Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Star measuresDisplay measuresHEDISWhy members leave

Measures · D03 in 2023 · Part D · DD2 Member Complaints and Changes in the Drug Plan’s Performance

Members Choosing to Leave the Plan

Drug PlanRetentionSource: Enrollment Data

What it measures
Percent of plan members who chose to leave the plan.
How it's calculated
The percent of members who chose to leave the contract comes from disenrollment reason codes in Medicare’s enrollment system. The percent is calculated as the number of members who chose to leave the contract between January 1, 2021–December 31, 2021 (numerator) divided by all members enrolled in the contract at any time during 2021 (denominator).
Data source
MBDSS Medicare Beneficiary Database Suite of Systems (MBDSS)
Measurement period
01/01/2021 – 12/31/2021
Better when
Lower
Weight
4 (Patients’ Experience and Complaints Measure)
Star assignment
Clustering
Case-mix adjusted
No
In improvement measure
Yes
Used in CAI
No
Exclusions
ShowMembers who involuntarily left their contract due to circumstances beyond their control are removed from the final numerator, specifically: • Members affected by a contract service area reduction • Members affected by PBP termination • Members in PBPs that were granted special enrollment exceptions • Members affected by PBP service area reductions where there are no PBPs left within the contract that the enrollee is eligible to enroll into • Members affected by LIS reassignments • Members who are enrolled in employer group plans • Members who were passively enrolled into a Demonstration (MMP) • Contracts with less than 1,000 enrollees • 1876 Cost contract disenrollments into the transition MA contract (H contract) • Members who moved out of the service area of the contract from which they disenrolled (based on the member’s address as submitted by the plan into which the member enrolled or the member’s current SSA address if there is no address submitted by the plan into which the member enrolled) or where the service area of the contract they enrolled into does not intersect with the service area of the contract from which they disenrolled.
Notes
This measure includes members with a disenrollment effective date between 1/1/2021 and 12/31/2021 who disenrolled from the contract with any one of the following disenrollment reason codes: 11 - Voluntary Disenrollment through plan 13 - Disenrollment because of enrollment in another Plan 14 - Retroactive 99 - Other (not supplied by beneficiary). If all potential members in the numerator meet one or more of the exclusion criteria, the measure result will be “Not enough data available”. The Disenrollment Reasons Survey (DRS) data available in the HPMS plan preview and in the CMS downloadable Master Table, are not used in the calculation of this measure. The DRS data are presented in each of the systems for information purposes only.
Disaster policy
Higher measure star (2022-2023) for contracts with 25% or more enrolled affected by 2021 disasters.

From the 2023 Star Ratings Technical Notes (CMS).

Cut points over time

Score needed to earn each star level. Part D thresholds differ for MA-PD and standalone PDP contracts. Dotted lines and open dots: where the cut points may move for 2028.

How the 2028 cut points are projected

Each boundary moves by its median year-on-year change since 2019, capped at 5 points, the most CMS lets a non-survey cut point move in a year. It's the same projection the Star outlook uses for every contract. CMS sets real cut points from all contracts' scores each year, so treat these as a direction, not a forecast of the exact number.

StarsOrg type2027Projected 2028Move
2★MA-PD3735−2
3★MA-PD2829+1
4★MA-PD17170
5★MA-PD880
2★PDP1312−1
3★PDP76−1
4★PDP550
5★PDP220

2023 star distribution

Not rated: Not enough data available (215); Plan too new to be measured (68); No data available (28); Plan not required to report measure (6)

