Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
All questionsFor vendor teamsFor health plansFor providers

Questions › Quality and Star Ratings

Which Medicare Advantage contracts fell below 4 stars for 2027?

72 Medicare Advantage contracts fell below 4 stars in CMS's 2027 Star Ratings after being rated 4 stars or higher for 2026. Together they cover 4,938,086 members across 41 parent organizations. Falling below 4 stars generally ends a contract's quality bonus payment for 2028.

35 contracts moved the other way, reaching 4 stars after being rated below 4. In all, 506 Medicare Advantage contracts received an overall rating for 2027.

The 72 contracts, largest first

ContractParent organization20262027Members
H2802 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43.5 411,900
H4513 HealthSpring Health Care Service Corporation 4.53.5 389,224
H3359 Healthfirst Medicare Plan Healthfirst, Inc. 4.53.5 361,896
H1889 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43.5 264,831
H0543 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43 248,919
H3815 Alignment Health Plan Alignment Healthcare USA, LLC 43.5 227,073
H5322 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43.5 218,947
H3959 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation 43.5 205,750
H7917 BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee 43.5 189,267
H1961 Peoples Health UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 4.53.5 157,120
H3655 Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield Elevance Health, Inc. 43.5 142,647
H0628 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation 43.5 135,432
H4141 Humana Humana Inc. 43.5 125,636
H2663 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation 43.5 115,432
H2293 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation 43.5 115,141
H0169 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43.5 102,010
H4152 Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island 43.5 74,436
H3388 CDPHP Medicare Advantage Lifetime Healthcare, Inc. 4.53.5 69,842
H5591 Martin's Point Generations Advantage Martin's Point Health Care, Inc. 43.5 62,400
H6723 Medical Mutual of Ohio MEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO 43.5 60,945
H3668 MediGold Trinity Health Corporation 4.53.5 58,574
H3146 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation 4.53.5 57,507
H3219 Allina Health Aetna Medicare Allina Health and Aetna Insurance Holding Company 43.5 57,074
H3256 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 53.5 55,269
H0432 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43.5 55,063
H0174 Wellcare Centene Corporation 43.5 50,506
H8003 Blue Cross Blue Shield of South Carolina BlueCross BlueShield of South Carolina (BCBSSC) 43.5 49,746
H7379 CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield Medicare Advantage CareFirst, Inc. 42.5 47,957
H3794 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43.5 47,369
H1035 Florida Blue HMO Guidewell Mutual Holding Corporation 43.5 46,087
H5302 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation 4.53.5 45,254
H2322 Health Alliance Plan by Henry Ford Health Henry Ford Health System 43.5 41,027
H6396 CareSource MyCare Ohio (HMO D-SNP) CareSource 4.53.5 40,849
H5932 Highmark Wholecare Medicare Assured Highmark Health 43.5 40,362
H4523 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation 43 39,624
H0302 Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona (AZ Blue) Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona 4.53.5 38,702
H4279 UPMC for Life Complete Care UPMC Health System 43.5 37,410
H6453 Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Louisiana Louisiana Health Service & Indemnity Company 43.5 35,886
H9725 HealthSpring Health Care Service Corporation 43 33,438
H0624 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43.5 32,541
H3305 MVP HEALTH CARE MVP Health Care, Inc. 43.5 27,158
H2226 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43.5 24,195
H5945 Prominence Health Plan Universal Health Services, Inc. 4.53.5 23,720
H4227 VISTA Health Plan Inc. Independence Health Group, Inc. 43.5 23,267
H2962 Ultimate Health Plans Ultimate Healthcare Holdings, LLC 43.5 22,713
H3706 GlobalHealth MHH Healthcare, L.P. 43.5 19,643
H9808 HealthTeam Advantage Risant Health, Inc. 4.53.5 19,139
H9485 Mass General Brigham Health Plan Mass General Brigham Incorporated 43.5 18,399
H7787 HealthSpring Health Care Service Corporation 43 17,914
H2425 Blue Plus Aware Integrated, Inc. 43.5 16,097
H7020 HealthSpring Health Care Service Corporation 43 15,661
H7326 Wellcare Centene Corporation 43 12,664
H1822 SCAN Health Plan SCAN Group 4.53.5 12,652
H4808 Devoted Health Devoted Health, Inc. 43 12,205
H9179 Trinity Health Plan of Michigan Trinity Health Corporation 4.53 11,074
H7220 Anthem HealthKeepers Elevance Health, Inc. 43 10,824
H8928 Fallon Health Fallon Community Health Plan, Inc. 43.5 10,212
H4847 Wellcare Centene Corporation 43 7,138
H0978 SCAN Health Plan SCAN Group 43.5 6,253
H1846 MediGold Trinity Health Corporation 43 5,911
R2604 UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealth Group, Inc. 43.5 5,593
H3928 Aetna Medicare CVS Health Corporation 43.5 4,912
H8166 Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield Highmark Health 43 4,056
H1119 Valor Health Plan The Schroer Group, Inc. 43.5 2,494
H7605 Devoted Health Devoted Health, Inc. 43.5 2,347
H6529 MyTruAdvantage SIHO Holding, Inc. 43.5 2,315
H2416 PrimeWest Health PrimeWest Rural MN Health Care Access Initiative 43.5 2,277
H6847 Mass General Brigham Health Plan Mass General Brigham Incorporated 43.5 2,124
H8093 Georgia Health Advantage Mitchell Family Office 53.5 2,064
H9907 Tufts Health Plan Point32Health, Inc. 43.5 2,033
H3800 Provider Partners Health Plans Rifkin Managed Care Holding, LLC 43.5 1,079
H4093 Provider Partners Health Plans Rifkin Managed Care Holding, LLC 53.5 860

How this is worked out

Each contract's overall rating in CMS's 2027 Star Ratings data tables is compared with its rating for 2026, by contract ID. A contract is counted if it was rated 4 stars or higher in 2026 and below 4 stars in 2027. Contracts that weren't rated in 2026, including new ones, aren't counted either way.

Members are the contract's enrollment in CMS's monthly file for November 2026. Plans with 10 or fewer members are hidden by CMS and count as zero. Medicare Advantage only: PACE, cost plans, demonstrations and standalone drug plans are left out.

Ratings released in October of one year apply to the following year's plan, and to quality bonus payments the year after that. A contract's rating can also change later if CMS recalculates it, for example after a successful appeal or court case.

Sources

Go further

Related questions