Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Revenue & risk scoresPart D resultsMedical loss ratioWhere the money goesPremiums & MOOPBenefitsACOs

Benefits · Cattaraugus market

Cattaraugus, NY: plans compared for 2027

Plans for everyone: what's on offer

PlansParents$0 premiumMOOPmedianGivebackshare · median /monthDentalshare · median /yearOTCshare · median /yearEyewearmedian /yearHearing aidsshare · median /yearRidesMealsSSBCIshare · median /yearOptional extras
202734853%$7,500 24%$55.00 88%$1,000 44%$160 $150 91%$700 15%53% 0%—18%
202639854%$7,200 31%$47.05 95%$1,500 64%$160 $200 95%$1,000 15%56% 0%—3%

Medians across the plans on offer, not weighted by members. Giveback, dental, OTC, hearing aid and SSBCI medians are among plans that offer them with a dollar limit. SSBCI is only for members with a qualifying chronic condition.

Special needs plans: what's on offer

PlansParents$0 premiumMOOPmedianGivebackshare · median /monthDentalshare · median /yearOTCshare · median /yearEyewearmedian /yearHearing aidsshare · median /yearRidesMealsSSBCIshare · median /yearOptional extras
202715567%$9,850 0%— 87%$875 100%$580 $150 93%$1,050 27%60% 87%$5640%
202614514%$9,250 7%$72.00 79%$1,230 100%$880 $200 100%$1,100 21%79% 86%$1,1767%

Medians across the plans on offer, not weighted by members. Giveback, dental, OTC, hearing aid and SSBCI medians are among plans that offer them with a dollar limit. SSBCI is only for members with a qualifying chronic condition.