Cut point bands

Star yearOrg type1★2★3★4★5★
2027MA-PD> 37 %> 28 % to <= 37 %> 17 % to <= 28 %> 8 % to <= 17 %<= 8 %
2027PDP> 13 %> 7 % to <= 13 %> 5 % to <= 7 %> 2 % to <= 5 %<= 2 %
2026MA-PD> 39 %> 28 % to <= 39 %> 17 % to <= 28 %> 8 % to <= 17 %<= 8 %
2026PDP> 17 %> 11 % to <= 17 %> 5 % to <= 11 %> 3 % to <= 5 %<= 3 %
2025MA-PD> 36 %> 24 % to <= 36 %> 17 % to <= 24 %> 8 % to <= 17 %<= 8 %
2025PDP> 22 %> 16 % to <= 22 %> 9 % to <= 16 %> 5 % to <= 9 %<= 5 %
2024MA-PD> 41 %> 29 % to <= 41 %> 18 % to <= 29 %> 10 % to <= 18 %<= 10 %
2024PDP> 25 %> 17 % to <= 25 %> 11 % to <= 17 %> 7 % to <= 11 %<= 7 %
2023MA-PD> 39 %> 24 % to <= 39 %> 15 % to <= 24 %> 7 % to <= 15 %<= 7 %
2023PDP> 23 %> 16 % to <= 23 %> 11 % to <= 16 %> 7 % to <= 11 %<= 7 %
2022MA-PD> 44 %> 29 % to <= 44 %> 16 % to <= 29 %> 9 % to <= 16 %<= 9 %
2022PDP> 20 %> 13 % to <= 20 %> 9 % to <= 13 %> 6 % to <= 9 %<= 6 %
2021MA-PD> 38 %> 28 % to <= 38 %> 17 % to <= 28 %> 8 % to <= 17 %<= 8 %
2021PDP> 21 %> 15 % to <= 21 %> 13 % to <= 15 %> 8 % to <= 13 %<= 8 %
2020MA-PD> 42%> 24% to ? 42%> 15% to ? 24%> 5% to ? 15%? 5%
2020PDP> 15%> 12% to ? 15%> 8% to ? 12%> 6% to ? 8%? 6%
2019MA-PD> 23%> 18% to ? 23%> 11% to ? 18%> 6% to ? 11%? 6%
2019PDP> 24%> 15% to ? 24%> 10% to ? 15%> 6% to ? 10%? 6%
2018MA-PD> 28%> 18% to ? 28%> 13% to ? 18%> 8% to ? 13%? 8%
2018PDP> 15%> 11% to ? 15%> 7% to ? 11%> 2% to ? 7%? 2%
2017MA-PD> 47%> 24% to ? 47%> 17% to ? 24%> 9% to ? 17%? 9%
2017PDP> 25%> 15% to ? 25%> 12% to ? 15%> 7% to ? 12%? 7%
2016MA-PD> 31%> 23% to ? 31%> 16% to ? 23%> 10% to ? 16%? 10%
2016PDP> 23%> 13% to ? 23%> 9% to ? 13%> 5% to ? 9%? 5%
2015MA-PD> 46%> 29% to ? 46%> 16% to ? 29%> 9% to ? 16%? 9%
2015PDP> 20%> 15% to ? 20%> 8% to ? 15%> 4% to ? 8%? 4%

Lowest-scoring contracts, 2023

ContractParentMembersScoreStarsΔShortfall to 4★Pctile
H1426 CCA Health CaliforniaCommonwealth Care Alliance, Inc.—571−3420%
S7126 Mutual of Omaha RxMutual of Omaha Insurance Company—4410330%
R3175 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc.0561−4410%
H8343 Amerigroup Insurance CompanyElevance Health, Inc.—551—400%
H9428 WellcareCentene Corporation—551—400%
H3047 WellcareCentene Corporation—541—391%
H7323 WellcareCentene Corporation2,0175310381%
H7163 Primewell Health ServicesLouisiana Health Service & Indemnity Company—521—371%
H6975 WellcareCentene Corporation—501—351%
H0270 WellcareCentene Corporation631501—351%
H6713 WellcareCentene Corporation—491—342%
H8553 WellcareCentene Corporation—471—322%
H7518 WellcareCentene Corporation3,236461—312%
H0982 Solis Health PlansAthena Healthcare Holdings, LLC26,276461−1312%
H3071 Clear Spring HealthGroup 1001—461−2312%
H3975 WellcareCentene Corporation3,494461—312%
H4699 WellcareCentene Corporation—441—293%
H9460 HealthSpringHealth Care Service Corporation1,325441−2293%
H9335 WellcareCentene Corporation—441—293%
S6946 Clear Spring HealthGroup 1001—3910283%
H0724 WellcareCentene Corporation0431−2283%
H7175 WellcareCentene Corporation—431−1283%
H4847 WellcareCentene Corporation7,138421−1274%
H1947 Healthy BlueElevance Health, Inc.3,4864220274%
H5410 HealthSpringHealth Care Service Corporation15,658421−4274%

History

Star yearCodeNameMeasuredWeightSource
2027D03Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2025 – 12/31/20252Enrollment Data
2026D03Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2024 – 12/31/20242Enrollment Data
2025D03Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2023 – 12/31/20234Enrollment Data
2024D03Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2022 – 12/31/20224Enrollment Data
2023D03Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2021 – 12/31/20214Enrollment Data
2022D03Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2020 – 12/31/20202Enrollment Data
2021D05Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2019 – 12/31/20192Enrollment Data
2020D05Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2018 – 12/31/20181.5Enrollment Data
2019D05Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2017 – 12/31/20171.5Enrollment Data
2018D05Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2016 – 12/31/20161.5Enrollment Data
2017D05Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2015 - 12/31/20151.5Enrollment Data
2016D05Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2014 - 12/31/20141.5Enrollment Data
2015D04Members Choosing to Leave the Plan01/01/2013 - 12/31/20131.5Enrollment Data