Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
All questionsFor vendor teamsFor health plansFor providers

Questions › Members and markets

Which Medicare Advantage plans do members leave most often?

On average, 14.3% of members chose to leave their Medicare Advantage contract during the year CMS measured for the 2027 Star Ratings, across 511 contracts weighted by size. Among contracts with at least 10,000 members, the highest rate was 50%, at Healthfirst Medicare Plan (H5989).

The measure counts members who switched by choice. Deaths, moves out of the service area and plans that closed don't count.

Highest leave rates, contracts with 10,000+ members

ContractParent organizationMembersLeft, 2027 ratingsLeft, 2026 ratings
H5989 Healthfirst Medicare Plan Healthfirst, Inc.12,756 50%21%
H8597 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation13,523 46%47%
H9888 Devoted Health Devoted Health, Inc.16,645 41%48%
H4808 Devoted Health Devoted Health, Inc.12,205 40%30%
H0982 Solis Health Plans Athena Healthcare Holdings, LLC26,276 38%33%
H7284 Humana Humana Inc.11,029 38%31%
H5718 Devoted Health Devoted Health, Inc.11,310 37%—
H8173 Devoted Health Devoted Health, Inc.12,331 37%58%
H9700 Devoted Health Devoted Health, Inc.21,398 37%—
H2041 Devoted Health Devoted Health, Inc.27,242 37%—
H3146 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation57,507 36%34%
H4523 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation39,624 35%26%
H8849 Wellpoint Elevance Health, Inc.56,520 35%20%
H5471 Simply Healthcare Plans, Inc. Elevance Health, Inc.31,554 35%33%
H2593 Wellpoint Elevance Health, Inc.14,312 35%19%
H5325 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation18,860 35%26%
H0432 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc.55,063 35%34%
H2293 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation115,141 35%14%
H5453 Devoted Health Devoted Health, Inc.46,567 34%—
H4161 Anthem Blue Cross Partnership Plan Elevance Health, Inc.51,413 34%37%

How this is worked out

The leave rate is CMS's Star measure "Members Choosing to Leave the Plan": the share of a contract's members who left by choice during the measurement year (01/01/2025 – 12/31/2025). CMS publishes it as a whole percentage. The average weights each contract by its members in November 2026.

A rate reflects the local market as well as the plan: competitors' benefits, broker activity and network changes all move it. CMS's survey of members who left asks why; the reasons are on the page linked below.

Sources

Go further

Related questions