Every plan sold here

PlanMembers herePremium/monthMOOP/yearPart B giveback/monthDental/yearOTC/yearEyewear/yearHearing aids/yearRidesMealsSSBCI/yearOptional extras/monthWorse / better
H3351-017 Univera SeniorChoice Basic (HMO) Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. 1,397 $0.00$9,850was $8,500None$500was $1,000Nonewas $120Nonewas $150No $ limitNoNoNone$26.00 · dental 4 / 0
H3379-040 AARP Medicare Advantage from UHC NY-0007 (HMO-POS) UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 1,197 $0.00$9,300was $8,300None$1,000was $1,500$100shared allowancewas $160$75was $150$700NoYesNoneNone 4 / 0
H3312-065 Aetna Medicare Signature (HMO-POS) CVS Health Corporation 1,013 $0.00$7,150was $6,750None$750None$100No $ limitNoYesNoneNone 1 / 0
H3362-044 Independent Health's Encompass 65 RED 044 (HMO) Independent Health Association, Inc. 554 $110.00was $95.00$8,000was $7,500None$2,000was $1,500None$200$500was $400NoNoNoneNone 2 / 2
H3384-069 Community Blue Medicare HMO Signature (HMO) Highmark Health 471 $0.00$7,150was $6,750None$750was $1,500$100was $300$100No $ limitNoYesNoneNone 3 / 0
H3351-019 Univera SeniorChoice Advanced (HMO-POS) Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. 326 $75.40was $50.80$7,500None$500was $1,000Nonewas $120Nonewas $150No $ limitNoNoNone$26.00 · dental 4 / 0
H3418-008 AARP Medicare Advantage from UHC NY-0019 (PPO) UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 316 $39.00was $38.00$8,900was $8,500NonePreventive onlyNone$100$700NoNowas YesNone$54.00 · dental 3 / 0
H3351-002 Univera SeniorChoice Secure (HMO-POS) Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. 230 $104.70was $83.20$6,000None$500was $1,000Nonewas $120Nonewas $200No $ limitNowas YesNowas YesNone$26.00 · dental 6 / 0
H3362-042 Independent Health's Encompass 65 RED 042 (HMO) Independent Health Association, Inc. 179 $49.00was $40.00$9,850was $9,250None$1,500None$200$500was $400NoNoNoneNone 2 / 1
H3351-012 Univera SeniorChoice Value Plus (HMO-POS) Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. 164 $93.30was $69.80$6,700None$500was $1,000Nonewas $120Nonewas $200No $ limitNoNoNone$26.00 · dental 4 / 0
H5970-029 HumanaChoice H5970-029 (PPO) Humana Inc. 153 $65.00was $32.00$9,250None$1,000was $2,000None$200was $250No $ limitNoYesNoneNone 3 / 0
H2775-106 Wellcare Simple Open (PPO) Centene Corporation 135 $0.00$9,850was $9,250NoneNo $ limitNoneNonewas $100$1,500NoNoNoneNone 2 / 0
H5970-016 Humana USAA Honor Giveback (PPO) Humana Inc. 131 $0.00$4,950$110.00$2,000$200shared allowance$250No $ limitYes · 24 tripsYesNoneNone 0 / 0
H2775-111 Wellcare Giveback Open (PPO) Centene Corporation 118 $0.00$9,850was $9,250$37.00was $40.00No $ limitNoneNoneNoneNoNoNoneNone 2 / 0
H3362-016 Independent Health's Encompass 65 (HMO) Independent Health Association, Inc. 95 $0.00$6,750$60.00was $11.00$2,000$300$200$500was $400Yes · 24 tripsNoNoneNone 0 / 2
H5599-004 Wellcare Fidelis Simple (HMO-POS) Centene Corporation 82 $0.00$9,850was $9,250NoneNo $ limitNoneNonewas $200Nonewas $1,500NoNoNoneNone 3 / 0
H3384-070 Community Blue Medicare HMO Distinct (HMO) Highmark Health 60 $77.00was $55.00$6,750None$1,000was $2,000$180was $220$200No $ limitNoYesNoneNone 3 / 0
H3379-060 AARP Medicare Advantage Patriot No Rx NY-MA3 (HMO-POS) UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 59 $0.00$7,150was $6,700$125.00was $115.00$1,000$200shared allowancewas $240$125was $100$1,000NoYesNoneNone 2 / 2
H3344-013 Independent Health's Medicare Passport Connect (PPO) Independent Health Association, Inc. 56 $81.00was $58.80$9,850was $9,250None$1,500None$200Nonewas $400NoNoNoneNone 3 / 0
H5599-002 Wellcare Fidelis Assist (HMO-POS) Centene Corporation 46 $0.00was $32.50$9,850was $9,250None$1,000was $1,500$156shared allowancewas $240$200$700was $1,000NoNoNoneNone 4 / 1
H2775-113 Wellcare Assist Open (PPO) Centene Corporation 41 $0.00was $58.80$9,850was $9,250NoneNo $ limitNonewas $132$100$1,000NoNoNoneNone 2 / 1
H5521-323 Aetna Medicare Eagle Giveback (PPO) CVS Health Corporation 31 $0.00$9,850was $9,250$100.00was $75.00$2,000$240$375was $250No $ limitNoYesNoneNone 1 / 2
H3384-022 Senior Blue 601 (HMO) Highmark Health 15 $0.00$6,700$7.00was None$2,000$100$100No $ limitNoYesNoneNone 0 / 1
H5599-010 Wellcare Fidelis Patriot Simple (HMO-POS) Centene Corporation ≤10 $0.00$9,850was $9,250None$2,000was $3,000$420shared allowancewas $600$200$1,500NoYesNoneNone 3 / 0
H5521-738 Aetna Medicare Elite (PPO) CVS Health Corporation · New — $35.00$9,850None$1,500None$250No $ limitNoYesNoneNone 0 / 0
