Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
All questionsFor vendor teamsFor health plansFor providers

Questions › Care and benefits

How often do appeals of prior authorization denials succeed?

Often. Among 187 contracts that report appeal results as a share of appeals decided, the typical contract approved 67% of appealed denials in 2025 (61% weighted by members). In 79% of these contracts, more than half of appeals succeeded.

A high overturn rate can mean the first decision was often wrong, or that the appeal brought records the first review didn't have. Either way, it is work for the provider's staff, and few denials are appealed at all: where plans give both counts, about 7 in every 100.

Larger parent organizations

Parent organizationContracts reportingMembersAppeals approvedAverage denial rate
UnitedHealth Group, Inc.5810,075,591 60%13.0%
Humana Inc.305,771,603 65%7.5%
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.81,970,487 40%8.8%
Centene Corporation45756,559 94%16.0%
Highmark Health7478,813 78%4.3%
Healthfirst, Inc.4352,064 87%9.5%
UPMC Health System4227,815 62%4.8%
Aware Integrated, Inc.2203,227 39%5.2%
Lifetime Healthcare, Inc.3201,694 30%13.5%
UCare Minnesota5184,670 50%35.6%
Network Health, Inc.184,885 64%12.0%
Martin's Point Health Care, Inc.284,722 66%7.3%
Medica Holding Company483,332 96%5.8%
Intermountain Health Care, Inc.267,359 97%7.0%
Lumeris Group Holdings Corporation256,489 7%12.6%

How this is worked out

Plans' posted reports give the share of denied standard requests that were approved after appeal, but not all on the same basis: most give it as a share of appeals decided, some as a share of all denials, and some don't say. Only the first kind is used here, for contracts with at least 1,000 members (187 contracts, 22 parent organizations). The member-weighted figure counts each contract by its members; the parent figures do the same. The denial rate column is the simple average of the contracts' reported rates.

The "7 in every 100" figure divides appeals decided by standard requests denied, across the contracts that give both counts.

Sources

  • Each plan's posted prior authorization report for 2025, required by CMS's Interoperability and Prior Authorization final rule (CMS-0057-F).

Go further

Related questions