Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Star measuresDisplay measuresHEDISWhy members leave

Why members leave

How many members choose to leave their Medicare Advantage plan each year, and the reasons they give CMS. Start with the national picture, then pick a parent organization to see its contracts.

14.3%
i
Leave rate

Share of members who chose to leave their contract during 2025, from the Star Ratings measure "Members Choosing to Leave the Plan" (2027 Star Ratings). It counts voluntary switches to another plan; it excludes people who died, moved out of the service area, or whose plan ended.

National figure = average across 511 MA contracts, weighted by each contract's current members. The middle (median) contract's rate is 15%.

of MA members chose to leave in 2025 (+1.8 pts vs 2024)
183 / 462
i
Contracts with rising leave rates

Contracts whose leave rate in 2025 was higher than in 2024, out of contracts with both years. 224 improved.

contracts where more members left than the year before
19%
i
Financial reasons

CMS's composite score (0–100) for premium or drug copay went up, found a plan that costs less, more expensive than expected, could no longer afford it: the average share of surveyed members who left in 2024 answering "yes" to the related survey questions ("Did you leave the plan because…"). From the Disenrollment Reasons Survey (2026 Star Ratings data, the latest CMS published). Scores for different reasons don't add to 100.

CMS hides a contract's score when it has fewer than 30 responses, is unreliable, or is not statistically different from the national average, so published scores lean toward contracts that stand out, and averages here are over those published scores only.

National = CMS's published national average for MA contracts (Display Measures Technical Notes, Attachment A). Unlike an average of the published contract scores, it includes contracts whose scores CMS hid.

Questions in this group: premium or drug copay went up, found a plan that costs less, more expensive than expected, could no longer afford it.

financial reasons score, 2024 leavers
23%
i
Doctors and hospitals

CMS's composite score (0–100) for the doctors, other providers, clinics or hospitals they wanted were not covered by the plan: the average share of surveyed members who left in 2024 answering "yes" to the related survey questions ("Did you leave the plan because…"). From the Disenrollment Reasons Survey (2026 Star Ratings data, the latest CMS published). Scores for different reasons don't add to 100.

CMS hides a contract's score when it has fewer than 30 responses, is unreliable, or is not statistically different from the national average, so published scores lean toward contracts that stand out, and averages here are over those published scores only.

National = CMS's published national average for MA contracts (Display Measures Technical Notes, Attachment A). Unlike an average of the published contract scores, it includes contracts whose scores CMS hid.

Questions in this group: the doctors, other providers, clinics or hospitals they wanted were not covered by the plan.

doctors and hospitals score, 2024 leavers
15%
i
Getting care approved and paid

CMS's composite score (0–100) for frustrated by the approval process for care, problems getting needed care, problems getting a claim paid, hard to learn what's covered or what it costs: the average share of surveyed members who left in 2024 answering "yes" to the related survey questions ("Did you leave the plan because…"). From the Disenrollment Reasons Survey (2026 Star Ratings data, the latest CMS published). Scores for different reasons don't add to 100.

CMS hides a contract's score when it has fewer than 30 responses, is unreliable, or is not statistically different from the national average, so published scores lean toward contracts that stand out, and averages here are over those published scores only.

National = CMS's published national average for MA contracts (Display Measures Technical Notes, Attachment A). Unlike an average of the published contract scores, it includes contracts whose scores CMS hid.

Questions in this group: frustrated by the approval process for care, problems getting needed care, problems getting a claim paid, hard to learn what's covered or what it costs.

getting care approved and paid score, 2024 leavers
8%
i
Prescription drug coverage

CMS's composite score (0–100) for drug list changed, a prescribed drug was refused or hard to get, hard to get brand-name drugs, approval process for non-formulary drugs: the average share of surveyed members who left in 2024 answering "yes" to the related survey questions ("Did you leave the plan because…"). From the Disenrollment Reasons Survey (2026 Star Ratings data, the latest CMS published). Scores for different reasons don't add to 100.

CMS hides a contract's score when it has fewer than 30 responses, is unreliable, or is not statistically different from the national average, so published scores lean toward contracts that stand out, and averages here are over those published scores only.

National = CMS's published national average for MA contracts (Display Measures Technical Notes, Attachment A). Unlike an average of the published contract scores, it includes contracts whose scores CMS hid. Only MA contracts with drug coverage are asked about drugs.

