Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Star measuresDisplay measuresHEDISWhy members leave

Measures · D10 in 2016 · Part D · DD4 Drug Safety and Accuracy of Drug Pricing

MPF Price Accuracy

Drug PlanPricing AccuracySource: Prescription Drug Events

What it measures
A score comparing the prices members actually pay for their drugs to the drug prices the plan provided for this Website (Medicare’s Plan Finder Website). (Higher scores are better because they mean the plan provided more accurate prices.)
How it's calculated
This measure evaluates the accuracy of drug prices posted on the MPF tool. A contract’s score is based on the accuracy index. The accuracy price index compares point-of-sale PDE prices to plan-reported MPF prices and determines the magnitude of differences found. Using each PDE’s date of service, the price displayed on MPF is compared to the PDE price. The accuracy index considers both ingredient cost and dispensing fee and measures the amount that the PDE price is higher than the MPF price. Therefore, prices that are overstated on MPF—that is, the reported price is higher than the actual price—will not count against a plan’s accuracy score. The index is computed as: (Total amount that PDE is higher than PF + Total PDE cost) / (Total PDE cost). The best possible accuracy index is 1. An index of 1 indicates that a plan did not have PDE prices greater than MPF prices. A contract’s score is computed using its accuracy index as: 100 – ((accuracy index - 1) x 100).
Data source
PDE data, MPF Pricing Files, HPMS approved formulary extracts, and data from First Data were obtained from a number of sources: PDE data, MPF Pricing Files, HPMS approved formulary extracts. Post-reconciliation PDE adjustments are not reflected in this measure.
Measurement period
01/01/2014 - 09/30/2014
Better when
Higher
Weight
1 (Process Measure)
Star assignment
Clustering
Case-mix adjusted
—
In improvement measure
No
Used in CAI
—
Exclusions
ShowA contract with less than 30 PDE claims over the measurement period. PDEs must also meet the following criteria: • Pharmacy number on PDE must appear in MPF pharmacy cost file as either a retail- only pharmacy or a retail and limited access-only pharmacy (PDE with pharmacy numbers reported as non-retail pharmacy types or both retail and mail order/HI/LTC are excluded) • Drug must appear in formulary file and in MPF pricing file • PDE must be a 30 day supply • Date of service must occur at a time that data are not suppressed for the plan on MPF • PDE must not be a compound claim • PDE must not be a non-covered drug
Notes
Please see Attachment M: Methodology for Price Accuracy Measure for more information about this measure.

From the 2016 Star Ratings Technical Notes (CMS).

Cut points over time

Score needed to earn each star level. Part D thresholds differ for MA-PD and standalone PDP contracts. Dotted lines and open dots: where the cut points may move for 2028.

How the 2028 cut points are projected

Each boundary moves by its median year-on-year change since 2019, capped at 5 points, the most CMS lets a non-survey cut point move in a year. It's the same projection the Star outlook uses for every contract. CMS sets real cut points from all contracts' scores each year, so treat these as a direction, not a forecast of the exact number.

StarsOrg type2027Projected 2028Move
2★MA-PD97100+3
3★MA-PD98100+2
4★MA-PD99990
5★MA-PD1001000
2★PDP8788+1
3★PDP98100+2
4★PDP99990
5★PDP1001000

2016 star distribution

Not rated: Plan too new to be measured (102); No data available (29); Not enough data available (20); Plan not required to report measure (13)