H3384-072 Community Blue Medicare HMO Standard (HMO) Highmark Health · New — $368.00$7,150NonePreventive onlyNone$100No $ limitNoYesNoneNone 0 / 0
H3384-073 Community Blue Medicare HMO 651 (HMO) Highmark Health · New — $118.00$6,700None$2,000$160$200No $ limitNoYesNoneNone 0 / 0
H5526-023 Freedom Valor (PPO) Highmark Health ≤10 $0.00$6,700$50.00$2,000$160$100$500NoYesNoneNone 0 / 0
H3362-045 Independent Health's Encompass 65 RED 045 (HMO) Independent Health Association, Inc. · New — $286.00$7,000None$2,000None$200$500NoNoNoneNone 0 / 0
H3351-001 Univera Medicare Freedom (HMO-POS) Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. ≤10 $0.00$6,500was $4,500$25.00was $35.00$500was $1,000Nonewas $200$250No $ limitNowas YesYesNone$26.00 · dental 5 / 0
H3305-020 MVP Medicare Preferred Gold without Part D (HMO-POS) MVP Health Care, Inc. ≤10 $0.00$7,200NonePreventive only$100$150No $ limitYes · 12 tripsYesNoneNone 0 / 0
H3305-022 MVP Medicare Secure Plus with Part D (HMO-POS) MVP Health Care, Inc. ≤10 $165.00was $116.00$6,000None$300was $1,500$80was $200$175No $ limitYes · 24 tripsYesNoneNone 3 / 0
H3305-038 MVP Medicare WellValue with Part D (HMO-POS) MVP Health Care, Inc. · New — $71.00$9,850NonePreventive onlyNone$150No $ limitNoNoNoneNone 0 / 0
H9615-025 MVP Medicare Secure Plus Choice with Part D (PPO) MVP Health Care, Inc. · New — $256.00$7,500None$300$80$175No $ limitYes · 24 tripsYesNoneNone 0 / 0
H3387-017 UHC Dual Complete NY-S4 (HMO-POS D-SNP) UnitedHealth Group, Inc. · D-SNP 708 $0.00was $5.90$9,850was $9,250NoneNo $ limit$1,728shared allowancewas $1,500$200$1,100Yes · 36 tripsYes$1,728shared allowancewas $1,500None 1 / 2
H3379-053 UHC Complete Care NY-30 (HMO-POS C-SNP) UnitedHealth Group, Inc. · C-SNP 328 $0.00$8,900was $8,300None$1,000$516shared allowancewas $600$100was $125$700NoYes$516shared allowancewas $600None 3 / 0
H3312-070 Aetna Medicare Full Dual (HMO D-SNP) CVS Health Corporation · D-SNP 248 $0.00was $23.10$9,850was $9,250NoneNo $ limit$1,560was $1,680$100was $200No $ limitNoYes$1,560shared allowancewas $1,680None 3 / 1
H2001-063 UHC Dual Complete NY-S001 (PPO D-SNP) UnitedHealth Group, Inc. · D-SNP 157 $19.40was $52.80$9,850was $9,250NoneNo $ limit$1,200shared allowancewas $1,176$200$750NoNowas Yes$1,200shared allowancewas $1,176None 2 / 2
H2775-112 Wellcare Dual Access Open (PPO D-SNP) Centene Corporation · D-SNP 134 $0.00was $58.80$9,850was $9,250None$612shared allowancewas $744$612was $744$100$1,500NoYes$612shared allowancewas $744None 3 / 1
H3387-015 UHC Dual Complete NY-Q001 (HMO-POS D-SNP) UnitedHealth Group, Inc. · D-SNP 46 $0.00was $31.00$9,850was $9,250NoneNo $ limit$420shared allowance$150was $200$750NoYes$420shared allowanceNone 2 / 1
H2292-001 UHC Nursing Home Plan NY-F001 (PPO I-SNP) UnitedHealth Group, Inc. · I-SNP 34 $4.20was $58.80$9,850was $9,250Nonewas $72.00Preventive only$580shared allowancewas $800$300$1,100Yes · 18 tripsNoNoneNone 3 / 1
H5599-003 Wellcare Fidelis Dual Align Unity (HMO D-SNP) Centene Corporation · D-SNP 26 $40.50was $58.80$9,850was $9,250NoneNo $ limit$1,980was $2,904Nonewas $2,904Nonewas $1,000NoYes$1,980shared allowancewas $2,904None 4 / 1
H5521-461 Aetna Medicare Longevity (PPO I-SNP) CVS Health Corporation · I-SNP 17 $10.70was $58.80$9,850was $9,250None$1,500$600$250$1,500NoNoNo $ limitNone 1 / 1
H5599-014 Wellcare Fidelis Dual Liberty Sync (HMO D-SNP) Centene Corporation · D-SNP · New — $0.00$9,850NoneNo $ limit$300$200$1,000NoYes$300shared allowanceNone 0 / 0
H5599-016 Wellcare Fidelis Dual Access (HMO D-SNP) Centene Corporation · D-SNP · New — $0.00$9,850None$492shared allowance$492$200$1,000NoYes$492shared allowanceNone 0 / 0
H3312-105 Aetna Medicare Chronic Care (HMO C-SNP) CVS Health Corporation · C-SNP · New — $0.00$9,850None$750$300$100No $ limitNoNo$300shared allowanceNone 0 / 0
H3312-112 Aetna Medicare Chronic Care Total (HMO C-SNP) CVS Health Corporation · C-SNP · New — $0.00$9,850None$1,000$360$150No $ limitNoNo$360shared allowanceNone 0 / 0
H3533-036 Humana Gold Plus SNP-DE H3533-036 (HMO D-SNP) Humana Inc. · D-SNP · New — $0.00$9,850NoneNo $ limit$1,380shared allowance$100No $ limitYes · 24 tripsYes$1,380shared allowanceNone 0 / 0
H3362-020 Independent Health's Medicare Family Choice (HMO I-SNP) Independent Health Association, Inc. · I-SNP ≤10 $40.00was $58.80$5,000was $3,000NoneNone$400was $480$150$2,000Yes · 36 tripsNoNoneNone 2 / 1
Members here: the plan's members living in this county in the latest month (— when it had none, or is new). Red: worse for members than last year in this county, with last year's value under it.
i
How this is put together

