Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
All organizationsMedicare AdvantageDuals & special needsPart DMedicaidACOsPACEPublic companies

← Medicaid managed care

CareSource

Medicaid comprehensive managed care, July 2024. Medicare Advantage parent page.

i
Where these figures come from

Source: CMS's Medicaid Managed Care Enrollment and Program Characteristics report, its table of enrollment by program and plan. Each state reports how many people each plan had enrolled on July 1. CMS publishes the table about 19 months later, so July 2024 is the newest.

What's counted: comprehensive managed care plans, including those that also cover long-term services and supports. Dental-only, behavioral-health-only, transportation, PACE and primary care case management programs are listed on plan pages but left out of the totals. So are dental and pharmacy vendors that some states list inside a comprehensive program. Each person in a comprehensive program has one plan, so plan counts add up within a state.

Parent organization: each plan is matched to its parent by its brand and the parent the state reports. Where the parent also runs Medicare Advantage plans, it carries the name CMS uses for it in MA, so the two lines of business line up. Parents with no MA plans are named for the company or public agency that runs the plan.

Gaps: a state may report a count of 10 or fewer as 0, and some states leave dual-eligible counts blank. A plan's members reflect that state's own July count, not an audited figure.

1,762,958
Medicaid members, #8 nationally (2.6%)
−15.7%
against July 2023
6
states, 9 plans
99%
of its Medicaid + MA members are Medicaid (20,867 in MA)
i
Medicaid share of members

Medicaid comprehensive plan members ÷ (those members + the parent's Medicare Advantage members), both in July 2024. A dual-eligible person in both a Medicaid plan and an MA plan of the same parent counts twice. Shown beside the parent's MA figures, not added to them: Medicaid is a separate line of business, paid by states on different terms.

67,716
dual-eligible Medicaid members (also on Medicare)

Members by year

JulyMembersChangeNational shareRankStates
20222,056,326—2.8%86
20232,090,728+1.7%2.7%86
20241,762,958−15.7%2.6%86

Many states' Medicaid rolls fell from 2023 as the pandemic's continuous-coverage rule ended and states rechecked eligibility.

By state

StateMembersShare of stateState's membersDual eligiblePlans
Ohio1,209,27844%2,718,81551,0732
Georgia378,13524%1,594,09502
Indiana154,76510%1,608,9935602
Massachusetts16,5232%903,79515,6771
Arkansas3,9238%47,869721
New York3340%4,751,4303341

How its plans did, 2024 program reports

82.7%
medical loss ratio, weighted by members (9 of 11 plans reported one)
8
appeals resolved per 1,000 members; 29% decided for the member
952
state fair hearings requested, 97 decided for the member
16
state penalties ($6.1M) and 28 other compliance actions in 5 states

By plan
i
Where these figures come from

Source: each state's Managed Care Program Annual Report (MCPAR), which CMS publishes as one file per year. The 2024 reports cover each state's own contract year: a calendar year, July to June, October to September or another span ending in 2024 or early 2025. CMS posted them in spring 2026. CMS file (CSV).

Members: the plan's enrollment as the state reported it in the report, usually near the end of the period. It can differ from the July 1 count above.

MLR: the medical loss ratio the state reported for the plan, the share of premium revenue spent on care and quality improvement. Most states report it per plan and program; some report one figure for all the plan's programs or by region, marked under the figure. The MLR's own period can be a year or two before the report's. Left blank where the state reported 0, N/A or a figure outside 50–150%, which isn't a ratio.

Appeals per 1,000: appeals the plan resolved in the period ÷ the reported members × 1,000. Decided for member: appeals resolved wholly or partly in the member's favor ÷ appeals resolved, for plans that reported outcomes.

Fair hearings: requests for a state fair hearing (the step after the plan's own appeal) filed, and those decided for the member. Grievances per 1,000: complaints resolved ÷ members × 1,000.

Gaps: states define and count these their own way, so compare plans within a state more readily than across states. The figures aren't audited.

