Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
Revenue & risk scoresPart D resultsMedical loss ratioWhere the money goesPremiums & MOOPBenefitsACOs

ACOs: who makes money, and how

Accountable care organizations earn a share of what they save Medicare against a benchmark CMS sets, and in two-sided tracks they pay back part of their losses. This page looks at where their members' spending goes, which ACOs come out ahead, and how much of the savings comes from the benchmark itself. It starts with care spending per member set side by side across Medicare Advantage, ACOs and traditional Medicare.

Care spending per member, like for like

Medicare Advantage and traditional Medicare, 2023

Parts A and B care spending per member per month

Medicare Advantage $929
Traditional Medicare $956

At a 1.0 risk score

Medicare Advantage $815
Traditional Medicare $955

MA plans spent 3% less per member on Medicare-covered care than traditional Medicare spent. Adjusted for risk scores the gap is 15%, but MA risk scores run high because MA plans record more diagnoses, so the adjusted figure overstates MA's advantage.

i
How this is counted

Medicare Advantage: what MA plans paid for Parts A and B benefits (claims incurred, from each contract's medical loss ratio filing) over its member months, all MA contracts that filed. Supplemental benefits, Part D and plan administration aren't included. Members' own cost sharing isn't included.

Traditional Medicare: what Medicare paid for Parts A and B for every aged and disabled traditional Medicare beneficiary, from CMS's county data for the MA ratebooks. Hospice is left out (Medicare pays hospice for MA members too), and so are indirect and direct medical education payments, which Medicare also pays for MA members outside the plans. People with kidney failure (ESRD) are in the MA figure but not this one; they are a small share of MA members.

At a 1.0 risk score: spending divided by the average CMS-HCC risk score. Traditional Medicare's is normalized to 1.0. MA's is the average risk score in CMS's plan payment data, weighted by member months. MA plans record diagnoses more completely than traditional Medicare's claims do, which raises MA risk scores for people in the same health. CMS cuts MA risk scores for this by law, but studies by MedPAC find the cut doesn't cover the whole difference, so the adjusted MA figure is too low by an amount nobody can measure exactly.

The year is the latest that both sources cover: MA medical loss ratio filings come out about three years after the contract year.

ACOs and traditional Medicare nearby, 2024

Parts A and B spending per member per month

Shared Savings Program ACO members $1,097
Traditional Medicare with primary care, same counties $1,099

At a 1.0 risk score

Shared Savings Program ACO members $1,099
Traditional Medicare with primary care, same counties $1,138

Shared Savings Program ACO members cost 0.1% less than traditional Medicare beneficiaries with primary care in the same counties. Their risk scores are higher, so adjusted for risk they cost 3.4% less.

i
How this is counted

ACO members: Medicare's Parts A and B spending per assigned beneficiary in each Shared Savings Program ACO, from CMS's results file, weighted by person-years.

Traditional Medicare, same counties: for each ACO, the average spending of traditional Medicare beneficiaries who had primary care (the people CMS can assign to an ACO) in the counties where its members live, by enrollment type (aged, disabled, dual eligible, ESRD), weighted by the ACO's members in each. From CMS's county file of assignable beneficiaries. This comparison group includes the ACOs' own members, who are about half of it, so the gap with people outside ACOs is larger than shown.

Both figures leave out people with no primary care visit, who cost much less; that is why they are higher than traditional Medicare's overall average. Counties where CMS hides an ACO's count are left out. ACO REACH isn't included: its risk scores are on a different scale from the county file's.

What ACOs saved and earned

ProgramYearACOsMembersBenchmarkSavedSavings ratePaid to ACOsOwed by ACOsMedicare keptEarned / owed / short / over
Shared Savings202248210,418,297 $120B$4.3B3.6% $2.5B—$1.8B 303 / 0 / 1 / 178
Shared Savings202345310,235,411 $128B$5.2B4.0% $3.1B$14.2M$2.1B 313 / 20 / 0 / 120
Shared Savings202447610,326,340 $140B$6.6B4.7% $4.1B$20.0M$2.5B 360 / 16 / 0 / 100
REACH2022991,829,027 $23.3B$533M2.3% $686M$178M$25.9M 77 / 22 / 0 / 0
REACH20231322,046,054 $27.5B$987M3.6% $1.1B$195M$63.2M 96 / 36 / 0 / 0
REACH20241152,510,749 $36.5B$1.6B4.4% $1.7B$243M$135M 96 / 19 / 0 / 0

