Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in

Opportunities

Contracts ranked by their weighted stars on Quality Improvement measures (lowest first), then by average percentile against other contracts.

Measures at 1–2★
i
Star outlook

Chance the rating at the 2028 release is lower (red) or higher (green) than today, from 400 simulated years recomputed with CMS's arithmetic and recalibrated against past outcomes. Below: the chance of 4★ or more, which carries the quality bonus. Method and backtest.

Flags
H9725 HealthSpringHealth Care Service Corporation 33,43816.9% 1— pctile 2 of 2−7 3−1 / −1.5 3 2.5 47% 1 28% · 15%4★+ 14% Lost 4★
H7779 American Health Advantage of TennesseeMitchell Family Office 297−33.3% 1— pctile 1 of 1−2 —— / — — 2.5 42% 1 —
H4808 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 12,20544.5% 1— pctile 2 of 2−3 3−1 / — 3 3 40% 1 38% · 7%4★+ 4% Lost 4★
H9686 Alignment Health PlanAlignment Healthcare USA, LLC 6,962236.8% 1— pctile 1 of 1−2 4−1 / +0.5 4 3.5 14% 73% · 1%4★+ 54% · $611K at risk
H4523 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 39,62421.9% 1— pctile 2 of 2−3 3−1 / −1 3.5 2.5 26% 1 CMP 19% · 27%4★+ 21% Lost 4★
H2272 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 10,63215.0% 1— pctile 1 of 1−2 3.5— / — 3.5 2.5 36% 60% · 13%4★+ 9%
H7379 CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield Medicare AdvantageCareFirst, Inc. 47,95779.8% 1— pctile 2 of 2−5 2.5−1.5 / −1 2.5 3 43% 1 9% · 55%4★+ 6% Lost 4★
H1846 MediGoldTrinity Health Corporation 5,911120.4% 1— pctile 2 of 2−5 3−1 / −1 3 3 29% 1 27% · 25%4★+ 16% Lost 4★
H4232 American Health Advantage of UtahMitchell Family Office 29654.2% 1— pctile 1 of 1−1 —— / — — 2 57% 1 —
H9690 American Health Advantage of IndianaMitchell Family Office 4836.4% 1— pctile 1 of 1— —— / — — 2.5 52% —
H8797 Perennial AdvantagePerennial Consortium, LLC 1,609112.3% 1— pctile 1 of 1−2 —— / — — 2.5 43% 1 —
H4661 WellcareCentene Corporation 3,924133.8% 1— pctile 1 of 1— 2.5— / — 2.5 2.5 65% 25% · 17%4★+ 1%
H8332 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 197−28.1% 1— pctile 1 of 1−2 —— / — — 2 58% 1 CMP —
H8166 Highmark Blue Cross Blue ShieldHighmark Health 4,056−74.4% 1— pctile 2 of 2−6 3−1 / −1 3 3 39% 1 CMP 50% · 5%4★+ 4% Lost 4★
H5163 Verda Health Plan of TexasVerda Healthcare, Inc. 3,88919.3% 1— pctile 1 of 1— 2— / — 1.5 2 81% 2 4% · 62%4★+ 1%
H4490 American Health Advantage of MissouriMitchell Family Office 83244.4% 1— pctile 1 of 1−1 —— / — — 2 50% 1 —
H0294 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 71,413−48.4% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−1 3−0.5 / −0.5 3 3 30% 11 CMP 25% · 14%4★+ 9%
H0543 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 248,919−20.5% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−7 3−1 / −0.5 3.5 3 30% 1 14% · 37%4★+ 35% Lost 4★
H0523 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 11,124−22.4% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−2 30 / 0 3 3 40% 1 CMP 40% · 8%4★+ 3%
H1109 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 1,80377.5% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−7 4−0.5 / 0 3.5 3 23% 1 CMP 62% · 18%4★+ 49% · $434K at risk
H6348 WellcareCentene Corporation 5,89049.3% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−4 2.5−0.5 / −0.5 2 2.5 59% 1 CMP 20% · 28%4★+ 1%
H9460 HealthSpringHealth Care Service Corporation 1,3251.6% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−4 2.5−0.5 / −1 2 2.5 71% 1 54% · 3%4★+ 1%
H0251 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 76,188−3.7% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−4 3−0.5 / −1 3 3 47% 1 20% · 25%4★+ 6%
H9431 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 666−48.8% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−2 2.5−0.5 / −0.5 3 2 58% 1 CMP 20% · 30%4★+ 1%
H1360 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 2,231−35.9% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−3 30 / −0.5 3 3 34% 1 49% · 5%4★+ 2%
H2686 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 10,98341.7% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−3 3−0.5 / — 3 3 36% 1 29% · 17%4★+ 6%
H3706 GlobalHealthMHH Healthcare, L.P. 19,64316.4% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−4 3.5−0.5 / −1 4 2.5 32% 42% · 40%4★+ 26% Lost 4★
