Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Revenue & risk scoresPart D resultsMedical loss ratioWhere the money goesPremiums & MOOPBenefitsACOs

Medical loss ratio

The share of revenue each contract spent on claims and quality improvement, as reported to CMS, 2021–2023.

These figures are about 3 years old. CMS publishes MLR well after the year closes: the latest file covers 2023 and came out in 2026. Use them for patterns, not current margins. Revenue and cost detail starts with 2023.

23
contracts below 85% in 2023 (of 635) · $52.4M owed CMS · median 91.3%
49
contracts below 85% in 2022 (of 615) · $422M owed CMS · median 90.9%
23
contracts below 85% in 2021 (of 564) · $143M owed CMS · median 92.1%
How to read this

Below 85%: the contract must pay CMS the shortfall (a remittance). Three years in a row brings an enrollment sanction; five, a termination. Usually a sign the contract was very profitable.

Very high MLR (above about 92%): little left for administration and margin; a sign of financial strain.

MLR shown is CMS's adjusted MLR (with the credibility adjustment small contracts get). Admin is non-claims costs as a share of revenue.

Parent organization 2023revenue-weighted20222021 Contracts below 85%2023 Remittance owedall years Revenue2023
UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 70 contracts 89.1%87.8%89.4% 2 $352M $173B
Humana Inc. 48 contracts 91.0%89.2%90.2% 2 $8.1M $97.0B
CVS Health Corporation 38 contracts 90.0%87.3%88.5% 1 $103M $57.4B
Elevance Health, Inc. 44 contracts 91.7%93.4%93.7% 1 $6.0M $34.2B
Centene Corporation 87 contracts 88.8%88.4%92.4% 15 $107M $28.5B
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc. 8 contracts 96.6%98.8%98.2% $26.5B
Health Care Service Corporation 27 contracts 91.5%93.3%93.9% $17.2B
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Mutual Ins. Co. 6 contracts 91.2%100.9%94.9% $9.4B
Highmark Health 9 contracts 89.0%90.2%90.3% 1 $35.1M $5.9B
SCAN Group 4 contracts 92.0%94.4%93.3% $5.1B
Healthfirst, Inc. 1 contract 86.0%87.8%88.4% $4.8B
Molina Healthcare, Inc. 17 contracts 93.1%92.8%92.7% $1.7M $4.3B
Guidewell Mutual Holding Corporation 6 contracts 93.2%94.9%90.4% 1 $553K $4.2B
UPMC Health System 3 contracts 92.9%89.8%92.0% $3.1B
MHH Healthcare, L.P. 3 contracts 90.1%87.1%88.6% $3.1B
Corewell Health 3 contracts 95.1%97.7%95.0% $2.9B
Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. 4 contracts 90.4%90.6%90.4% $2.8B
BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee 2 contracts 88.0%86.8%86.2% $3.5M $2.5B
California Physicians' Service 4 contracts 93.7%95.0%97.3% $2.4B
Independence Health Group, Inc. 3 contracts 87.4%89.3%92.5% $2.1B
Devoted Health, Inc. 18 contracts 90.0%92.7%103.8% $2.0B
Point32Health, Inc. 4 contracts 91.8%100.2%100.4% $1.9B
Aware Integrated, Inc. 2 contracts 95.8%90.3%93.6% $1.8B
Alignment Healthcare USA, LLC 5 contracts 89.8%92.1%94.1% $1.7B
Risant Health, Inc. 3 contracts 96.7%101.0%97.7% $1.7B
Cambia Health Solutions, Inc. 10 contracts 92.0%93.0%91.9% $1.7B
UCare Minnesota 4 contracts 93.6%93.1%92.7% $1.5B
CuraCor Solutions Corp. 3 contracts 93.4%92.9%92.6% $1.4B
BlueCross BlueShield of Alabama 2 contracts 94.4%93.8%93.7% $1.4B
Clover Health Holdings, Inc. 2 contracts 87.4%99.2%102.7% $1.3B
EmblemHealth, Inc. 1 contract 94.1%93.3%96.4% $1.3B
Henry Ford Health System 2 contracts 91.6%97.0%97.5% $1.1B
Independent Health Association, Inc. 3 contracts 94.6%125.4%122.2% $1.0B
Group 1001 1 contract 99.4%96.0%97.8% $991M
Lumeris Group Holdings Corporation 3 contracts 88.7%93.9%100.1% $986M
Triton Health Systems, L.L.C. 1 contract 89.5%88.0%87.7% $954M
Rite Aid Corporation 1 contract 97.7%103.7%101.8% $945M
Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island 2 contracts 88.7%93.8%94.0% $940M
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc. 2 contracts 94.1%93.1%93.4% $892M
Providence St Joseph Health 1 contract 88.7%89.3%89.5% $848M
LMC Family Holdings, LLC 1 contract 92.0%93.7%— $845M
Network Health, Inc. 1 contract 88.3%87.5%88.0% $808M
Sanford Health 6 contracts 94.9%99.3%88.8% $792M
MVP Health Care, Inc. 2 contracts 96.8%93.8%92.8% $745M
Medica Holding Company 6 contracts 98.0%96.6%98.8% $732M
Gemstone Holdings, Inc. 1 contract 96.1%99.0%97.5% $728M
MEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO 3 contracts 90.2%91.7%93.7% $727M
Presbyterian Healthcare Services 2 contracts 108.8%98.1%98.9% $726M
Martin's Point Health Care, Inc. 2 contracts 95.6%100.9%96.8% $719M
Sentara Health Care (SHC) 2 contracts 100.2%102.6%103.4% $681M
Trinity Health Corporation 4 contracts 94.6%100.8%93.8% $605M
Louisiana Health Service & Indemnity Company 5 contracts 100.5%94.0%95.1% $590M
Intermountain Health Care, Inc. 2 contracts 99.6%93.4%88.8% $575M
PacificSource 2 contracts 93.2%88.6%90.1% $569M
Horizon Mutual Holdings, Inc 2 contracts 104.6%102.8%102.2% $567M
The Carle Foundation 4 contracts 98.5%96.0%94.8% $526M
HealthPartners, Inc. 1 contract 99.9%95.0%95.8% $523M
Health First Shared Services, Inc. 1 contract 85.0%94.3%86.3% $512M
Hawaii Medical Service Association 1 contract 94.9%96.8%88.6% $499M
CAPITAL BLUE CROSS 3 contracts 95.7%96.3%98.0% $497M
Baylor Scott & White Health 2 contracts 89.1%92.5%99.1% $457M
St Francis Health System & St John Health System 2 contracts 92.4%90.2%91.1% $450M
Banner Health 4 contracts 95.2%106.8%105.4% $420M
Universal Health Services, Inc. 2 contracts 93.6%100.6%98.5% $399M
Premera 2 contracts 96.0%101.8%97.3% $393M
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City 2 contracts 102.1%98.5%96.2% $377M
University of Wisconsin Hospitals and Clincs Autho 2 contracts 94.5%97.2%95.3% $363M
General Catalyst Group Management Holdings LP 1 contract 88.0%85.5%89.2% $351M
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona 4 contracts 97.8%106.2%102.0% $349M
Mercy Care 1 contract 91.6%108.1%109.8% $347M
USAble Mutual Insurance Company 5 contracts 95.4%91.9%93.7% $315M
Elevance Health, Inc. & BCBSMA & BCBSRI & BCBSVT 1 contract 87.6%91.1%92.5% $299M
Thomas Jefferson University 1 contract 85.0%84.9%90.0% $294K $294M
BCBS MN, MT, NE, ND, WY, Wellmark IA and SD 1 contract 87.7%88.5%88.0% $292M
BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina (BCBSSC) 2 contracts 97.3%92.4%92.0% $37.0K $288M
Elderplan, Inc. 1 contract 89.0%92.0%93.1% $285M
Ultimate Healthcare Holdings, LLC 1 contract 87.6%85.5%94.9% $251M
ATRIO Health Plans 2 contracts 99.1%89.3%92.4% $246M
Allina Health and Aetna Insurance Holding Company 1 contract 87.5%85.4%90.5% $241M
Community Health Plan of Washington 1 contract 102.1%98.3%98.9% $241M
Visiting Nurse Service of New York 1 contract 88.3%96.5%— $229M
Johns Hopkins Healthcare LLC 2 contracts 104.1%103.5%104.2% $223M
Aultman Health Foundation 1 contract 95.6%92.6%93.9% $195M
Clever Care Health Plan, Inc. 1 contract 100.6%110.7%99.0% $194M
DOCTORS HEALTHCARE PLANS, INC. 1 contract 95.5%99.3%98.5% $192M
New York City Health and Hospitals Corporation 1 contract 91.7%90.8%96.6% $191M
Commonwealth of PA Pub Schools Retirement System 1 contract 102.0%98.1%92.7% $177M
Fallon Community Health Plan, Inc. 1 contract 96.6%95.5%86.6% $173M
Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company 1 contract 85.6%91.6%122.6% $169M
BayCare Health System, Inc. 1 contract 106.8%108.9%119.9% $169M
