Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in

Opportunities

Contracts ranked by their weighted stars on Source: Call Center Monitoring measures (lowest first), then by average percentile against other contracts.

Measures at 1–2★ Outlook Flags
H2225 Commonwealth Care Alliance MassachusettsCareSource 19,38513.2% 10% pctile 2 of 2−6 4−0.5 / −0.5 4 4 5% —
H1035 Florida Blue HMOGuidewell Mutual Holding Corporation 46,087−27.9% 10% pctile 2 of 2−6 4−0.5 / −0.5 3.5 4.5 20% —
H2773 Quality Health Plans Of New York, Inc.QHP Financial Group, Inc. —— 1.51% pctile 2 of 2−3 2.5— / — 2.5 2.5 56% —
H5989 Healthfirst Medicare PlanHealthfirst, Inc. 12,756−62.8% 1.51% pctile 2 of 20 4— / — 3.5 4 24% —
H6723 Medical Mutual of OhioMEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO 60,945−13.7% 21% pctile 2 of 20 3.5— / — 3 3.5 20% 11 CMP —
H4497 Medical Mutual of OhioMEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO 12,280−18.9% 21% pctile 2 of 20 3.5— / — 3 3.5 13% 11 CMP —
H6864 Guildnet, Inc.Jewish Guild for the Blind —— 21% pctile 2 of 2+1 3.5— / — 3.5 4 28% 1 —
H5211 Security Health Plan of Wisconsin, Inc.Sanford Health 79,28911.2% 2.52% pctile 1 of 2−4 4.50 / 0 4.5 4.5 12% —
H8237 Insurance Company Of Scott And WhiteBaylor Scott & White Holdings —— 2.52% pctile 1 of 2+1 3.5+0.5 / — 4 3 25% 1 —
H1189 CHRISTUS Health AdvantageCHRISTUS Health 8,87523.6% 2.52% pctile 1 of 2+3 —— / — — — 35% 21 CMP —
H9877 Virginia PremierSentara Health Care (SHC) —— 2.53% pctile 1 of 2— —— / — — — 50% —
H5992 Senior Whole Health of New YorkMolina Healthcare, Inc. 1,578130.4% 32% pctile 0 of 2+2 —— / — — — 59% 1 —
H3706 GlobalHealthMHH Healthcare, L.P. 19,64316.4% 33% pctile 0 of 2−1 3.50 / 0 3.5 3 27% 1 —
H2241 Golden StateMacArthur Court Acquisition Corp —— 33% pctile 0 of 20 30 / — 3 3 37% —
H3923 Capital Blue CrossCAPITAL BLUE CROSS 42,31850.0% 34% pctile 0 of 2−3 3.5−0.5 / 0 3.5 4 8% — Lost 4★
H3962 Capital Blue CrossCAPITAL BLUE CROSS 8,23816.8% 34% pctile 0 of 2−3 40 / 0 3.5 4.5 3% —
H9001 Fallon HealthFallon Community Health Plan, Inc. 11,737−0.5% 34% pctile 0 of 2+2 4.50 / 0 4.5 4 5% 2 CMP —
H3054 Constellation Health, Llc.Constellation Health, LLC. —— 35% pctile 0 of 2+2 3.5+1 / — 3 4.5 37% —
H8266 Constellation Health, Llc.Constellation Health, LLC. —— 35% pctile 0 of 2+2 3.5+0.5 / — 3 4 45% —
H4876 Constellation Health, Llc.Constellation Health, LLC. —— 35% pctile 0 of 2+2 —— / — — 4 35% —
H6988 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield HPElevance Health, Inc. 10,164243.7% 35% pctile 0 of 2−1 2— / — 2 2 73% — Sanctioned
H9302 Premera Blue Cross Medicare AdvantagePremera —— 36% pctile 0 of 2−1 3.50 / 0 3.5 3.5 22% —
H3811 Samaritan Advantage Health PlansSamaritan Health Services, Inc. 1,371−90.1% 3.56% pctile 0 of 2+2 3.50 / 0 4 3.5 18% —
H8170 America's 1st Choice Of South Carolina, Inc.Anthem Inc. —— 3.56% pctile 0 of 2−2 —— / — — — 60% —
H1587 Arkansas Superior Select Health PlansSelect Founders, LLC 2,83311.5% 3.56% pctile 0 of 2−2 —— / — — — 50% —
H3708 American Health Advantage of OklahomaMitchell Family Office 54945.6% 3.56% pctile 0 of 2−2 —— / — — — 22% —
H9403 Clear Spring HealthGroup 1001 —— 3.57% pctile 0 of 2— —— / — — — — —
H6672 Clear Spring HealthGroup 1001 —— 3.57% pctile 0 of 2— —— / — — — — —
H9589 Clear Spring HealthGroup 1001 —— 3.57% pctile 0 of 2— —— / — — — — —
H2334 Clear Spring HealthGroup 1001 —— 3.57% pctile 0 of 2— —— / — — — — —