H8176 Molina Healthcare of South CarolinaMolina Healthcare, Inc. 3,128191.0% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−7 2.5−1 / −1 3 2 41% 1 CMP 7% · 66%4★+ 5%
H8604 The Health PlanThe Health Plan of West Virginia, Inc. 7,183130.0% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−2 3−0.5 / −1 3.5 3 31% 26% · 22%4★+ 10%
H7147 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 9,37942.2% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−2 40 / — 3.5 3 32% 1 76% · 5%4★+ 20% · $2.3M at risk
H3384 Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield or Highmark Blue ShieldHighmark Health 22,566−50.5% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−5 40 / 0 3.5 3.5 22% 11 CMP 59% · 9%4★+ 42% · $14.9M at risk
H5471 Simply Healthcare Plans, Inc.Elevance Health, Inc. 31,554−36.5% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−7 4−0.5 / −1 3.5 3 22% 1 CMP 53% · 12%4★+ 49% · $20.2M at risk Sanctioned
H5296 Alignment Health PlanAlignment Healthcare USA, LLC 34,03955.5% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−3 4.5−0.5 / −0.5 3.5 3.5 20% 53% · 4%4★+ 74% · $771K at risk
H5299 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 17,745363.7% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−2 4.5−0.5 / — 4 3 25% 1 56% · 7%4★+ 70% · $342K at risk
H5325 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 18,860−10.6% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−1 3−0.5 / −1 3.5 2.5 38% 1 CMP 28% · 16%4★+ 5%
H1278 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc. 135,992−29.5% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−5 3−0.5 / −0.5 3 3 40% 11 CMP 26% · 14%4★+ 13%
H5533 UPMC for LifeUPMC Health System 58,457−9.7% 1.5— pctile 2 of 2−4 4.50 / −0.5 4 3.5 22% 69% · 1%4★+ 53% · $8.5M at risk
H1619 Jefferson Health PlansThomas Jefferson University 4,175133.8% 2— pctile 1 of 1— 3— / — 3.5 3 30% 31% · 24%4★+ 6%
H4537 WellcareCentene Corporation 2,251−1.4% 2— pctile 1 of 1−1 2.5— / — 2.5 2.5 69% 29% · 21%4★+ 1%
H2752 HealthSpringHealth Care Service Corporation 332−29.7% 2— pctile 1 of 1— —— / — — 2.5 65% 1 —
H1526 Gold Kidney Health PlanGold Kidney Health Plan 3,05881.3% 2— pctile 1 of 1— 2.5— / — 2.5 2.5 64% 1 20% · 40%4★+ 1%
H4093 Provider Partners Health PlansRifkin Managed Care Holding, LLC 8608.3% 2— pctile 1 of 1−3 3.5−1.5 / — 5 2.5 36% 35% · 40%4★+ 29% Lost 4★
H1609 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 121,173−8.0% 2— pctile 1 of 2−3 4−0.5 / 0 4 3 14% 1 CMP 39% · 19%4★+ 71% · $29.5M at risk
H2697 Devoted HealthDevoted Health, Inc. 54,55186.1% 2— pctile 2 of 20 40 / −1 3.5 3 26% 11 CMP 59% · 9%4★+ 42% · $12.9M at risk
H4407 HealthSpringHealth Care Service Corporation 14,55112.1% 2— pctile 2 of 2−3 40 / 0 3.5 3.5 25% 1 59% · 14%4★+ 39% · $4.3M at risk
H4733 Community Health GroupCommunity Health Group 10,36212.6% 2— pctile 2 of 2−5 2.5−1 / — 3 3 58% 4% · 59%4★+ 2%
H2034 Community CareCareSource 310−37.1% 2— pctile 1 of 1−1 —— / — — 3 48% 2 —
H1215 WellcareCentene Corporation 2,84168.0% 2— pctile 2 of 2−2 2.5−0.5 / −0.5 2.5 2.5 59% 13% · 38%4★+ 1%
H2056 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation 8,2754.0% 2— pctile 2 of 2−1 30 / 0 3 2.5 48% 1 CMP 44% · 4%4★+ 1%
H3810 AllCare AdvantageAllCare Health, Inc. 2,485−3.7% 2— pctile 1 of 20 2.50 / −1 2.5 2.5 65% 4 16% · 43%4★+ 1%
Key
Sanctioned
CMS imposed an intermediate sanction (for example, a suspension of enrollment or marketing) or a termination in the last 3 years, and hasn't announced lifting it.
LPI
Low-performing icon: rated below 3 stars on its Part C or Part D summary for 3 years running. Medicare Plan Finder shows a warning, online enrollment is blocked, and members can switch to another plan mid-year.
Lost 4★
Overall rating fell below 4 stars this year after 4 or more last year, so the contract loses CMS's quality bonus payment.
Data ×N
N measures CMS reduced because it found problems with the contract's data ("CMS identified issues with this plan's data").
Sanction ded.
CMS took stars off the rating because the contract was under sanction.
Warn/ CAP · CMP
CMS warning letters and ad hoc corrective action plans, and civil money penalties, in the 2 years before the ratings came out. All CMS actions.

Click a column header to sort (headers with two or three labels sort by each value separately). Under Overall: change vs 1 and 3 years earlier.

Members = latest monthly enrollment loaded. Star changes compare to the contract's previous rated year.