Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Revenue & risk scoresPart D resultsMedical loss ratioWhere the money goesPremiums & MOOPBenefitsACOs

Medical loss ratio

The share of revenue each contract spent on claims and quality improvement, as reported to CMS, 2021–2023.

These figures are about 3 years old. CMS publishes MLR well after the year closes: the latest file covers 2023 and came out in 2026. Use them for patterns, not current margins. Revenue and cost detail starts with 2023.

23
contracts below 85% in 2023 (of 635) · $52.4M owed CMS · median 91.3%
49
contracts below 85% in 2022 (of 615) · $422M owed CMS · median 90.9%
23
contracts below 85% in 2021 (of 564) · $143M owed CMS · median 92.1%
How to read this

Below 85%: the contract must pay CMS the shortfall (a remittance). Three years in a row brings an enrollment sanction; five, a termination. Usually a sign the contract was very profitable.

Very high MLR (above about 92%): little left for administration and margin; a sign of financial strain.

MLR shown is CMS's adjusted MLR (with the credibility adjustment small contracts get). Admin is non-claims costs as a share of revenue.

Parent: Health Care Service Corporation ×
2023care spend PMPM
i
Care spend per member

What the contract spent on members' care in 2023, per member per month: claims plus quality-improvement spending (the top of the MLR fraction), divided by member-months. Published only from 2023.

20222021 Years below 85% Remittance owedall years Revenue2023 Admin% of revenue · PMPM
i
Admin costs

Everything the contract spent that wasn't a claim, as a share of its revenue (line 5.7 of the MLR form, "total non-claims costs"): claims processing and cost-containment staff, sales staff, agent and broker commissions, general overhead, and some taxes and fees. A high share leaves less for members' care or for margin.

Includes the broker commissions in the next column.

From CMS's full MLR form, published only from 2023.

Brokers% of revenue · PMPM
i
Agent and broker commissions

Commissions and fees paid to agents and brokers who sign members up (line 5.4 of the MLR form), as a share of revenue, and per member per month (PMPM: divided by the contract's member-months). It shows how much the contract leans on paid sales channels to win and keep members.

Part of the Admin column. From CMS's full MLR form, published only from 2023.

Supplemental% of revenue · PMPM
i
Supplemental benefit spending

Claims paid for extra benefits that traditional Medicare doesn't cover (dental, vision, hearing, over-the-counter allowances, meals, transportation, fitness and similar), as a share of revenue and per member per month (line 2.1b of the MLR form ÷ revenue, and ÷ member-months). It is part of claims, so it's inside the MLR, not admin.

MA plans fund these mostly from their CMS rebates, so this shows how much of that money reaches members as tangible extras, which is often what members notice and switch plans over. Contract pages break it down by benefit.

From CMS's full MLR form, published only from 2023.

H4513 HealthSpring 85.7%$1,25885.5%87.2% $4.6B 14.0%$205.86 2.2%$31.64 5.4%$78.97
S5617 HealthSpring 96.6%$19195.9%94.7% $3.7B 5.5%$10.89 0.1%$0.15 ——
S5660 Express Scripts Medicare 93.4%$13094.0%95.0% $1.6B 3.1%$4.31 1.2%$1.66 ——
H7849 HealthSpring 97.2%$93991.4%91.5% $910M 14.6%$136.71 2.0%$18.87 7.2%$67.14
H3949 HealthSpring 85.4%$1,44885.5%89.3% $895M 16.7%$280.81 2.0%$33.59 4.1%$68.73
H0354 HealthSpring 87.6%$1,15491.0%88.8% $895M 10.4%$136.81 2.1%$27.42 4.7%$61.93
H0107 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Montana 97.1%$98986.1%87.1% $663M 5.7%$57.73 0.7%$7.46 1.3%$13.02
H8634 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of IL, NM, OK, TX 87.0%$1,17791.0%90.2% $538M 7.5%$98.78 2.7%$35.27 1.4%$18.48
S5715 HealthSpring 100.5%$14092.8%92.2% $467M 10.2%$14.20 1.0%$1.44 ——
H5410 HealthSpring 86.1%$1,00895.5%90.0% $395M 14.6%$167.38 2.1%$23.71 6.2%$71.17
H0439 HealthSpring 91.9%$1,25492.7%94.8% $373M 17.0%$227.30 2.0%$27.04 5.7%$75.56
H2108 HealthSpring 92.0%$1,57795.3%98.4% $324M 16.7%$276.63 2.0%$33.58 2.3%$37.32
H3822 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of IL, NM 95.9%$95891.2%98.1% $264M 14.4%$143.66 1.6%$15.69 2.6%$26.05
H7787 HealthSpring 95.5%$97598.4%99.3% $260M 15.7%$159.79 2.4%$24.56 1.8%$18.60
H9725 HealthSpring 86.3%$1,06586.5%90.5% $246M 17.0%$207.18 2.0%$25.03 5.1%$61.86
H4407 HealthSpring 86.0%$1,06087.7%91.1% $208M 17.2%$213.50 2.2%$27.21 5.0%$62.14
H4801 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of OK, TX 111.5%$1,637105.7%— $183M 11.8%$169.99 1.1%$15.38 1.4%$20.52
H1666 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of NM, TX 92.0%$1,03888.6%92.0% $174M 20.7%$227.32 3.4%$37.63 1.8%$19.55
H3251 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Mexico 91.3%$1,07797.0%94.1% $143M 15.4%$185.77 1.7%$20.35 2.6%$31.86
H0672 HealthSpring 89.4%$90389.7%94.1% $104M 13.4%$135.19 2.2%$22.19 5.7%$57.85
H7020 HealthSpring 85.9%$99888.8%96.3% $74.0M 17.2%$202.94 2.1%$24.75 3.5%$41.47
H8133 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas 117.2%$1,610121.1%111.0% $65.6M 14.7%$185.22 1.2%$15.20 2.3%$28.60
H9706 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas 104.8%$1,190101.8%95.6% $40.6M 14.0%$159.14 —— 2.8%$31.59
H7389 HealthSpring 86.2%$88785.5%— $26.7M 14.8%$157.17 2.0%$20.93 3.4%$35.94
H3979 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Oklahoma 97.7%$962—— $20.6M 25.2%$250.36 2.1%$20.79 3.9%$39.10
H8554 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of OK, TX 92.6%$1,130—— $12.5M 14.8%$161.23 1.4%$15.03 3.4%$36.67
H2752 HealthSpring 93.7%$1,238—— $4.7M 14.9%$211.74 1.9%$27.03 4.2%$60.41

27 rows. Red = below 85%. PACE organizations don't file MLR reports.