Which Medicare Advantage plans deny the most prior authorization requests?
Across 234 contracts with 21.6 million members that published counts for 2025, plans denied 9.2% of standard prior authorization requests, about 108 denials per 1,000 members.
The denial rate and the denial burden rank plans differently. Contracts that ask for authorization on more services report lower denial rates but deny more per member: the fifth with the most requests denied 6.1% of requests and 171 per 1,000 members, against 15.0% and 42 for the fifth with the fewest.
Denial rate against denials per member
Contracts grouped into fifths by how many standard requests they report per 1,000 members.
| Requests per member | Contracts | Members | Requests per 1,000 | Denial rate | Denials per 1,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fewest | 47 | 3,152,356 | 278 | 15.0% | 42 |
| Second | 47 | 4,750,160 | 574 | 17.0% | 97 |
| Middle | 47 | 5,135,630 | 822 | 13.5% | 111 |
| Fourth | 47 | 5,265,183 | 1,553 | 7.3% | 113 |
| Most | 46 | 3,312,953 | 2,780 | 6.1% | 171 |
Most denials per member, contracts with 10,000+ members
How this is worked out
CMS's Interoperability and Prior Authorization rule requires Medicare Advantage plans to post yearly prior authorization figures on their own websites; the first reports cover 2025. We collect those reports and keep each one as published. Here: standard (non-expedited) requests, from contract-level reports that give counts, for contracts with at least 1,000 members.
- Denial rate = standard requests denied ÷ standard requests, as the plan reports it.
- Denials per 1,000 members = denied requests ÷ the contract's average members × 1,000. It measures how often a member meets a denial, whatever the plan's list of services needing approval.
What counts as a request differs between plans: some count every service line, some count a whole episode, and delegated providers' requests are in some reports and not others. Reports showing more than 20 requests per member (nearly everything counted as a request) are left out as not comparable. Some large parents publish percentages without counts, so their contracts can't be included. Partly approved requests are counted as denials by some plans.
Sources
- Each plan's posted prior authorization report for 2025, required by CMS's Interoperability and Prior Authorization final rule (CMS-0057-F); links in the table and on each contract's page.
- CMS, monthly enrollment by contract, for average members.