Prior authorization, as plans report it (2025)
i
Under 42 CFR 422.122(c), for all medical items and services combined (drugs are excluded), per contract: the list of services that need prior authorization; the share of standard requests approved, denied, and approved after appeal; the share approved after the review time was extended; the share of expedited requests approved and denied; and the mean and median time from request to decision for standard and expedited requests.
Plans must give percentages, not counts. Most large plans print counts too; Aetna, Anthem and HCSC don't, so their request volumes are unknown.
Standard requests had to be decided within 14 days in 2025 (7 days from 2026); expedited within 72 hours.
Many plans hand prior authorization for imaging, musculoskeletal, cardiology and oncology care to a utilization management vendor (eviCore, Carelon, Cohere and others).
Not here yet: 170 contracts (3,740,986 members) searched with no report found · 147 contracts (609,924 members) not searched yet.
i
Every figure here is taken from the plan's own published report, as printed, and checked against that report. Each contract links to its source.
Plans publish at different levels: most by contract, some for a product, a brand, or all their contracts combined. Shared figures are labelled wherever they appear.
Plans also differ in how they count. Some count a partial approval as a denial; "approved after appeal" can be a share of appeals or of all denials; times come in days or hours. We convert units but don't otherwise change what plans printed, and we note the differences next to the figures they affect.
How plans compare
The largest ten parent organizations. Each dot is one published report (usually one contract) with at least 1,000 members, sized by members; the orange tick is the middle report for that parent.
Standard requests denied i
Standard requests deniedShare of standard (non-urgent) prior authorization requests the plan denied in 2025, as printed. A figure published for a product or for all of a parent's contracts appears once, as one dot.
Some plans count a partial approval as a denial (HCSC says so); others don't say.
i
Share of standard (non-urgent) prior authorization requests the plan denied in 2025, as printed. A figure published for a product or for all of a parent's contracts appears once, as one dot.
Some plans count a partial approval as a denial (HCSC says so); others don't say.
Typical (median) time to decide a standard request i
Median time to decideThe median time from request to decision for standard requests. Hollow dots were printed as "under 1 day", so the true figure is lower.
UnitedHealthcare is left out: its printed median is higher than its printed mean for every contract, which is unusual for decision times (see the table's ⓘ), so its times can't be compared like for like.
Contracts a plan reports in several parts (Kaiser's California contracts by region, Martin's Point by type of service, BCBS Minnesota by plan) have no single median, so they're left out too.
i
The median time from request to decision for standard requests. Hollow dots were printed as "under 1 day", so the true figure is lower.
UnitedHealthcare is left out: its printed median is higher than its printed mean for every contract, which is unusual for decision times (see the table's ⓘ), so its times can't be compared like for like.
Contracts a plan reports in several parts (Kaiser's California contracts by region, Martin's Point by type of service, BCBS Minnesota by plan) have no single median, so they're left out too.
How often plans are asked, against how often they say no i
Requests and denialsEach dot is a contract the plan reported by itself with counts: standard requests per 1,000 average members across, share denied up. Plans that print only percentages (Aetna, Anthem, HCSC) can't appear.
A low denial rate on many requests can still mean more members meet a "no" than a higher rate on few requests; this shows both at once.
i
Each dot is a contract the plan reported by itself with counts: standard requests per 1,000 average members across, share denied up. Plans that print only percentages (Aetna, Anthem, HCSC) can't appear.
A low denial rate on many requests can still mean more members meet a "no" than a higher rate on few requests; this shows both at once.
By contract: Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.
| Contract | Members | Standard requestsper 1,000 | Standard denied | Expedited denied | Approved after appeal | Standard decisioniTime to decision Median time from request to decision, with the mean below it. Plans print days, hours, or both; all are converted here. "<1 d" was printed as "under 1 day". Anthem prints no unit; its footnote says the figures are days. Why the mean is often much higher than the median. Most requests are decided the same day, many as soon as they're submitted, while a smaller share wait days for medical records or clinical review, up to the deadline. Those slow cases pull the mean up; the median shows the typical request. Several plans print whole days, so a median of "0 days" means under a day. UnitedHealthcare is the exception: its printed mean is below its median for every contract (marked). With that many same-day decisions, a mean below the median would be unusual, so read UnitedHealthcare's times with caution. |
Expedited decisionmedian · mean | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H0524 Kaiser Permanente 2 parts combined1 | 1,342,702 | 288,204214 | 15.0% | 5.7% | 32%of appeals | —1.3 d | —15 h | Report 1 · Report 2 |
| H8794 Kaiser Permanente 2 parts combined1 | 120,558 | 73,436609 | 11.2% | 6.5% | 39%of appeals | —1.2 d | —16.9 h | Report 1 · Report 2 |
| H0630 Kaiser Permanente | 112,338 | 69,309616 | 9.6% | 7.0% | 66%of appeals | 1.1 d5.3 d | 2 d1.9 d | Report |
| H2172 Kaiser Permanente | 111,220 | 90,494813 | 5.5% | 14.0% | 69%of appeals | 0 h3 h | 0 h4 h | Report |
| H9003 Kaiser Permanente | 106,381 | 62,374586 | 12.6% | 9.9% | 47%of appeals | 20 h3.7 d | 1 h14 h | Report |
| H5050 Kaiser Permanente | 100,746 | 184,9181,835 | 6.1% | 8.5% | 70%of appeals | 4 h1 d | 2 h17 h | Report |
| H1170 Kaiser Permanente | 39,932 | 51,5231,290 | 3.1% | 3.1% | 52%of appeals | 4.8 d5.5 d | 23 h1.5 d | Report |
| H1230 Kaiser Permanente | 36,610 | 22,497614 | 7.1% | 3.2% | 64%of appeals | 14 h1.9 d | 1 h6 h | Report |
| H3138 Kaiser Permanente | 933 | 876938 | 8.5% | 7.2% | 100%of appeals | 3.1 d7 d | 2 d1.9 d | Report |
| H2704 Kaiser Permanente | — | 77 | 0.0% | — | — | 0 h19 h | —— | Report |
Hover a contract for its parent. Contracts with figures published for a product, a brand or the whole parent show that shared figure, labelled. Request volume and requests per 1,000 are shown only where the plan reported the contract by itself.
Notes
- Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. reports some contracts in parts (by region, by type of service, or by plan). We add the parts' counts together and recompute the percentages from them; the mean time is weighted by each part's requests. A median can't be combined from several medians, so it's left blank.