Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Star measuresDisplay measuresHEDISWhy members leave

Measures · D04 in 2023 · Part D · DD2 Member Complaints and Changes in the Drug Plan’s Performance

Drug Plan Quality Improvement

Drug PlanQuality ImprovementSource: Star Ratings (improvement)

What it measures
This shows how much the drug plan’s performance has improved or declined from one year to the next year. If a plan receives 1 or 2 stars, it means, on average, the plan’s scores declined (got worse). If a plan receives 3 stars, it means, on average, the plan’s scores stayed about the same. If a plan receives 4 or 5 stars, it means, on average, the plan’s scores improved. Keep in mind that a plan that is already doing well in most areas may not show much improvement. It is also possible that a plan can start with low ratings, show a lot of improvement, and still not be performing very well.
How it's calculated
The numerator is the net improvement, which is a weighted sum of the number of significantly improved measures minus the number of significantly declined measures. The denominator is the sum of the weights associated with the measures eligible for the improvement measure (i.e., the measures that were included in the 2022 and 2023 Star Ratings for this contract and had no specification changes).
Data source
Star Ratings 2022 and 2023 Star Ratings
Measurement period
Not Applicable
Better when
Higher
Weight
5 (Improvement Measure)
Star assignment
Clustering
Case-mix adjusted
No
In improvement measure
No
Used in CAI
No
Exclusions
ShowContracts must have data in at least half of the measures used to calculate improvement to be rated in this measure.
Notes
Attachment H contains the formulas used to calculate the improvement measure and lists indicating which measures were used.
Disaster policy
Includes only measures which have data from both years.

From the 2023 Star Ratings Technical Notes (CMS).

Cut points over time

Score needed to earn each star level. Part D thresholds differ for MA-PD and standalone PDP contracts. Dotted lines and open dots: where the cut points may move for 2028.

How the 2028 cut points are projected

Each boundary moves by its median year-on-year change since 2019, capped at 5 points, the most CMS lets a non-survey cut point move in a year. It's the same projection the Star outlook uses for every contract. CMS sets real cut points from all contracts' scores each year, so treat these as a direction, not a forecast of the exact number.

StarsOrg type2027Projected 2028Move
2★MA-PD−0.3−0.31−0.01
3★MA-PD000
4★MA-PD0.230.27+0.04
5★MA-PD0.510.56+0.04
2★PDP−0.14−0.08+0.07
3★PDP000
4★PDP0.250.16−0.09
5★PDP0.50.54+0.04

2023 star distribution

Not rated: Not enough data available (150); Plan too new to be measured (130); No data available (28); Plan not required to report measure (6)

Cut point bands

Star yearOrg type1★2★3★4★5★
2027MA-PD< -0.296792>= -0.296792 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.231209>= 0.231209 to < 0.513866>= 0.513866
2027PDP< -0.142857>= -0.142857 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.245851>= 0.245851 to < 0.502381>= 0.502381
2026MA-PD< -0.233766>= -0.233766 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.320439>= 0.320439 to < 0.579545>= 0.579545
2026PDP< -0.183824>= -0.183824 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.330927>= 0.330927 to < 0.672727>= 0.672727
2025MA-PD< -0.218869>= -0.218869 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.242468>= 0.242468 to < 0.496603>= 0.496603
2025PDP< -0.2825>= -0.2825 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.273334>= 0.273334 to < 0.576667>= 0.576667
2024MA-PD< -0.253472>= -0.253472 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.206957>= 0.206957 to < 0.456458>= 0.456458
2024PDP< -0.123026>= -0.123026 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.175272>= 0.175272 to < 0.38356>= 0.38356
2023MA-PD< -0.325131>= -0.325131 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.159307>= 0.159307 to < 0.391045>= 0.391045
2023PDP< -0.237362>= -0.237362 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.389234>= 0.389234 to < 0.851667>= 0.851667
2022MA-PD< -0.2>= -0.2 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.428571>= 0.428571 to < 0.68421>= 0.684211
2022PDPNANA>= 0 to < 0.545455>= 0.545455 to < 0.80952>= 0.809524
2021MA-PD< -0.32>= -0.32 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.391304>= 0.391304 to < 0.592593>= 0.592593
2021PDP< -0.12>= -0.12 to < 0>= 0 to < 0.086957>= 0.086957 to < 0.407407>= 0.407407
2020MA-PD< -0.100? -0.100 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.346? 0.346 to < 0.550? 0.550
2020PDP< -0.186? -0.186 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.323? 0.323 to < 0.698? 0.698
2019MA-PD< -0.342? -0.342 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.316? 0.316 to < 0.463? 0.463
2019PDPNANA? 0.000 to < 0.341? 0.341 to < 0.512? 0.512
2018MA-PD< -0.184? -0.184 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.438? 0.438 to < 0.605? 0.605
2018PDP< -0.125? -0.125 to < 0.083? 0.083 to < 0.438? 0.438 to < 0.600? 0.600
2017MA-PD< -0.241? -0.241 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.415? 0.415 to < 0.659? 0.659
2017PDP< -0.149? -0.149 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.415? 0.415 to < 0.657? 0.657
2016MA-PD< -0.250? -0.250 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.333? 0.333 to < 0.545? 0.545
2016PDP< -0.273? -0.273 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.333? 0.333 to < 0.545? 0.545
2015MA-PD< -0.231? -0.231 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.357? 0.357 to < 0.500? 0.500
2015PDP< -0.154? -0.154 to < 0.000? 0.000 to < 0.357? 0.357 to < 0.500? 0.500

Lowest-scoring contracts, 2023

ContractParentMembersScoreStarsΔShortfall to 4★Pctile

History

Star yearCodeNameMeasuredWeightSource
2027D04Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2026D04Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2025D04Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2024D04Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2023D04Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2022D04Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2021D06Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2020D06Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2019D06Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2018D07Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2017D07Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2016D07Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)
2015D05Drug Plan Quality ImprovementNot Applicable5Star Ratings (improvement)