Part D results
CMS's year-end Part D reconciliation, 2022–2024. When a plan's actual drug costs land well above its bid, CMS shares the loss through risk sharing (the "risk corridors"); when they land well below, the plan pays CMS back. A large positive amount means the plan's drug bid was badly underpriced. 2024 is the latest year CMS has published.
How to read this
Risk sharing: positive = CMS paid the plan (costs ran over the bid by more than the corridor); negative = the plan paid CMS. These are CMS's settled figures. Plans also report risk sharing in their MLR filings, sometimes as an estimate made before CMS settled, so a filing can differ.
Per member per year: risk sharing ÷ Part D member-months × 12. Part D member-months include stand-alone drug plan (PDP) members.
CMS's reconciliation also settles reinsurance (catastrophic drug costs) and low-income cost sharing; those are pass-through subsidies, not a sign of profit or loss, so they're shown on contract pages only.
| 2024 | 2023 | 2022 | 3-year total | Per member per year2024 | Part D members2024 avg | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H1463 Health Alliance Medicare | $4.4M | $917K | $2.1M | $7.4M | $174 | 25,185 |
| H3471 Health Alliance Northwest | $1.9M | $483K | $1.3M | $3.7M | $155 | 12,523 |
| H6306 FirstMedicare Direct | $1.1M | $900K | $1.1M | $3.2M | $226 | 5,008 |
| H1737 Health Alliance Medicare | $22.7K | $21.8K | $410 | $44.9K | $43 | 531 |
| H8064 FirstMedicare Direct | −$3.3K | $0 | $5.5K | $2.2K | −$8 | 402 |
| H2591 Health Alliance Medicare | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 535 |
| S4219 Health Alliance Medicare Prescription Plan PDP | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | 825 |
Red = CMS paid the plan. Sorted by the 3-year total. Parent totals add up each contract under its current parent; CMS also publishes its own parent rollup, which can differ where contracts changed hands.