StatePlanProgram MembersMLRAppealsper 1,000Decided for member Fair hearingsfiled · for memberGrievancesper 1,000State actions
Arkansas CareSource PASSE Arkansas Provider Led Shared Savings Entity (PASSE)Jan 2024–Dec 2024 3,770 94.8%all programs 153.3578 resolved — 2 · 0 6.1 —
Georgia CareSource Georgia Georgia FamiliesJul 2023–Jun 2024 350,883 88.5% 3.11,094 resolved 35% 42 · 1 1.2 6
Georgia CareSource Georgia Planning for Healthy BabiesJul 2023–Jun 2024 17,635 71.2% 0.24 resolved 25% 0 · 0 0.9 —
Georgia CareSource Georgia Georgia PathwaysJul 2023–Jun 2024 769 — 10.48 resolved 50% 0 · 0 1.3 2
Indiana CareSource Healthy Indiana PlanJan 2024–Dec 2024 82,490 90.0% 13.41,109 resolved 22% 2 · 0 53.7 4
Indiana CareSource Hoosier HealthwiseJan 2024–Dec 2024 73,774 90.6% 2.8210 resolved 28% 0 · 0 31 4
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance One Care One Care Medicare Medicaid PlanJan 2024–Dec 2024 29,710 — 83.42,479 resolved 44% 17 · 2 151.8 7
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCO Senior Care Options (SCO)Jan 2024–Dec 2024 16,775 98.0% 59.3994 resolved 41% 6 · 0 154 9
New York Elderserve Health, Inc., dba RiverSpring at Home Medicaid Advantage Plus (MAP)Apr 2024–Mar 2025 478 106.0% 37.718 resolved 28% 22 · 3 154.8 1
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc. Ohio Medicaid Managed CareJul 2023–Jun 2024 1,271,667 80.0% 6.17,812 resolved 21% 825 · 84 6.2 7
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc. MyCare Ohio 12/27/2024Jul 2023–Jun 2024 33,646 87.0% 24.3816 resolved 52% 36 · 7 60.6 3

Comprehensive plans only. Each state reports for its own contract year, shown under the program. Figures are as the state reported them; a dash means it wrote N/A, NR or nothing.

State compliance actions
i
State compliance actions

Every compliance action the state took against a plan in the 2024 reporting period, as listed in the sanctions section of its program annual report, across all the state's managed care programs, not only comprehensive ones.

Penalties are fines, civil money penalties, liquidated damages and capitation the state withheld. Corrective action plans and notices (compliance letters, warnings) usually carry no dollar amount. The category follows the type the state chose and its own description. Overpayments the state recouped are listed separately: they're money owed back, not a penalty.

These are state actions, separate from CMS's own compliance actions against Medicare Advantage contracts. A state may list an action taken in an earlier year if it was still open, so the same action can appear in two years' reports.

16 penalties ($6.1M), 12 corrective action plans, 16 notices or other actions.

