Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Star measuresDisplay measuresHEDISWhy members leave

Measures · C29 in 2024 · Part C · HD5 Health Plan Customer Service

Reviewing Appeals Decisions

AppealsHealth PlanSource: Independent Review Entity

What it measures
This rating shows how often an independent reviewer found the health plan’s decision to deny coverage to be reasonable.
How it's calculated
Percent of appeals where a plan‘s decision was “upheld” by the Independent Review Entity (IRE) (numerator) out of all the plan‘s appeals (upheld, overturned, and partially overturned appeals only) that the IRE reviewed (denominator). This is calculated as:
Data source
Independent Review Entity (IRE) Data were obtained from the Independent Review Entity (IRE) contracted by CMS for Part C appeals. The appeals used in this measure are based on the date in the calendar year the appeal was received by the IRE, not the date a decision was reached by the IRE. If a Reopening occurs and is decided prior to June 30, 2023, the Reopened decision is used in place of the Reconsideration decision. Reopenings decided on or after June 30, 2023 are not reflected in these data the original decision result is used. The results of appeals that occur beyond Level 2 (i.e., Administrative Law Judge or Medicare Appeals Council appeals) are not included in the data.
Measurement period
01/01/2022 – 12/31/2022
Better when
Higher
Weight
4 (Measures Capturing Access)
Star assignment
Clustering
Case-mix adjusted
No
In improvement measure
Yes
Used in CAI
No
Exclusions
ShowIf the minimum number of appeals (upheld + overturned + partially overturned) is ≤ 10, the result is “Not enough data available.” Dismissed and Withdrawn appeals are excluded from this measure.
Notes
This measure includes all Standard Coverage, Standard Claim, and Expedited appeals received by the IRE, regardless of the appellant. This includes appeals requested by a beneficiary, appeals requested by a party on behalf of a beneficiary, and appeals requested by non-contract providers.
Disaster policy
Higher measure star (2023-2024) for contracts with 25% or more enrolled affected by 2022 disasters.

From the 2024 Star Ratings Technical Notes (CMS).

Cut points over time

Score needed to earn each star level. Part D thresholds differ for MA-PD and standalone PDP contracts. Dotted lines and open dots: where the cut points may move for 2028.

How the 2028 cut points are projected

Each boundary moves by its median year-on-year change since 2019, capped at 5 points, the most CMS lets a non-survey cut point move in a year. It's the same projection the Star outlook uses for every contract. CMS sets real cut points from all contracts' scores each year, so treat these as a direction, not a forecast of the exact number.

StarsOrg type2027Projected 2028Move
2★MA8893+5
3★MA9699+3
4★MA98100+2
5★MA100101+1

2024 star distribution

Not rated: Not enough data available (341); Plan not required to report measure (59); No data available (29)

Cut point bands

Star yearOrg type1★2★3★4★5★
2027MA< 88 %>= 88 % to < 96 %>= 96 % to < 98 %>= 98 % to < 100 %100%
2026MA< 83 %>= 83 % to < 96 %>= 96 % to < 98 %>= 98 % to < 100 %100%
2025MA< 78 %>= 78 % to < 92 %>= 92 % to < 96 %>= 96 % to < 99 %>= 99 %
2024MA< 73 %>= 73 % to < 88 %>= 88 % to < 96 %>= 96 % to < 100 %100%
2023MA< 68 %>= 68 % to < 83 %>= 83 % to < 91 %>= 91 % to < 97 %>= 97 %
2022MA< 69 %>= 69 % to < 84 %>= 84 % to < 91 %>= 91 % to < 96 %>= 96 %
2021MANA>= 43 % to < 69 %>= 69 % to < 85 %>= 85 % to < 94 %>= 94 %
2020MA< 74%? 74% to < 81%? 81% to < 90%? 90% to < 95%? 95%
2019MA< 59%? 59% to < 78%? 78% to < 88%? 88% to < 97%? 97%
2018MA< 62%? 62% to < 76%? 76% to < 86%? 86% to < 93%? 93%
2017MA< 71%? 71% to < 77%? 77% to < 88%? 88% to < 93%? 93%
2016MA< 73%? 73% to < 85%? 85% to < 89%? 89% to < 94%? 94%
2015MA< 67%? 67% to < 77%? 77% to < 87%? 87% to < 95%? 95%

Lowest-scoring contracts, 2024

ContractParentMembersScoreStarsΔShortfall to 4★Pctile
H9191 Provider Partners Health PlansRifkin Managed Care Holding, LLC1,3394010560%
R5941 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue ShieldElevance Health, Inc.13,077601−4360%
H5943 VillageHealthSCAN Group6496410320%
H2032 Baylor Scott & White Health PlanBaylor Scott & White Health9,246681—281%
H1610 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation10,909762−2201%
H6898 Vermont Blue AdvantageBlue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Mutual Ins. Co.0772—191%
H6328 Care N' Care Insurance CompanyTexas Health Resources—7720191%
H7115 Memorial Hermann Health PlanMemorial Hermann Health System14,6027720191%
H4140 Doctors HealthCare Plans, Inc.DOCTORS HEALTHCARE PLANS, INC.27,8787820182%
H0111 WellcareCentene Corporation6,204792−1172%
H6988 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield HPElevance Health, Inc.10,164792−1172%
H5599 WellcareCentene Corporation68,655802−1163%
H2171 Care N' Care Insurance CompanyTexas Health Resources—8020163%
H3811 Samaritan Advantage Health PlansSamaritan Health Services, Inc.1,371802−3163%
H3890 Johns Hopkins Advantage MDJohns Hopkins Healthcare LLC6,7878220143%
H5859 CareOregon AdvantageCareOregon, Inc.13,070822−2143%
H6502 Blue Medicare AdvantageBlue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City—8320134%
H6399 Aetna MedicareCVS Health Corporation7,268832—134%
H8928 Fallon HealthFallon Community Health Plan, Inc.10,212832—134%
H1189 CHRISTUS Health AdvantageCHRISTUS Health8,875832−2134%
H5549 VNS Health MedicareVisiting Nurse Service of New York74,845842—125%
H1352 Blue Medicare AdvantageBlue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas City—8420125%
H5587 Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona Health ChoiceBlue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona8,603842−2125%
H3471 Health Alliance NorthwestThe Carle Foundation—852−1115%
H8142 Baylor Scott & White Health PlanBaylor Scott & White Health38,649852−2115%

History

Star yearCodeNameMeasuredWeightSource
2027C31Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2025 – 12/31/20252Independent Review Entity
2026C32Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2024 – 12/31/20242Independent Review Entity
2025C29Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2023 – 12/31/20234Independent Review Entity
2024C29Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2022 – 12/31/20224Independent Review Entity
2023C27Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2021 – 12/31/20214Independent Review Entity
2022C27Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2020 – 12/31/20202Independent Review Entity
2021C31Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2019 – 12/31/20192Independent Review Entity
2020C32Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2018– 12/31/20181.5Independent Review Entity
2019C33Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2017 – 12/31/20171.5Independent Review Entity
2018C33Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2016 – 12/31/20161.5Independent Review Entity
2017C31Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2015 - 12/31/20151.5Independent Review Entity
2016C31Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2014 - 12/31/20141.5Independent Review Entity
2015C33Reviewing Appeals Decisions01/01/2013 - 12/31/20131.5Independent Review Entity