Revenue and risk scores
What CMS paid Medicare Advantage contracts, from CMS's plan payment data for 2022–2024. CMS publishes each payment year about 18 months after it ends, after the year-end reconciliation, so 2024 is the latest available. Sources and method.
i
For each plan, CMS gives an average A/B payment per member per month (PMPM), standardized to a 1.0 risk score, the plan's average risk score, and its average rebate PMPM. Estimated revenue PMPM = A/B payment × risk score + rebate, weighted by each plan's member-months from CMS's monthly enrollment files.
Checked against the revenue plans reported in their 2023 MLR filings: within about 5%, usually a little under. Part D payments are not included.
i
CMS's CMS-HCC risk score: 1.0 is the cost of an average traditional-Medicare beneficiary. A plan's score rises with sicker members and with more complete diagnosis coding; payment scales with it. The averages here are member-month weighted, as CMS reports them (after CMS's normalization and coding-intensity adjustments).
i
When a plan bids below its county benchmark, CMS returns part of the difference as a rebate, which must fund extra benefits or lower premiums. A falling rebate usually means thinner benefits the next year.
| Avg members2024 | A/B PMPMat 1.0 risk | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H3952 Independence Blue Cross | 75,108 | $1.1B$1,276 | 1.171+2.8% | $1737.1% | $935 |
| H3909 Independence Blue Cross | 34,879 | $400M$955 | 0.908+3.5% | $15717.2% | $868 |
| H4227 VISTA Health Plan Inc. | 17,116 | $308M$1,498 | 1.461+0.4% | $17720.4% | $902 |
| H5361 AmeriHealth | 3,524 | $45.7M$1,080 | 0.965— | $191— | $914 |
| H4739 First Choice VIP Care (HMO D-SNP) | 190 | $2.9M$1,287 | 1.157−8.2% | $21442.3% | $927 |
| H0738 AmeriHealth Caritas VIP Care (HMO-D-SNP) | 171 | $2.8M$1,349 | 1.22— | $188— | $952 |
| H6378 AmeriHealth Caritas VIP Care (HMO-D-SNP) | 57 | $758K$1,112 | 0.926— | $206— | $978 |
7 contracts. Medicare Advantage contracts only (CMS's Part C file). Parents are each contract's current parent, as elsewhere on this site. Members are 2024 member-months ÷ 12.