StatePlanActionTopic and reason AmountAssessedRemediatedSource
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.Ohio Medicaid Managed Care FinePenalty HEDIS/CAHPS requirements: Failure to meet quality measure minimum performance standards2 instances $5,909,940 Mar 22, 2024 YesNov 20, 2024 CMS file
New York Elderserve Health (dba RiverSpring)Managed Long Term Care Partial Cap (MLTC) FinePenalty Reporting (timeliness, completeness, accuracy): Plan did not submit timely encounter data1 instance $121,559 Dec 12, 2024 In progress CMS file
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.MyCare Ohio 12/27/2024 FinePenalty Implementation of Rate Changes: Failure to meet rate loading requirement1 instance $25,000 Apr 9, 2024 YesJun 21, 2024 CMS file
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.Ohio Medicaid Managed Care FinePenalty Implementation of Rate Changes: Failure to meet the requirements in loading rates timely1 instance $25,000 Apr 9, 2024 YesJun 20, 2024 CMS file
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.Ohio Medicaid Managed Care FinePenalty Delegation requirements: Failure to meet FDR submission timeframes2 instances $16,900 Apr 4, 2024 YesMay 15, 2024 CMS file
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.Ohio Medicaid Managed Care FinePenalty Network adequacy standards: Failure to meet provider panel requirements9 instances $9,000 Dec 4, 2023 YesDec 21, 2023 CMS file
New York Elderserve Health, Inc., dba RiverSpring at HomeMedicaid Advantage Plus (MAP) FinePenalty Reporting (timeliness, completeness, accuracy): Plan did not submit timely encounter data1 instance $6,767 Dec 12, 2024 In progress CMS file
Indiana CareSourceHoosier Healthwise Liquidated damagesPenalty Reporting: MCE did not meet contract standards for appeals in the Q3 2024 priority reports1 instance $5,460 Dec 28, 2024 YesJan 6, 2025 CMS file
Indiana CareSourceHealthy Indiana Plan Liquidated damagesPenalty Reporting: MCE did not meet contract standards for appeals in the Q3 2024 priority reports1 instance $5,460 Dec 28, 2024 YesJan 6, 2025 CMS file
Indiana CareSourceHealthy Indiana Plan Liquidated damagesPenalty Reporting: MCE did not meet contract standards for appeals in the Q2 2024 priority reports1 instance $4,620 Sep 6, 2024 YesSep 13, 2024 CMS file
Indiana CareSourceHoosier Healthwise Liquidated damagesPenalty Reporting: MCE did not meet contract standards for appeals in the Q2 2024 priority reports1 instance $4,620 Sep 6, 2024 YesSep 13, 2024 CMS file
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.Ohio Medicaid Managed Care FinePenalty late deliverable/s: Failure to submit deliverables timely6 instances $2,500 Dec 6, 2023 YesDec 22, 2023 CMS file
Indiana CareSourceHoosier Healthwise Liquidated damagesPenalty Reporting: MCE did not meet metric standards for appeals and grievances in the Q1 2024 priority reports1 instance $2,310 Jun 3, 2024 YesJun 11, 2024 CMS file
Indiana CareSourceHealthy Indiana Plan Liquidated damagesPenalty Reporting: MCE did not meet metric standards for appeals and grievances in the Q1 2024 priority reports1 instance $2,310 Jun 3, 2024 YesJun 11, 2024 CMS file
Indiana CareSourceHoosier Healthwise Liquidated damagesPenalty
Contract noncompliance: MCE received a notice of noncompliance for responding late to internet quorum (IQ)...MCE received a notice of noncompliance for responding late to internet quorum (IQ) inquiries for February 2024, which is not permitted by their contract.
1 instance
$400 Mar 13, 2024 YesMar 27, 2024 CMS file
Indiana CareSourceHealthy Indiana Plan Liquidated damagesPenalty
Contract noncompliance: MCE received a notice of noncompliance for responding late to internet quorum (IQ)...MCE received a notice of noncompliance for responding late to internet quorum (IQ) inquiries for February 2024, which is not permitted by their contract.
1 instance
$400 Mar 13, 2024 YesMar 27, 2024 CMS file
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.Ohio Medicaid Managed Care Corrective action planCorrective action plan Financial issues: Failure to meet claims adjudication and Payment processing requirements2 instances — May 29, 2024 YesAug 23, 2024 CMS file
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.MyCare Ohio 12/27/2024 Corrective action planCorrective action plan Performance improvement: Failure to meet Comprehensive Adjustment Review requirements (pending)16 instances — Apr 29, 2024 YesNov 26, 2024 CMS file
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.Ohio Medicaid Managed Care Corrective action planCorrective action plan Performance improvement: Comprehensive administrative review findings13 instances — Apr 29, 2024 YesAug 30, 2024 CMS file
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaGeorgia Families Corrective action planCorrective action plan Reporting: Background Check Report Tab 2 "Licensed Employee & Attestations" is not dated. Was also missing on the original submission1 instance — Apr 4, 2024 YesMay 7, 2024 CMS file
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaGeorgia Pathways Corrective action planCorrective action plan
Reporting: Georgia Pathways report contain incorrect data. "As indicated in the email below, for...Georgia Pathways report contain incorrect data. "As indicated in the email below, for the December 2023 reporting period, Tabs 6-8 for suspended members should reflect 0. Tabs 6-8 are to be filled out with data on outreach to non-compliant members for the January 2024 reporting period with first report due on February 15, 2024. These Tabs should not be filled out for this reporting period.
1 instance
— Mar 22, 2024 YesApr 25, 2024 CMS file
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaGeorgia Pathways Corrective action planCorrective action plan
Reporting: Georgia Pathways report contained incorrect data.In reviewing the CareSource report...Georgia Pathways report contained incorrect data.In reviewing the CareSource report for the January 2024 reporting period (as indicated below) CareSource submitted an incorrect report as it relates to Tabs 1-4. For the December 2023 reporting period, CareSource submitted a report that was also incorrect as it relates to Tabs 1-4.
1 instance
— Feb 16, 2024 YesMar 28, 2024 CMS file
Ohio CareSource Ohio, Inc.MyCare Ohio 12/27/2024 Corrective action planCorrective action plan Performance improvement: Failure to meet Transportation requirements1 instance — Jan 3, 2024 YesMar 7, 2024 CMS file
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaGeorgia Families Corrective action planCorrective action plan Reporting: Prompt Pay Reports (Prompt Pay Report, Prompt Pay Cover Letter and Prompt Pay Affidavit) were submitted 2 days late.1 instance — Oct 20, 2023 YesJan 29, 2024 CMS file
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaGeorgia Families Corrective action planCorrective action plan
Reporting: The February and March 2023 reports were found to have identical information on all...The February and March 2023 reports were found to have identical information on all three tabs. These reports also both had February data on the TPL COB Tab and March data on the TPL Subro-Recovery tab and Cost Avoidance tab.
1 instance
— Oct 6, 2023 YesJan 29, 2024 CMS file