Questions in this group: drug list changed, a prescribed drug was refused or hard to get, hard to get brand-name drugs, approval process for non-formulary drugs.

prescription drug coverage score, 2024 leavers
11%
i
Information and help

CMS's composite score (0–100) for couldn't get information or help, a question or complaint handled badly, customer service not courteous: the average share of surveyed members who left in 2024 answering "yes" to the related survey questions ("Did you leave the plan because…"). From the Disenrollment Reasons Survey (2026 Star Ratings data, the latest CMS published). Scores for different reasons don't add to 100.

CMS hides a contract's score when it has fewer than 30 responses, is unreliable, or is not statistically different from the national average, so published scores lean toward contracts that stand out, and averages here are over those published scores only.

National = CMS's published national average for MA contracts (Display Measures Technical Notes, Attachment A). Unlike an average of the published contract scores, it includes contracts whose scores CMS hid.

Questions in this group: couldn't get information or help, a question or complaint handled badly, customer service not courteous.

information and help score, 2024 leavers

Leave rate by year
i
Trend

Enrollment-weighted share of MA members who chose to leave, by the year they left (each Star Ratings year measures leaving two years earlier). Weights are current members, so older years reflect today's mix of contracts.

Reasons given by year
i
Reasons trend

CMS's composite score (0–100) for each reason: the average share of surveyed leavers answering "yes" to the related questions, by the year they left. Lines are CMS's published national averages; for members who left in 2013–2017 CMS published one average across all contract types, and two groups had slightly different questions then ("needed care, coverage and cost information" and "information about prescription drugs"). CMS hides a contract's score when it has fewer than 30 responses, is unreliable, or is not statistically different from the national average, so published scores lean toward contracts that stand out, and averages here are over those published scores only.

By parent organization
i
How parents are compared

Each parent's leave rate and reasons are averages across its MA contracts, weighted by each contract's current members. Contracts without a value are left out of that average.

Leave rate is from the 2027 Star Ratings (members who left in 2025); reasons from 2026 (left in 2024). Member change compares the latest month with 12 months earlier and includes all reasons for change (new enrollment, deaths, switching).

The "All MA contracts" row shows the member-weighted leave rate and CMS's published national reason averages. Cells shaded red are at least 5 points worse than national. Click a parent to see its contracts.