Earned: paid shared savings. Owed: paid back part of its losses. Short: saved, but not enough to share (below its minimum savings rate) or not eligible. Over: spent above benchmark without owing anything (one-sided track, or losses within its minimum loss rate).

i
How this is counted

From CMS's Shared Savings Program and ACO REACH financial and quality results. Saved is the benchmark less actual Parts A and B spending, summed over ACOs (losses count against savings). Medicare kept is what was saved less what ACOs were paid, plus what they paid back. For REACH it is before CMS's discount, which is already taken out of the benchmark.

CMS waived shared losses for 2022 because the COVID-19 emergency covered the whole year, so no ACO owed anything that year. Results for a year come out the following late summer or fall.

How much of the savings is the benchmark

An ACO's benchmark starts from its own members' past spending, then CMS adds an adjustment: a regional adjustment that raises the benchmark when its members cost less than others in its region (and, for ACOs that started before 2024, can lower it), or, from 2024, a prior savings adjustment for ACOs that saved in earlier years. In 2024 these adjustments added $2.4B to Shared Savings Program benchmarks, against $6.6B saved in all. Of the 360 ACOs paid shared savings, 43 would have shown no savings without the adjustment.

i
How this is counted

CMS reports each ACO's regional or prior savings adjustment per beneficiary on its historical benchmark. We carry it into the performance year by the same factor CMS applies to the whole historical benchmark (updated benchmark ÷ historical benchmark), then multiply by person-years. That is close to, but not exactly, CMS's own arithmetic, since the update is applied by enrollment type.

"Would have shown no savings": per-beneficiary savings less the adjustment is zero or below. That doesn't mean the ACO did nothing: the regional adjustment is CMS's deliberate reward for already being efficient. It shows how much of the program's payout rewards an ACO's starting point rather than a fall in spending.

Risk scores matter too: the benchmark rises with members' risk scores, though CMS caps that rise at 3% over an agreement period. The ACO table below shows each ACO's risk score change since its third benchmark year against the program's, which nets out CMS's model and normalization changes.

Which ACOs come out ahead, 2024

Shared Savings Program · ACO REACH

By risk level

ACOsMembersSavings rateEarned per memberShare earningShare owing
Global (full risk)982,063,6944.4% $68984%16%
Professional (half risk)17447,0554.0% $26682%18%

By MA ownership

ACOsMembersSavings rateEarned per memberShare earningShare owing
Not MA-owned1092,270,2864.3% $59883%17%
Owned by an MA parent6240,4635.2% $74783%17%

Savings rate: saved ÷ benchmark across the group. Earned per member: shared savings paid less losses owed, per beneficiary-year.

i
The groups

Risk level: Shared Savings Program tracks Basic A and B share savings only; Basic C and D add some shared losses; Basic E and Enhanced carry the most risk and earn the highest share of savings. ACO REACH: Global takes all of the savings or losses, Professional half.

ACO type (Shared Savings Program): CMS calls an ACO high revenue when its participants' own Medicare revenue is at least 35% of its members' total Medicare spending, which in practice means one that includes a hospital; low-revenue ACOs are mostly physician practices.

Owned by an MA parent: ACOs a Medicare Advantage parent organization owns now, from our ownership research (see each ACO's page).

Where the spending goes, 2024

Spending and use per member: all ACO REACH ACOs, the quarter of ACOs with the highest savings rates and the quarter with the lowest.

All ACOsTop quarterBottom quarterTop vs bottom
Spending per member per year
Hospital inpatient $4,179$4,556 $4,549 0%
Hospital outpatient $2,778$2,547 $3,011 −15%
Physician and other Part B $4,871$5,592 $5,035 11%
Skilled nursing $896$1,051 $1,083 −3%
Home health $631$798 $667 20%
Hospice $521$709 $591 20%
Durable medical equipment $447$535 $433 24%
Ambulance $146$175 $158 11%
Use per 1,000 members a year
Hospital admissions 264305 271 12%
Emergency department visits 609647 630 3%
Skilled nursing admissions 4860 51 16%
Primary care visits 7,1288,735 7,273 20%

Quarters rank ACOs by savings rate within the program and year. The top quarter's members aren't the same people as the bottom's: some of the difference is who they serve and where.

i
How this is counted

ACO REACH reports total spending by type of service; we divide by aligned beneficiary-months ÷ 12 to put it per beneficiary-year. Admissions are per 1,000 beneficiary-years on the same basis; visits are as CMS reports them, per 1,000.

