Which Medicare Advantage contracts carry CMS's low-performing icon?
4 contracts carry CMS's low-performing icon in the 2027 Star Ratings, with 11,948 members between them. The icon marks contracts rated below 3 stars on their Part C or Part D summary rating for three years in a row.
For members it matters in three ways: Medicare Plan Finder shows a warning, online enrollment into the plan is blocked, and members can switch to another plan during the year. CMS can also move to end a contract that stays this low.
The contracts
| Contract | Parent organization | Overall | Part C | Part D | Triggered by | Members |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H4982 Aetna Medicare | CVS Health Corporation | 2.5 | 2.5 | 2.5 | Part C or D | 9,288 |
| H3814 ATRIO Health Plans | ATRIO Health Plans | 2.5 | 2.5 | 3 | Part C | 1,997 |
| H9066 Nascentia Health Plus | VISITING NURSE ASSOCIATION OF CENTRAL NEW YORK | — | — | 2 | Part D | 663 |
| H7389 HealthSpring | Health Care Service Corporation | 2.5 | 2.5 | 2.5 | Part C | 0 |
How this is worked out
The list is CMS's own: the "Low Performing Contracts" table in the 2027 Star Ratings data, which also says whether Part C, Part D or either triggered the icon. The three years are the 2025, 2026 and 2027 ratings. Standalone drug plans can carry the icon too; they're left out here.
Members are each contract's enrollment in CMS's November 2026 monthly file.
Sources
- CMS, Part C and D Star Ratings data tables, 2027 ratings (Low Performing Contracts).