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaGeorgia Families Corrective action planCorrective action plan
Reporting: Claims Processing Report was submitted with incorrect data. "The original report...Claims Processing Report was submitted with incorrect data. "The original report submission was excluding values for top five denials reasons (medical and behavioral health) and included some unexpected negative record counts".
1 instance
— Oct 6, 2023 YesJan 29, 2024 CMS file
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaGeorgia Families Corrective action planCorrective action plan Reporting: ER Monitoring Report was submitted with insufficient data relating to the submission of appeals.10 instances — Oct 6, 2023 YesJan 30, 2024 CMS file
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaGeorgia Families Corrective action planCorrective action plan
Reporting: TPL COB Cost Avoidance Report was submitted with incorrect data.None of the effective...TPL COB Cost Avoidance Report was submitted with incorrect data.None of the effective dates of coverage or termination dates were populated for the TPL COB tab. Potential issues with the carrier codes formats were identified, particularly "PAID" values associated with one provider.
1 instance
— Oct 6, 2023 YesJan 2, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance One CareOne Care Medicare Medicaid Plan Compliance letterNotice or other Marketing: Failure to update Member ID Cards when the Claims billing address changed.1 instance — Oct 31, 2024 YesOct 31, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCOSenior Care Options (SCO) Compliance letterNotice or other Marketing: Failure to update Member ID Cards when the Claims billing address changed.1 instance — Oct 31, 2024 YesOct 31, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCOSenior Care Options (SCO) Compliance letterNotice or other Marketing: Pervasive failure to adhere to marketing and communication materials guidelines.1 instance — Oct 31, 2024 YesOct 31, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance One CareOne Care Medicare Medicaid Plan Enrollment cessation, marketing cessation, corrective...Notice or other Financial issues: Noncompliance with contract requirement to maintain adequate protection against insolvency for CY2024 Q1 and CY2024 Q21 instance — Oct 16, 2024 YesApr 14, 2025 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCOSenior Care Options (SCO) Enrollment cessation, marketing cessation, corrective...Notice or other Financial issues: Noncompliance with contract requirement to maintain adequate protection against insolvency for CY2024 Q1 and CY2024 Q21 instance — Oct 16, 2024 YesApr 14, 2025 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCOSenior Care Options (SCO) Compliance letterNotice or other
Benefit Administration: CCA failed to implement processes and policies for determining a chronically ill...CCA failed to implement processes and policies for determining a chronically ill enrollee's eligibility prior to administering special supplemental benefits for the chronically ill (SSBCI).
1 instance
— Apr 26, 2024 YesApr 26, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance One CareOne Care Medicare Medicaid Plan Corrective action plan, compliance letterNotice or other
Reporting: Noncompliance with contract requirements concerning: (1) completeness and accuracy of...Noncompliance with contract requirements concerning: (1) completeness and accuracy of encounter data submissions for the entirety of CY23; and (2) accuracy of certified financial reports during CY23.
1 instance
— Apr 17, 2024 YesApr 9, 2025 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCOSenior Care Options (SCO) Corrective action plan, compliance letterNotice or other
Reporting: Noncompliance with contract requirements concerning: (1) completeness and accuracy of...Noncompliance with contract requirements concerning: (1) completeness and accuracy of encounter data submissions for the entirety of CY23; and (2) accuracy of certified financial reports during CY23.
1 instance
— Apr 17, 2024 YesApr 9, 2025 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance One CareOne Care Medicare Medicaid Plan Compliance letterNotice or other
Benefit Administration: CCA reported that from February 2 through March 24, 2023 they had incorrectly...CCA reported that from February 2 through March 24, 2023 they had incorrectly terminated 477 members. This impacted both active members that were incorrectly terminated and members that should have been disenrolled but were termed for incorrect span dates in contracts H0137 and H2225.
477 instances
— Feb 29, 2024 YesFeb 29, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance One CareOne Care Medicare Medicaid Plan Compliance letterNotice or other
Performance improvement: Ventilator/ claims issue: failure to meet prompt payment provisions for previously...Ventilator/ claims issue: failure to meet prompt payment provisions for previously authorized services billed with certain modifiers from mid-2020 through December 19th, 2022.
1 instance
— Feb 29, 2024 YesFeb 29, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCOSenior Care Options (SCO) Compliance letterNotice or other
Performance improvement: Ventilator/ claims issue: failure to meet prompt payment provisions for previously...Ventilator/ claims issue: failure to meet prompt payment provisions for previously authorized services billed with certain modifiers from mid-2020 through December 19th, 2022.
1 instance
— Feb 29, 2024 YesFeb 29, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCOSenior Care Options (SCO) Compliance letterNotice or other Marketing: Failure to adhere to marketing and communication materials guidelines for enrollment packages and Summary of Benefits materials.1 instance — Feb 29, 2024 YesFeb 29, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCOSenior Care Options (SCO) Compliance letterNotice or other
Benefit Administration: CCA reported that from February 2 through March 24, 2023 they had incorrectly termed...CCA reported that from February 2 through March 24, 2023 they had incorrectly termed 477 members. This impacted both active members that were incorrectly termed and members that should have been disenrolled but were termed for incorrect span dates in contracts H0137 and H2225.
477 instances
— Feb 29, 2024 YesFeb 20, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance One CareOne Care Medicare Medicaid Plan Compliance letterNotice or other Marketing: Failure to Include Correct Information Regarding Prior Authorization Requirements in the Evidence of Coverage (EOC)1 instance — Feb 15, 2024 YesFeb 15, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance One CareOne Care Medicare Medicaid Plan Compliance letterNotice or other Cost Sharing: Failure to reduce members cost-sharing according to LIS assignments, resulting in incorrect cost share.1 instance — Feb 2, 2024 YesFeb 2, 2024 CMS file
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance SCOSenior Care Options (SCO) Compliance letterNotice or other Cost Sharing: Failure to reduce members cost-sharing according to LIS assignments, resulting in incorrect cost share.1 instance — Feb 2, 2024 YesFeb 2, 2024 CMS file

