Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
All questionsFor vendor teamsFor health plansFor providers

Questions › Quality and Star Ratings

Which Medicare Advantage contracts carry CMS's low-performing icon?

4 contracts carry CMS's low-performing icon in the 2027 Star Ratings, with 11,948 members between them. The icon marks contracts rated below 3 stars on their Part C or Part D summary rating for three years in a row.

For members it matters in three ways: Medicare Plan Finder shows a warning, online enrollment into the plan is blocked, and members can switch to another plan during the year. CMS can also move to end a contract that stays this low.

The contracts

ContractParent organizationOverallPart CPart DTriggered byMembers
H4982 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation 2.52.52.5 Part C or D9,288
H3814 ATRIO Health Plans ATRIO Health Plans 2.52.53 Part C1,997
H9066 Nascentia Health Plus VISITING NURSE ASSOCIATION OF CENTRAL NEW YORK ——2 Part D663
H7389 HealthSpring Health Care Service Corporation 2.52.52.5 Part C0

How this is worked out

The list is CMS's own: the "Low Performing Contracts" table in the 2027 Star Ratings data, which also says whether Part C, Part D or either triggered the icon. The three years are the 2025, 2026 and 2027 ratings. Standalone drug plans can carry the icon too; they're left out here.

Members are each contract's enrollment in CMS's November 2026 monthly file.

Sources

Go further

Related questions