H9190 Gateway Health Plan Of Ohio, Inc.Gateway Health Plan, LP —— 3.58% pctile 0 of 2+1 2.50 / — 2.5 2.5 57% —
H1777 ArchCare AdvantageCatholic Health Care System —— 3.58% pctile 0 of 2+3 3.50 / — 4 3.5 18% —
H3071 Clear Spring HealthGroup 1001 —— 3.59% pctile 0 of 20 2.50 / — 2 3 61% —
H5431 HealthSun Health Plans, Inc.Elevance Health, Inc. 68,8638.5% 3.510% pctile 0 of 2+1 5+0.5 / +1 4.5 5 5% — Sanctioned
H2417 Itasca Medical Care/IMCare ClassicItasca County 3568.5% 3.510% pctile 0 of 2+2 —— / — — 4.5 5% —
H1352 Blue Medicare AdvantageBlue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City —— 3.510% pctile 0 of 20 3— / — 3.5 3.5 33% —
H5608 Elevate Medicare AdvantageDenver Health and Hospital Authority 5,1020.7% 3.511% pctile 0 of 2−1 3.50 / 0 3.5 3.5 26% —
H9312 Fresenius Health Plans Insurance CompanyFresenius Medicare Care AG & Co. KGaA —— 3.512% pctile 0 of 2−1 —— / — — — 33% —
H1343 Fresenius Health Plans Of Texas, Inc.Fresenius Medicare Care AG & Co. KGaA —— 3.514% pctile 0 of 2— —— / — — — — —
H6320 Fresenius Health Plans Of North Carolina, Inc.Fresenius Medicare Care AG & Co. KGaA —— 3.521% pctile 0 of 2−1 —— / — — — 12% —
H3262 Fresenius Health Plans Of New York, Inc.Fresenius Medicare Care AG & Co. KGaA —— 3.521% pctile 0 of 2— —— / — — — — —
H5932 Highmark Wholecare Medicare AssuredHighmark Health 40,3623.5% 48% pctile 0 of 20 3.50 / +1 3.5 3.5 31% —
H9208 Riverlink HealthCatholic Health Initiatives —— 48% pctile 0 of 20 3−1 / — 3.5 3 27% — Lost 4★
H3765 Heartlandplains HealthCatholic Health Initiatives —— 49% pctile 0 of 2+1 3— / — 3 3.5 36% —
H6947 Qualchoice AdvantageCatholic Health Initiatives —— 49% pctile 0 of 20 2.5— / — 2.5 3 65% —
H5928 Blue Shield of CaliforniaCalifornia Physicians' Service 7,508−17.7% 49% pctile 0 of 2−2 3.5−0.5 / 0 3.5 4 20% 1 — Lost 4★
H5580 Mercy Care AdvantageMercy Care 10,9651.0% 49% pctile 0 of 20 3.50 / +0.5 3.5 3.5 23% —
H5549 VNS Health MedicareVisiting Nurse Service of New York 74,84596.6% 410% pctile 0 of 2−2 30 / 0 2.5 3.5 33% —
H8554 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of OK, TXHealth Care Service Corporation 775−14.6% 411% pctile 0 of 2+2 30 / — 3 3 30% 1 CMP —
H5991 EmblemHealthEmblemHealth, Inc. 2,285−1.8% 411% pctile 0 of 2+1 2.5−0.5 / −1 2.5 3 50% 1 CMP —
Key
Sanctioned
CMS imposed an intermediate sanction (for example, a suspension of enrollment or marketing) or a termination in the last 3 years, and hasn't announced lifting it.
LPI
Low-performing icon: rated below 3 stars on its Part C or Part D summary for 3 years running. Medicare Plan Finder shows a warning, online enrollment is blocked, and members can switch to another plan mid-year.
Lost 4★
Overall rating fell below 4 stars this year after 4 or more last year, so the contract loses CMS's quality bonus payment.
Data ×N
N measures CMS reduced because it found problems with the contract's data ("CMS identified issues with this plan's data").
Sanction ded.
CMS took stars off the rating because the contract was under sanction.
Warn/ CAP · CMP
CMS warning letters and ad hoc corrective action plans, and civil money penalties, in the 2 years before the ratings came out. All CMS actions.

Click a column header to sort (headers with two or three labels sort by each value separately). Under Overall: change vs 1 and 3 years earlier.

Members = latest monthly enrollment loaded. Star changes compare to the contract's previous rated year.