliforniaCalifornia Physicians' Service 46,966−0.9% 37% pctile 0 of 1−2 2.5−1 / −1 2.5 2.5 51% 4% · 64%4★+ 3%
H0034 Hamaspik, Inc.Hamaspik of Rockland County, Inc. 2,71473.8% 37% pctile 0 of 1+2 4+0.5 / — 4 4 15% 54% · 23%4★+ 60% · $693K at risk
H5932 Highmark Wholecare Medicare AssuredHighmark Health 40,3623.5% 37% pctile 0 of 1−1 3.5−0.5 / −1 3.5 3 23% 37% · 28%4★+ 25% Lost 4★
H1644 Longevity Health PlanLongevity Health Founders, LLC 804−11.1% 37% pctile 0 of 1−1 5— / +2 5 4 — 69% · 1%4★+ 92% · $106K at risk
H4213 Arkansas Blue MedicareUSAble Mutual Insurance Company 2,25826.4% 37% pctile 0 of 1−1 3−0.5 / −0.5 3.5 3 43% 1 CMP 7% · 55%4★+ 3%
H3924 Geisinger GoldRisant Health, Inc. 24,445−33.0% 37% pctile 0 of 1−2 4−0.5 / 0 4 4.5 8% 11 CMP 40% · 24%4★+ 66% · $7.3M at risk
H3890 Johns Hopkins Advantage MDJohns Hopkins Healthcare LLC 6,78717.7% 37% pctile 0 of 1−1 4+0.5 / +1 4 4 13% 57% · 12%4★+ 41% · $2.6M at risk
H4091 Simpra AdvantageAssociated Care Ventures, Inc. 3,55318.2% 37% pctile 0 of 1−1 —— / — — 3 31% 2 —
H3359 Healthfirst Medicare PlanHealthfirst, Inc. 361,89613.0% 37% pctile 0 of 1−1 3.5−1 / −0.5 3.5 4 20% 19% · 45%4★+ 49% Lost 4★
Key
Sanctioned
CMS imposed an intermediate sanction (for example, a suspension of enrollment or marketing) or a termination in the last 3 years, and hasn't announced lifting it.
LPI
Low-performing icon: rated below 3 stars on its Part C or Part D summary for 3 years running. Medicare Plan Finder shows a warning, online enrollment is blocked, and members can switch to another plan mid-year.
Lost 4★
Overall rating fell below 4 stars this year after 4 or more last year, so the contract loses CMS's quality bonus payment.
Data ×N
N measures CMS reduced because it found problems with the contract's data ("CMS identified issues with this plan's data").
Sanction ded.
CMS took stars off the rating because the contract was under sanction.
Warn/ CAP · CMP
CMS warning letters and ad hoc corrective action plans, and civil money penalties, in the 2 years before the ratings came out. All CMS actions.

Click a column header to sort (headers with two or three labels sort by each value separately). Under Overall: change vs 1 and 3 years earlier.

Members = latest monthly enrollment loaded. Star changes compare to the contract's previous rated year.