Parent organization CostDoctors & hospitalsCare approval & paymentDrug coverageInfo & help
All MA contracts511 rated contracts 14.3%+1.8 19%CMS23%CMS15%CMS8%CMS11%CMS
Athena Healthcare Holdings, LLC1 contract 26,27681.5% 38%+5 —————
Devoted Health, Inc.42 contracts 545,962160.9% 32.6%−2.4 17.8%25.4%13.2%10.5%9.6%
Zing Health Consolidator, Inc2 contracts 46,34337.6% 30.9%−4.3 11%30%—5%—
Ultimate Healthcare Holdings, LLC1 contract 22,713203.2% 26%+13 7%25%12%6%10%
Village Care of New York, Inc.1 contract 10,88841.4% 26%+5 —————
Centene Corporation52 contracts 852,091−3.3% 22.7%−1.5 16.1%26.9%18.5%12.2%14.3%
DOCTORS HEALTHCARE PLANS, INC.1 contract 27,87843.0% 22%+4 —————
Humana Inc.36 contracts 7,197,54724.1% 20.3%+0.9 16.4%23.1%14.2%8.4%9.8%
Eternal Health of Delaware, Inc.3 contracts 10,099247.8% 20.2%— —————
Health Care Service Corporation21 contracts 877,036−3.6% 17.8%+2.9 18.5%26.6%18.5%11%14.8%
Guidewell Mutual Holding Corporation5 contracts 262,379−3.9% 17.7%+5.9 21.9%21%12.4%12.2%9.8%
Elevance Health, Inc.39 contracts 1,888,526−14.0% 17%+2.7 17.2%21.9%14.4%7.6%9.7%
Imperial Health Plan of California1 contract 54,253112.2% 17%−1 9%60%36%—23%
ATRIO Health Plans3 contracts 33,466−14.3% 16.7%+3.9 9.7%39.6%10.7%2%7%
UnitedHealth Group, Inc.60 contracts 9,313,397−9.0% 16.5%+3.2 18.3%17.2%12.4%5.9%9.2%
Thomas Jefferson University3 contracts 31,61577.1% 16.2%+0.2 —————
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas1 contract 10,21229.3% 16%+8 25%17%13%9%11%
Visiting Nurse Service of New York1 contract 74,84596.6% 15%−4 —————
CVS Health Corporation42 contracts 4,181,196−0.3% 14.9%+4.2 20.9%13.7%10.9%7.6%8.9%
Molina Healthcare, Inc.15 contracts 139,98456.1% 13.8%+1.2 19.3%17.3%15.5%—13.2%
California Physicians' Service4 contracts 124,048−8.9% 13.4%+4.9 20.2%30.5%10%7%7.7%
Lumeris Group Holdings Corporation2 contracts 61,55910.9% 13%−4.1 13.8%22.2%14.7%5%7.4%
Elderplan, Inc.1 contract 27,29419.0% 13%−2 —————
Universal Health Services, Inc.3 contracts 52,42538.8% 12.9%+2.1 14%36%29%—16%
Banner Health2 contracts 18,321−26.8% 12.4%−9.7 17%19%13%—9%
CuraCor Solutions Corp.3 contracts 183,41811.5% 12%+4.5 22.9%11.6%9.5%15.9%9.6%
Astiva Health Holdings Incorporated1 contract 55,61043.6% 12%0 —————
Alignment Healthcare USA, LLC8 contracts 303,72530.9% 11.7%+0.8 13.1%31.8%21%—14.3%
The Health Plan of West Virginia, Inc.2 contracts 14,31531.4% 11.5%+4 9%9%7%—6%
Intermountain Health Care, Inc.1 contract 67,3641.2% 11%+4 15%48%11%—10%
CareOregon, Inc.1 contract 13,070−17.8% 11%+2 —————
LifeBridge Health, Inc.1 contract 14,40648.1% 11%0 18%35%25%—14%
CareSource5 contracts 87,182222.8% 10.7%−0.8 12%23%——12%
Healthfirst, Inc.4 contracts 377,2273.6% 10.5%+2 —————
USAble Mutual Insurance Company3 contracts 15,009−1.0% 10.4%−0.9 33%5%——7%
Clever Care Health Plan, Inc.1 contract 54,33781.6% 10%−17 —————
New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation1 contract 14,50415.8% 10%−4 —————
Cambia Health Solutions, Inc.6 contracts 71,593−13.2% 9.6%−2.9 25.9%19.4%9.2%7.9%5.2%
Sentara Health Care (SHC)2 contracts 10,421−72.8% 9.2%−0.8 16%27%15%—11%
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona2 contracts 47,30513.5% 9.1%+2.5 16%22%—7%10%
Triton Health Systems, L.L.C.1 contract 51,298−1.9% 9%−4 9%16%9%5%5%
Mercy Care1 contract 10,9651.0% 9%−1 —————
Independence Health Group, Inc.8 contracts 149,419−3.3% 8.4%+1.2 18.9%16.8%10.7%7%7%
Clover Health Holdings, Inc.2 contracts 160,01643.5% 8.2%−1 22%29%19%—17%
BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina (BCBSSC)1 contract 49,74642.2% 8%0 28%9%11%—7%
PacificSource1 contract 52,2927.4% 8%−2 23%27%9%6%5%
Orange County Health Authority1 contract 19,2455.4% 8%−2 —————
Local Initiative Health Authority for LA County1 contract 30,6091.6% 8%0 —————
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Nebraska2 contracts 28,39336.9% 7.7%−2.3 14%37%15%8%8%
MEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO2 contracts 73,225−14.6% 7.5%+1.5 15%32%23.4%—10.3%
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc.2 contracts 87,646−11.6% 7.5%+2.6 19%26%14%6%3%