Plans, July 2024

StatePlanProgramMembersChangevs year beforeDual eligibleShare of state
Arkansas CareSourceStatewide PASSEComprehensive MCO + MLTSS 3,923 +22.8% 72 8.2%
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaStatewide Georgia FamiliesComprehensive MCO 376,721 −19.5% 0 23.6%
Georgia CareSource GeorgiaStatewide Georgia Pathways to CoverageComprehensive MCO 1,414 — 0 0.1%
Indiana CareSource IndianaStatewideParent as the state reports it: CareSource Indiana, Inc. Healthy Indiana PlanComprehensive MCO 81,678 −4.3% 560 5.1%
Indiana CareSource IndianaStatewideParent as the state reports it: CareSource Indiana, Inc. Hoosier HealthwiseComprehensive MCO 73,087 −9.7% 0 4.5%
Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Alliance01330, 01337, 01338, 01339, 01340, 01341, 01342, 01344, 01354, 01301, 01302,...Parent as the state reports it: Commonwealth Care Alliance Senior Care OptionsComprehensive MCO + MLTSS 16,523 +10.4% 15,677 1.8%
New York Riverspring MAPNew York City, Nassau, and Westchester CountiesParent as the state reports it: ElderServe Health, Inc. Medicaid Advantage PlusComprehensive MCO + MLTSS 334 +72.2% 334 0.0%
Ohio CareSourceStatewide Ohio Medicaid Managed Care ProgramComprehensive MCO 1,191,420 −16.2% 33,215 43.8%
Ohio CareSourceNortheast, Northeast Central, East Central MyCare Ohio Opt-Out ProgramComprehensive MCO + MLTSS 17,858 +10.5% 17,858 0.7%

Other Medicaid programs (not in the totals)

Dental, behavioral health, transportation, long-term care only, PACE and case management programs, and vendors listed inside comprehensive programs. A person can be in one of these and a comprehensive plan at once, so their members aren't added to the totals.

StatePlanProgramMembers
GeorgiaCareSource Georgia Planning for Healthy BabiesOther limited benefits16,972
New YorkRiverspring at Home Managed Long Term CareLong-term services and supports19,046