Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
All questionsFor vendor teamsFor health plansFor providers

Questions › Oversight

What has CMS penalized Medicare Advantage plans for in the last 12 months?

In the 12 months to November 9, 2026, CMS sent 133 compliance and enforcement letters about Medicare Advantage contracts, including 14 civil money penalties totaling $1.5M. Most letters are lighter: 80 corrective action plans, 30 warning letters, 5 sanctions, 3 sanctions lifted, 1 terminations.

The most common issue was drug benefit (53 letters), followed by health benefit (46).

By kind of action

ActionLettersContracts namedPenalties
Ad hoc CAP8083—
Warning letter3078—
Civil money penalty14124$1.5M
Intermediate sanction550—
Sanction released34—
Termination11—

By issue

IssueLettersPenaltiesAmount
Drug Benefit530—
Health Benefit460—
Contract Administration2114$1.5M
Health and Drug Benefit110—
Deficiencies Corrected20—

The civil money penalties

DateContractParent organizationIssuePenaltySource
May 1, 2026 H0523 and 38 more Allina Health and Aetna Insurance Holding Company; CVS Health CorporationContract Administration$753,805 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H0074 and 35 more Centene CorporationContract Administration$380,785 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H3071 and 4 more Group 1001Contract Administration$84,190 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H4213 and 2 more USAble Mutual Insurance CompanyContract Administration$57,757 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H0107 and 7 more Health Care Service CorporationContract Administration$50,437 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H0294 and 12 more UnitedHealth Group, Inc.Contract Administration$48,869 Letter · CMS source
Apr 29, 2026 H1099 Health First Shared Services, Inc.Contract Administration$43,546 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H5211 Sanford HealthContract Administration$29,005 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H6743 and 1 more ATRIO Health PlansContract Administration$21,847 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H1290 and 4 more Devoted Health, Inc.Contract Administration$18,668 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H7115 Memorial Hermann Health SystemContract Administration$16,676 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H3330 and 1 more EmblemHealth, Inc.Contract Administration$11,648 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H0504 and 1 more California Physicians' ServiceContract Administration$10,988 Letter · CMS source
May 1, 2026 H3384 and 5 more Highmark HealthContract Administration$10,458 Letter · CMS source

How this is worked out

CMS posts every compliance and enforcement action it takes against Medicare Advantage and Part D contracts: warning letters, ad hoc corrective action plans, civil money penalties, intermediate sanctions (such as suspending enrollment or marketing) and terminations. We load the monthly compliance reports and enforcement pages, keep each letter, and match each to the contracts it names.

Counts here are of letters, not contracts: one letter can name many contracts of the same organization, and its penalty is for the whole letter. Medicare Advantage contracts only; letters about standalone drug plans or PACE alone are left out. The issue is CMS's own category for the letter.

Sources

Go further