Trinity Health Corporation4 contracts 78,17048.2% 7.4%+1.2 25%30%13%7%8%
SCAN Group8 contracts 467,93349.5% 7.2%−0.4 6.1%33.3%17.5%8%12.2%
MHH Healthcare, L.P.2 contracts 380,6637.8% 7.2%+1 18%20.5%11%—13.3%
Johns Hopkins Healthcare LLC3 contracts 14,98016.6% 7%−2.5 33.1%25.1%31%16%11.6%
Allina Health and Aetna Insurance Holding Company1 contract 57,07490.3% 7%−5 17%29%14%—12%
Horizon Mutual Holdings, Inc1 contract 28,58924.3% 7%+1 29%18%18%18%14%
INLAND EMPIRE HEALTH PLAN1 contract 38,360−0.6% 7%+1 —————
Mass General Brigham Incorporated4 contracts 21,626167.9% 7%+1 —————
Community Health Group2 contracts 11,00815.0% 7%+1 —————
SANTA CLARA COUNTY HEALTH AUTHORITY1 contract 11,9983.5% 7%+3 —————
Louisiana Health Service & Indemnity Company2 contracts 58,23822.0% 6.9%+0.6 35%20%16%—10%
Henry Ford Health System3 contracts 133,78854.1% 6.6%−1.3 23%21.8%13.1%—6%
Corewell Health3 contracts 287,11312.6% 6.6%−2.2 23.9%5.5%6.9%5.6%5.7%
Rifkin Managed Care Holding, LLC6 contracts 10,2946.9% 6.5%+1.2 —————
UPMC Health System4 contracts 226,385−1.1% 6.2%−1.6 20%11.3%6.2%3.8%4.9%
Medica Holding Company3 contracts 140,70871.3% 6.2%−0.9 30%7.5%9.7%8%9.1%
Fallon Community Health Plan, Inc.2 contracts 21,9492.2% 6.1%+2.5 17%26%12%7%8%
Highmark Health9 contracts 424,685−12.7% 6.1%+0.5 22%11.3%9.5%8%8.6%
BlueCross BlueShield of Alabama1 contract 114,3571.5% 6%+1 36%7%7%—6%
BayCare Health System, Inc.1 contract 22,03045.4% 6%−1 18%29%15%7%11%
LMC Family Holdings, LLC1 contract 40,7343.4% 6%−1 —————
West Virginia United Health System, Inc.1 contract 12,866264.4% 6%−4 —————
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Mutual Ins. Co.4 contracts 629,362−11.6% 5.9%+4.6 32.2%7.9%14.5%—8.8%
BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee2 contracts 220,8847.8% 5.7%−3.3 10.4%37.9%9%7%4.6%
Baylor Scott & White Health2 contracts 47,89522.3% 5.6%+0.2 24%23%16%7%6%
SIHO Holding, Inc.2 contracts 10,974117.8% 5.6%−3.4 —————
Presbyterian Healthcare Services1 contract 52,025−8.1% 5%−3 25%19%17%18%16%
The Regents of the University of California1 contract 12,03866.7% 5%— —————
General Catalyst Group Management Holdings LP1 contract 34,49329.3% 5%0 34%14%13%—9%
MVP Health Care, Inc.2 contracts 59,597−20.5% 5%+1.5 22.7%12.4%10.9%8%7.7%
Baystate Health, Inc.2 contracts 15,06217.4% 5%−3.4 19%26%13%6%7%
Risant Health, Inc.4 contracts 118,9850.5% 4.9%−4.1 22.4%10.1%9.1%4.4%3.9%
CareFirst, Inc.2 contracts 56,55678.2% 4.8%−8.2 27%37%——15%
Point32Health, Inc.4 contracts 124,742−1.9% 4.3%−1.2 20.6%36.5%12.7%7%7.4%
Health First Shared Services, Inc.1 contract 37,19711.5% 4%0 25%29%15%—8%
CAPITAL BLUE CROSS2 contracts 50,55643.4% 4%−2.5 35%10%12%—10%
Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island2 contracts 76,893−3.4% 4%+1 19%7%13%—11%
St Francis Health System & St John Health System1 contract 37,9678.2% 4%0 14%21%19%16%9%
Hawaii Medical Service Association2 contracts 43,68410.7% 4%+2 34%5%17%16%12%
University of Wisconsin Hospitals and Clincs Autho2 contracts 21,408−41.2% 3.9%−3.2 34%16%16%—9%
Aware Integrated, Inc.2 contracts 298,28243.8% 3.1%−1 32.8%5.4%7.2%5%3%
Network Health, Inc.2 contracts 133,95449.8% 3.1%−2 24%16%9%11%8%
Aultman Health Foundation1 contract 14,3930.8% 3%−4 25%9%10%——
Martin's Point Health Care, Inc.2 contracts 66,011−22.8% 2.9%−1.3 31%6%7%10%7%
EmblemHealth, Inc.3 contracts 37,840−4.3% 2.7%−0.6 —————
Sanford Health6 contracts 92,39514.2% 2.2%−0.9 30%12%9%—5%
Sharp Healthcare1 contract 19,95713.6% 2%−1 18%25%18%—16%
Lifetime Healthcare, Inc.5 contracts 335,31618.3% 1.6%−1.9 24%16%8.7%7.4%6%
HealthPartners, Inc.3 contracts 60,58216.3% 1.5%−4.6 22.9%18.1%9.6%6%7.8%
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.10 contracts 2,079,1003.4% 1.4%−0.3 17.1%20.2%21.7%8.5%15.9%
Independent Health Association, Inc.2 contracts 45,210−35.9% 1%−0.1 39%11%10%—8%
Gemstone Holdings, Inc.2 contracts 36,201−53.2% 1%−3.3 29%13%7%7%6%

Click any column header to sort; click again to reverse. Under "Members" is the 12-month change; under "Left" is the change from the prior year. Hover a reason header for the questions behind it.