Every ACO, 2024

ACOTrackMA ownerMembersSavings rateEarnedEarned per member Capitation shareDiscount Inpatient per memberQuality
Physicians Healthcare CollaborativeStandard, Global — 109,029 11.1% $187M $1,771 3% 3.0% $3,608 78
Rancho Health Management, LLCStandard, Global — 42,746 8.2% $51.3M $1,239 2% 3.0% $3,747 39
PCMA Cooperative LLCHigh Needs, Global — 5,170 23.1% $51.2M $12,090 3% 3.0% $12,083 92
agilon health Northeastern ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 6)Standard, Global — 20,085 16.5% $48.2M $2,572 3% 3.0% $3,588 80
Castell Accountable Care, LLCStandard, Global — 50,678 7.0% $46.8M $962 2% 3.0% $3,111 100
UT Southwestern Accountable Care NetworkStandard, Professional — 119,959 5.1% $43.5M $375 0% 0.0% $3,940 97
CareMount Value Partners IPAStandard, Global UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 54,912 5.1% $43.3M $810 12% 3.0% $4,364 93
Tri-Shield Health, Inc.New Entrant, Global — 20,346 11.7% $43.1M $2,445 0% 3.0% $5,051 95
Oak Street Health Medicare Partners LLCStandard, Global CVS Health Corporation 16,497 18.7% $42.5M $3,513 1% 3.0% $5,280 56
VillageMD Primary Providers ACO II, LLCStandard, Global — 25,755 9.2% $40.2M $1,611 7% 3.0% $4,746 99
agilon health Columbus Ohio ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 1)Standard, Global — 31,307 10.0% $39.2M $1,327 1% 3.0% $3,262 100
DULY HEALTH AND CARE ACCOUNTABLE CARE ORGANIZATIONStandard, Global — 43,006 6.6% $39.1M $966 15% 3.0% $3,584 72
Iora Health NE DCE, LLC (DBA Iora Health Network)New Entrant, Global — 16,021 15.2% $39.0M $2,527 1% 3.0% $3,837 97
HarmonyCares ACO LLCHigh Needs, Global — 3,333 29.4% $36.7M $15,552 0% 3.0% $13,043 95
Complete Care Collaborative of the NortheastHigh Needs, Global — 4,180 19.1% $36.6M $11,069 2% 3.0% $14,741 96
CenterWell Care Solutions, Inc.Standard, Global Humana Inc. 21,855 12.8% $35.7M $2,196 2% 3.0% $4,244 100
APA ACO Inc.Standard, Global — 31,079 6.0% $32.5M $1,108 8% 3.0% $5,309 50
American Choice Healthcare, LLCStandard, Global — 65,752 3.0% $32.4M $513 1% 3.0% $5,018 73
Complete Health Accountable Care LLCStandard, Global — 10,234 19.7% $32.1M $3,246 3% 3.0% $3,610 75
agilon health Texas ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 7)Standard, Global — 27,174 8.0% $31.0M $1,186 3% 3.0% $3,574 100
VillageMD Primary Providers ACO III, LLCStandard, Global — 19,171 10.3% $29.9M $1,607 6% 3.0% $3,784 100
ilumed, LLCStandard, Global — 77,710 2.6% $28.9M $397 14% 3.0% $3,351 78
Reliant Medical Group, Inc.Standard, Global UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 10,305 16.2% $27.3M $2,743 11% 3.0% $5,257 87
VillageMD New Hampshire ACO, LLCStandard, Global — 8,662 18.5% $24.9M $2,940 9% 3.0% $3,589 100
Subsero Healthcare, LLC d/b/a MAX Healthcare #1Standard, Global — 9,387 16.4% $24.5M $2,869 3% 3.0% $3,700 82
VillageMD Primary Providers ACO V, LLCStandard, Global — 10,104 14.3% $23.4M $2,455 6% 3.0% $4,317 100