Cut point bands

Star yearOrg type1★2★3★4★5★
2027MA-PD< 97>= 97 to < 98>= 98 to < 99>= 99 to < 100>= 100
2027PDP< 87>= 87 to < 98>= 98 to < 99>= 99 to < 100>= 100
2026MA-PD< 92>= 92 to < 93>= 93 to < 94>= 94 to < 99>= 99
2026PDP< 92>= 92 to < 93>= 93 to < 94>= 94 to < 99>= 99
2025MA-PD< 97>= 97 to < 98>= 98 to < 99>= 99 to < 100>= 100
2025PDP< 97>= 97 to < 98>= 98 to < 99>= 99 to < 100>= 100
2024MA-PD< 94>= 94 to < 96>= 96 to < 98>= 98 to < 99>= 99
2024PDP< 96>= 96 to < 97>= 97 to < 98>= 98 to < 99>= 99
2023MA-PD< 72>= 72 to < 86>= 86 to < 93>= 93 to < 97>= 97
2023PDP< 90>= 90 to < 94>= 94 to < 96>= 96 to < 99>= 99
2022MA-PD< 73>= 73 to < 83>= 83 to < 91>= 91 to < 96>= 96
2022PDP< 84>= 84 to < 88>= 88 to < 94>= 94 to < 97>= 97
2021MA-PDNANA>= 93 to < 97>= 97 to < 99>= 99
2021PDPNANANA>= 97 to < 99>= 99
2020MA-PDNANA? 92 to < 97? 97 to < 99? 99
2020PDPNANA? 96 to < 98? 98 to < 99? 99
2019MA-PDNANA? 91 to < 95? 95 to < 99? 99
2019PDPNANA? 96 to < 98? 98 to < 99? 99
2018MA-PDNANA? 89 to < 95? 95 to < 99? 99
2018PDPNANANA? 97 to < 99? 99
2017MA-PD< 94? 94 to < 96? 96 to < 98? 98 to < 99? 99
2017PDPNANANA? 98 to < 99? 99
2016MA-PD< 94? 94 to < 97? 97 to < 99? 99 to < 100? 100
2016PDPNANANA? 98 to < 99? 99
2015MA-PD< 79? 79 to < 90? 90 to < 95? 95 to < 99? 99
2015PDPNANA? 97 to < 98? 98 to < 99? 99

Lowest-scoring contracts, 2016

ContractParentMembersScoreStarsΔShortfall to 4★Pctile
S7694 Elixir InsuranceRite Aid Corporation—984−110%
H5989 Healthfirst Medicare PlanHealthfirst, Inc.12,756911−480%
S5921 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc.2,326,418984−110%
S5884 HumanaHumana Inc.3,926,785984010%
S5768 WellCareCentene Corporation—984−110%
S4219 Health Alliance Medicare Prescription PlanThe Carle Foundation—984010%
S5966 EmblemHealthEmblemHealth, Inc.105,012984+110%
S2874 HumanaHumana Inc.—984010%
S5820 UnitedHealthcareUnitedHealth Group, Inc.355,415984−110%
S5877 EMI HealthEducators Mutual Insurance Association1,090984−110%
S5593 Highmark Blue ShieldHighmark Health17,320984−110%
S5552 HumanaHumana Inc.—984010%
S5584 Blue Cross Blue Shield of MichiganBlue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Mutual Ins. Co.24,564984−110%
H1099 Health First Health Plans, Inc.Health First Shared Services, Inc.37,197942−250%
H2230 Blue Cross Blue Shield of MassachusettsBlue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc.45,136952−240%
H2261 Blue Cross Blue Shield of MassachusettsBlue Cross and Blue Shield of Massachusetts, Inc.42,510952−240%
H8266 Constellation Health, Llc.Constellation Health, LLC.—952—40%
H9110 REGENCE BLUECROSS BLUESHIELD OF UTAHCambia Health Solutions, Inc.—952—40%
H0602 Rocky Mountain Health Maintenance OrganizationUnitedHealth Group, Inc.—962−231%
H3362 Independent HealthIndependent Health Association, Inc.41,124962−231%
H1035 Florida Blue HMOGuidewell Mutual Holding Corporation46,087962−331%
H2962 Ultimate Health PlansUltimate Healthcare Holdings, LLC22,713962−331%
H5410 HealthSpringHealth Care Service Corporation15,658962−231%
H5433 CalOptima Health OneCareOrange County Health Authority19,245962−331%
H3344 Independent HealthIndependent Health Association, Inc.4,086962−231%

History

Star yearCodeNameMeasuredWeightSource
2027D07MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2025 – 9/30/20251Prescription Drug Events
2026D07MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2024 – 9/30/20241Prescription Drug Events
2025D07MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2023 – 9/30/20231Prescription Drug Events
2024D07MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2022 – 9/30/20221
2023D07MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2021 – 9/30/20211Prescription Drug Events
2022D07MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2020 – 12/31/20201
2021D09MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2019 – 12/31/20191Prescription Drug Events
2020D09MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2018 – 09/30/20181Prescription Drug Events
2019D09MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2017 – 09/30/20171Prescription Drug Events
2018D10MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2016 – 09/30/20161Prescription Drug Events
2017D10MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2015 - 09/30/20151Prescription Drug Events
2016D10MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2014 - 09/30/20141Prescription Drug Events
2015D08MPF Price Accuracy01/01/2013 - 09/30/20131Prescription Drug Events