From CMS's plan benefit package (PBP) files, which hold every approved plan's benefit design for the contract year, and CMS's Landscape files for premium (Part C + D, per month), in-network MOOP (per year) and the counties each plan is sold in. Individual and special needs Medicare Advantage plans only: employer group plans negotiate their own benefits and aren't in these files, and cost plans, PACE and medical savings accounts are left out.

Dollar limits are per year. Where a plan sets a limit per month, quarter or half year, it is multiplied out; a limit every two or three years is divided down. Dental is the combined yearly limit for preventive and comprehensive care; "Preventive only" means no comprehensive dental. Eyewear is the combined eyeglasses and contacts limit. Hearing aids count both ears. OTC counts only an allowance with a dollar limit: every plan must cover nicotine replacement and naloxone, and plans offering only that are shown as None. "No $ limit" means the benefit is covered with copays but no dollar cap.

Shared allowances. Many plans pool several benefits under one dollar limit, for example an OTC and hearing aid allowance on one card. Where a benefit has no limit of its own, the shared limit is shown and marked. It can be spent on the other benefits in the pool too, so it overstates what's available for that benefit alone.

SSBCI (special supplemental benefits for the chronically ill) are extras only members with a qualifying chronic condition can use, such as groceries, utilities, pest control or non-medical rides. The SSBCI column is the yearly allowance. Most plans load it on the same card as the OTC allowance, so the two show the same dollars, marked shared. Otherwise it is the SSBCI dollar limits added up; "No $ limit" means SSBCI services without a stated cap. Because not every member qualifies, SSBCI isn't counted in "cut a benefit"; an SSBCI cut (dropped, or a lower allowance) is shown on its own.

Optional extras are packages members can add for an extra monthly premium, usually dental. The column shows the cheapest package's premium.

Not counted: Part D drug coverage beyond the premium, and supplemental benefits outside the columns shown (fitness, acupuncture and the like).

Special needs plans: premiums are before the low-income subsidy, which pays all or most of the premium for most D-SNP members. Some D-SNPs file a Part B giveback of a few dollars or cents to price exactly at the subsidy amount; such a giveback isn't a real benefit, so a change in the giveback counts as a cut or gain only when one of the two years' amounts is at least $5 a month. For 2027 many D-SNPs lowered their premium to $0 and dropped those small givebacks, so their $0 premium share rises and their median giveback (among plans with one) jumps.

Changes compare the same plan ID with last year. A plan renumbered or merged into another shows as new. Red cells got worse for members: premium or MOOP up, a dollar limit lower, or a benefit dropped.

Each row is the plan's benefits for this county's segment, compared with the same segment last year.