ATLAS IPA, LLCHigh Needs, Global — 1,609 29.5% $23.1M $19,628 4% 3.0% $20,347 41
Accountable Care Coalition of Direct Contracting, LLCStandard, Global — 32,075 4.9% $21.2M $688 3% 3.0% $3,613 100
Complete Care Academy CollaborativeHigh Needs, Global — 3,537 13.5% $20.8M $7,447 2% 3.0% $15,573 97
Bloom Health Network LLC (d/b/a Bloom Healthcare)High Needs, Global — 1,848 28.4% $19.9M $14,576 1% 3.0% $8,946 100
Humana Direct Contracting Entity, Inc.Standard, Global Humana Inc. 102,613 1.6% $19.4M $199 1% 3.0% $3,280 52
agilon health Northeast Ohio ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 2)Standard, Global — 11,352 13.3% $19.4M $1,834 1% 3.0% $3,659 100
agilon health Mid-Atlantic ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 5)Standard, Global — 10,746 14.3% $19.3M $1,984 1% 3.0% $2,779 96
CareConnectMD DCE LLCHigh Needs, Global — 2,032 23.9% $18.9M $14,258 0% 3.0% $9,863 100
VillageMD Primary Providers ACO IV, LLCStandard, Global — 20,262 6.5% $18.5M $964 10% 3.0% $3,885 100
Pathways Accountable Care, LLC d/b/a Pathways Health PartnersStandard, Global — 18,861 6.1% $18.4M $1,049 1% 3.0% $4,640 79
Indiana University Health ACO, Inc.Standard, Professional — 40,910 7.3% $17.3M $438 2% 0.0% $3,632 99
Esse Health ACO, LLCStandard, Global — 38,785 3.5% $17.1M $462 2% 3.0% $3,694 73
Bluerock Care Community LLC (DBA: Penn Ave Health)Standard, Global — 13,000 8.9% $15.8M $1,290 2% 3.0% $4,139 98
NeueHealth Community ACO, LLCStandard, Global — 20,480 6.0% $15.8M $835 5% 3.0% $4,516 19
agilon health Ohio ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 3)Standard, Global — 9,253 11.0% $14.5M $1,656 1% 3.0% $4,030 100
VillageMD Primary Providers ACO, LLCStandard, Global — 11,746 8.6% $12.6M $1,102 5% 3.0% $2,796 99
Wellvana Premier Care, LLCStandard, Global — 38,819 2.3% $12.2M $327 3% 3.0% $3,856 79
PeaceHealth Direct Contracting LLCStandard, Professional — 24,916 7.9% $11.9M $498 2% 0.0% $3,562 98
Primary Care Alliance, LLCStandard, Global — 8,210 9.7% $11.9M $1,540 2% 3.0% $3,907 99
Fairview Health ServicesStandard, Professional — 27,114 6.1% $10.6M $406 1% 0.0% $3,949 96
Accountable Care Organization of Advocate Aurora Health, LLCStandard, Global — 6,981 11.4% $10.5M $1,734 6% 3.0% $4,209 55
Mirra Reach, LLCStandard, Global — 4,574 12.8% $10.0M $2,293 3% 3.0% $5,181 52
Advanced Illness Partners, LLCHigh Needs, Global — 2,237 12.1% $9.5M $5,704 1% 3.0% $11,467 96
NeueHealth Premier ACO, LLCStandard, Global — 12,280 5.1% $9.3M $793 2% 3.0% $4,110 91
Pearl Network, LLCStandard, Global — 14,358 4.3% $9.3M $686 2% 3.0% $4,596 38
Aledade Accountable Care 128, LLCStandard, Global — 16,629 4.8% $9.2M $584 1% 3.0% $3,066 100
ACO REACH South Texas, LLCStandard, Global — 10,189 6.1% $8.9M $958 3% 3.0% $4,598 79
Optimum NY Independent Practice Association, LLCStandard, Professional — 13,981 12.0% $8.8M $692 2% 0.0% $4,314 89
Community Care Contracting, LLCStandard, Global — 15,990 4.3% $8.6M $565 2% 3.0% $3,955 97