The Cigna Group 1 contract 88.3%90.7%91.2% $167M
The Health Plan of West Virginia, Inc. 2 contracts 90.6%101.4%96.5% $157M
Texas Health Resources 2 contracts 99.3%95.2%93.6% $148M
Sharp Healthcare 1 contract 96.5%95.2%98.0% $140M
Baystate Health, Inc. 2 contracts 93.5%123.2%95.3% $131M
Zing Health Consolidator, Inc 3 contracts 99.2%104.7%91.3% $128M
CareFirst, Inc. 2 contracts 102.7%93.4%92.2% $117M
LifeBridge Health, Inc. 1 contract 102.4%95.0%— $105M
Imperial Health Plan of California 2 contracts 97.7%97.1%95.9% $104M
Denver Health and Hospital Authority 1 contract 97.5%100.1%114.2% $100M
Montage Health 1 contract 94.7%96.4%98.9% $97.5M
University of Michigan Health 1 contract 95.6%100.9%105.6% $94.4M
HealthPartners UnityPoint Health, Inc. 1 contract 91.6%110.9%107.1% $93.0M
Chinese Hospital Association 1 contract 94.1%93.1%91.0% $92.9M
Associated Care Ventures, Inc. 1 contract 87.8%87.4%87.6% $92.5M
Moda Partners, Inc. 2 contracts 109.3%107.9%106.7% $91.8M
Molina Healthcare, Inc., 2 contracts 97.4%111.1%— $90.7M
Samaritan Health Services, Inc. 1 contract 96.4%99.4%85.9% $89.5M
Village Care of New York, Inc. 1 contract 94.8%99.0%114.2% $88.9M
Memorial Hermann Health System 1 contract 100.4%99.9%94.3% $84.6M
UNICO Services, Inc. 2 contracts 87.8%90.0%85.5% $298K $82.8M
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Nebraska 1 contract 115.3%114.5%104.6% $81.6M
SNP Holdings, LLC 1 contract 96.1%85.0%89.1% $78.5M
AllCare Health, Inc. 1 contract 96.4%91.8%95.5% $76.3M
Mitchell Family Office 3 contracts 90.1%91.7%91.0% $75.4M
Astiva Health Holdings Incorporated 1 contract 85.7%85.9%85.6% $63.5M
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Kansas 2 contracts 95.4%96.5%96.9% $61.8M
CareSource 2 contracts 107.8%107.7%112.8% $60.3M
Commonwealth Care Alliance, Inc. 4 contracts 98.2%101.6%95.1% $54.1M
Athena Healthcare Holdings, LLC 1 contract 91.9%89.3%97.5% $53.0M
CHRISTUS Health 1 contract 112.4%118.1%124.0% $52.1M
Select Founders, LLC 1 contract 85.4%87.2%85.3% $48.1M
Hamaspik of Rockland County, Inc. 1 contract 104.5%103.1%125.2% $43.5M
Troy Holdings, Inc. 1 contract 89.5%88.3%94.8% $42.5M
Mary Washington Healthcare 1 contract 108.0%111.9%124.5% $40.2M
Ochsner Clinic Foundation 1 contract 88.3%88.0%— $34.3M
Independent Living Systems, LLC 1 contract 103.3%139.0%— $30.9M
Western Health Advantage 1 contract 95.1%88.3%94.0% $30.7M
Liberty Healthcare Insurance 1 contract 93.2%85.0%— $29.3M
Rifkin Managed Care Holding, LLC 1 contract 92.0%—— $28.3M
Kansas Superior Select 1 contract 91.4%92.2%— $23.8M
Marquis Companies I, Inc. 1 contract 88.1%88.6%— $22.4M
Curana Health Holdings, LLC 1 contract 92.5%88.0%— $20.2M
NJ Collaborative Care, LLC 1 contract 91.0%109.3%100.7% $18.8M
Oscar Health, Inc. 1 contract 96.2%110.5%121.1% $17.3M
Perennial Consortium, LLC 1 contract 93.8%94.6%118.0% $16.9M
Tennessee Rural Health Improvement Association 2 contracts 150.5%132.1%125.2% $16.8M
University of Utah 1 contract 113.7%97.3%— $16.6M
McLaren Health Care Corporation 1 contract 110.6%138.3%— $16.3M
Gold Kidney Health Plan 1 contract 98.3%—— $15.1M
ParkerCare New York, LLC 1 contract 133.8%102.5%117.2% $13.6M
SIHO Holding, Inc. 2 contracts 136.9%—— $13.4M
Central Mass Health Holding LLC 1 contract 108.5%140.4%— $12.8M
BMC Health System, Inc. 1 contract 91.0%—— $11.8M
MedImpact Holdings, Inc. 1 contract 337.5%100.0%100.0% $10.4M
Aspirus, Inc. 1 contract 103.7%99.2%96.7% $9.6M
Avian Health Holdings, LLC 1 contract 149.1%—— $8.7M
Mass General Brigham Incorporated 1 contract 126.7%—— $8.3M
Educators Mutual Insurance Association 1 contract 86.1%85.7%87.3% $6.0M

149 rows. Red = below 85%. PACE organizations don't file MLR reports.