Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Star measuresDisplay measuresHEDISWhy members leave

Why members leave › CVS Health Corporation

Why members leave CVS Health Corporation

MA contracts only. Compared with all MA contracts nationally. Parent organization profile →

14.9%
i
Leave rate

Share of members who chose to leave during 2025 (2027 Star Ratings measure "Members Choosing to Leave the Plan"), averaged across this parent's 39 rated MA contracts weighted by current members.

National: 14.3%.

chose to leave in 2025 (national 14.3%); +4.2 pts vs 2024
4,181,196
members in 42 contracts (−0.3% in 12 months)

Reasons given (2024 leavers)
i
Reasons vs national

CMS's composite score (0–100) for each reason: the average share of surveyed leavers answering "yes" to the related questions (Disenrollment Reasons Survey, 2026 Star Ratings data). This parent's contracts are averaged by members, next to CMS's published national average for MA contracts. CMS hides a contract's score when it has fewer than 30 responses, is unreliable, or is not statistically different from the national average, so published scores lean toward contracts that stand out, and averages here are over those published scores only.

Red = at least 5 points above national.

ReasonCVS Health CorporationNationalDifference
Financial reasons
premium or drug copay went up, found a plan that costs less, more expensive than expected, could no longer afford it
20.9% 19% +1.9
Doctors and hospitals
the doctors, other providers, clinics or hospitals they wanted were not covered by the plan
13.7% 23% −9.3
Getting care approved and paid
frustrated by the approval process for care, problems getting needed care, problems getting a claim paid, hard to learn what's covered or what it costs
10.9% 15% −4.1
Prescription drug coverage
drug list changed, a prescribed drug was refused or hard to get, hard to get brand-name drugs, approval process for non-formulary drugs
7.6% 8% −0.4
Information and help
couldn't get information or help, a question or complaint handled badly, customer service not courteous
8.9% 11% −2.1

Leave rate vs national
i
Trend

Member-weighted leave rate by the year members left, for this parent and all MA contracts. Weights are current members.

Contracts
i
Contract detail

Leave rate: 2027 Star Ratings (left in 2025); "Stars" is the contract's star rating on that measure. Reasons: 2026 survey (left in 2024). Red = at least 5 points worse than national. Click a contract for its full history.

Contract Stars CostDoctors & hospitalsCare approval & paymentDrug coverageInfo & help
National14.3%19%CMS23%CMS15%CMS8%CMS11%CMS
H8597Aetna Medicare 13,523−24.4% 46%−1 1 —————
H3928Aetna Medicare 4,91232.3% 38%−2 1 33%14%16%——
H4711Aetna Medicare 8,271−12.6% 37%−5 2 7%18%11%——
H1206Aetna Medicare 4,53547.4% 37%— 2 —————
H3146Aetna Medicare 57,507−7.0% 36%+2 2 18%16%12%—13%
H4523Aetna Medicare 39,62421.9% 35%+9 2 —————
H5325Aetna Medicare 18,860−10.6% 35%+9 2 11%26%——10%
H2293Aetna Medicare 115,141−16.3% 35%+21 2 17%9%12%—10%
H4835Aetna Medicare 3,69440.6% 34%+11 2 26%7%9%—8%
H3288Aetna Medicare 68,5643.0% 32%+10 2 25%15%11%—12%
H3239Aetna Medicare 53,90240.8% 31%−4 2 11%24%——14%
H1609Aetna Medicare 121,173−8.0% 31%+11 2 15%37%20%—14%
H5302Aetna Medicare 45,25479.3% 31%−2 2 —————
H0523Aetna Medicare 11,124−22.4% 27%0 3 13%41%21%—15%
H1608Aetna Medicare 118,226−20.2% 27%+9 3 18%18%11%—9%
H5593Aetna Medicare 4,02930.2% 25%−15 3 13%23%8%—9%
H3931Aetna Medicare 70,785−35.7% 25%+7 3 20%18%——14%
H4982Aetna Medicare 9,288−51.1% 25%−4 3 8%39%17%—13%
H2663Aetna Medicare 115,432−10.2% 25%+2 3 18%9%15%—11%
H1692Aetna Medicare 21,6263.3% 25%−2 3 17%13%11%—11%
H7301Aetna Medicare 97,5252.4% 24%+7 3 18%25%11%—9%
H6399Aetna Medicare 7,26830.0% 24%+16 3 7%26%———
H3192Aetna Medicare 29,011−26.7% 24%−7 3 15%17%14%—14%
H3312Aetna Medicare 105,06927.3% 22%−1 3 13%24%12%6%9%
H0628Aetna Medicare 135,43245.1% 22%−6 3 14%14%11%9%8%
H3959Aetna Medicare 205,750−2.5% 19%0 3 23%11%6%—11%
H5521Aetna Medicare 1,043,255−6.0% 18%+12 3 23%15%15%9%7%
H2056Aetna Medicare 8,2754.0% 18%+3 3 20%23%12%7%10%
H1109Aetna Medicare 1,80377.5% 18%+6 3 —————
H1610Aetna Medicare 10,909−37.5% 17%−1 4 8%28%——17%
H9431Aetna Medicare 666−48.8% 16%+12 4 27%16%——15%
H3748Aetna Medicare 4,321−44.8% 13%0 4 17%12%8%6%7%
H7149Aetna Medicare 9,9082.2% 12%−32 4 12%52%17%10%9%
H3152Aetna Medicare 30,67414.8% 9%+1 4 21%17%11%—9%
H3597Aetna Medicare 22,8530.4% 8%−6 5 18%11%14%—11%
H5793Aetna Medicare 63,18289.4% 4%−18 5 18%15%12%20%18%
R6694Aetna Medicare 899−33.5% 3%−6 5 —————
H8649Aetna Medicare 1,503−71.0% 1%−20 5 21%30%16%10%9%
H5522Aetna Medicare 1,452,8591.9% 1%0 5 23%8%7%6%8%
H9314Aetna Medicare HIDE 16,398— —— — —————
H9771Aetna Medicare FIDE 27,969— —— — —————
H8332Aetna Medicare 197−28.1% —— — 21%18%13%—12%

Click any column header to sort. "—" means CMS published no value (too few responses, plan too new, or not statistically different from national). Hover a reason header for the questions behind it.