RGV ACO Health Providers, LLCStandard, Global — 5,889 10.0% $8.6M $1,618 3% 3.0% $4,407 97
Honest ACO of Michigan LLCStandard, Global — 24,618 2.5% $8.4M $354 3% 3.0% $4,285 28
CHESS Genesis, LLCStandard, Professional — 22,723 5.9% $8.4M $388 3% 0.0% $3,489 99
United Physicians Association, IncStandard, Global — 6,028 7.6% $7.6M $1,326 2% 3.0% $4,768 100
Honest ACO of New York LLCStandard, Global — 5,970 9.6% $7.5M $1,324 3% 3.0% $3,730 95
Physician Partners ACO Reach, LLCStandard, Global — 5,372 10.3% $7.5M $1,633 2% 3.0% $4,002 97
Health Partners for the Elderly LLCStandard, Global — 7,407 5.8% $7.0M $985 2% 3.0% $4,256 72
Commonwealth Primary Care ACO LLCStandard, Global — 7,000 7.0% $6.9M $1,027 1% 3.0% $3,409 100
agilon health Pennsylvania ACO, Inc. (DBA: Senior Health Connect ACO 4)Standard, Global — 5,873 8.8% $6.5M $1,180 3% 3.0% $3,596 98
Triad HealthCare Network, LLC.Standard, Global — 20,769 2.4% $5.9M $300 1% 3.0% $3,067 98
On Belay Health Solutions, LLCStandard, Global — 10,573 3.7% $5.7M $563 3% 3.0% $4,578 29
Allina Health SystemStandard, Professional — 36,838 2.3% $5.6M $156 0% 0.0% $3,966 78
Provider Partners Connect Care, LLCHigh Needs, Global — 1,247 12.4% $5.5M $5,672 2% 3.0% $12,492 100
Accountable Care Coalition of Southeast Texas, Inc.Standard, Global — 8,355 3.9% $5.5M $684 2% 3.0% $5,553 75
CINQCARE ACO REACH LLCStandard, Global — 10,607 3.6% $5.4M $567 3% 3.0% $4,935 52
Catholic Medical Partners-Accountable Care IPA, INCStandard, Global — 9,476 4.2% $5.0M $552 2% 3.0% $3,786 74
CHS ACO Op Co LLCHigh Needs, Global — 983 14.4% $4.7M $7,797 0% 3.0% $14,429 77
Complete Care Collaborative of the SouthHigh Needs, Global — 2,048 8.7% $4.7M $4,090 2% 3.0% $11,474 100
St. Luke's Clinic Coordinated Care, LtdStandard, Global — 25,100 1.4% $4.3M $177 3% 3.0% $2,896 100
C3 REACH LLCStandard, Professional — 12,242 4.9% $4.2M $363 4% 0.0% $5,139 26
AdventHealth ACO Plus, LLCStandard, Global — 24,013 1.2% $3.9M $167 2% 3.0% $3,990 51
MNO REACH-MI LLCStandard, Global — 18,739 1.5% $3.4M $188 2% 3.0% $3,409 75
Physician Leaders Direct Contracting Entity, LLCStandard, Global — 57,124 0.3% $3.2M $59 3% 3.0% $5,605 43
Pearl Primary Care Network, LLCStandard, Professional — 62,577 0.6% $3.0M $52 2% 0.0% $4,788 93
Nivano Physicians, Inc. IPANew Entrant, Global — 3,172 5.0% $3.0M $1,067 0% 3.0% $6,175 100
Medical Home Network REACH ACOStandard, Global — 14,200 1.5% $2.9M $217 3% 3.0% $4,473 74
UpStream GAP Q, LLCStandard, Global — 29,928 0.8% $2.7M $95 1% 3.0% $3,014 72
Northern Michigan Health Network dba NPO-CINStandard, Global — 7,794 3.1% $2.6M $346 3% 3.0% $3,138 99
Asaar Medical Inc.Standard, Global — 16,551 1.0% $2.1M $137 3% 3.0% $3,628 100
Hudson Heights REACH ACO, Inc.New Entrant, Professional — 2,586 9.6% $2.0M $826 1% 0.0% $5,869 49
Innovation Care Partners REACH LLCStandard, Global — 5,782 2.1% $1.6M $290 2% 3.0% $3,117 100
CareMax Health Partners, LLCStandard, Professional — 8,547 2.4% $1.5M $182 1% 0.0% $3,965 95
Collaborative Care Partners LLCStandard, Global — 7,530 1.5% $1.4M $193 43% 3.0% $2,448 29
Renovis Choice CompanyStandard, Global — 5,464 1.3% $1.3M $265 0% 3.0% $6,982 51
Temple Care, IncStandard, Professional — 7,043 2.7% $1.3M $193 0% 0.0% $4,408 52
Q Point Health, LLC (DBA Equality Health Direct)Standard, Professional — 10,569 2.0% $1.2M $116 2% 0.0% $3,572 93
NeueHealth Advantage ACO, LLCStandard, Global — 13,927 0.5% $987K $75 3% 3.0% $4,661 91
Prime Accountable Care East LLCStandard, Global — 23,152 0.3% $754K $34 2% 3.0% $3,795 73
Nevada Care ConnectHigh Needs, Global — 1,072 1.2% $499K $622 0% 3.0% $15,768 76
Arizona Health Advantage, IncStandard, Professional — 5,268 1.3% $460K $90 3% 0.0% $3,456 100
agilon health Coastal ACO, Inc.Standard, Global — 5,429 0.5% $316K $60 3% 3.0% $3,608 96
Assurity DCE LLCHigh Needs, Global — 1,527 −0.6% −$331K −$276 0% 3.0% $13,278 41
NW Momentum Health Partners ACOStandard, Professional — 8,232 −0.9% −$389K −$49 1% 0.0% $3,550 73
America's MDE, LLCStandard, Global — 5,370 −0.5% −$406K −$82 1% 3.0% $4,725 96
Harbor Health ACO, LLCStandard, Global — 5,629 −1.8% −$1.1M −$237 2% 3.0% $4,427 74
Complete Care Collaborative of the MidwestHigh Needs, Global — 2,346 −2.3% −$1.6M −$961 2% 3.0% $13,357 94
Park Nicollet Health Services ACO LLC d/b/a HealthPartners ACOStandard, Professional HealthPartners, Inc. 34,281 −1.0% −$2.1M −$64 1% 0.0% $3,674 70
CareAllies Accountable Care Solutions, LLCStandard, Global — 4,772 −4.6% −$3.0M −$691 1% 3.0% $5,294 40
Revere Health Collaborative Network, LLCStandard, Global — 15,607 −1.5% −$3.1M −$203 1% 3.0% $3,111 100
Alignment Health ACO, LLCStandard, Global — 8,914 −2.1% −$3.1M −$362 1% 3.0% $5,145 73
PRIME HEALTHCARE ACO, LLCStandard, Professional — 9,269 −5.9% −$3.4M −$395 0% 0.0% $4,690 19
PraxisCare, Inc.Standard, Global — 11,192 −3.2% −$4.1M −$377 2% 3.0% $3,278 96
'N HEALTH NETWORK PARTNERS, LLCStandard, Global — 12,826 −2.2% −$4.2M −$346 2% 3.0% $4,778 85
Arizona Best Care Network LLCStandard, Global — 5,636 −8.0% −$4.6M −$871 1% 3.0% $3,509 70
Genuine Health Direct, LLCStandard, Global — 21,692 −1.5% −$4.7M −$238 1% 3.0% $4,524 100
P3 Health Partners REACH ACO LLCStandard, Global — 12,193 −4.9% −$7.1M −$660 2% 3.0% $4,370 73
BH ACO, LLCStandard, Global — 19,538 −2.9% −$7.7M −$424 2% 3.0% $5,217 96
North East Medical ServicesStandard, Global — 6,753 −14.9% −$9.7M −$1,624 7% 3.0% $4,891 96
CVS Accountable Care Organization, Inc.Standard, Global — 211,985 −2.4% −$77.2M −$380 1% 3.0% $4,834 97
Vytalize Health 9 ACO LLCStandard, Global — 163,558 −4.5% −$105M −$667 3% 3.0% $4,344 73

Capitation share: monthly capitation payments CMS made to the ACO as a share of its members' total cost of care. Discount: the share of the benchmark CMS keeps before any savings are shared. All per member figures are per beneficiary-year.