Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
All questionsFor vendor teamsFor health plansFor providers

Questions › Quality and Star Ratings

How did the 4-star cut points change for 2027?

For 2027, the score needed for 4 stars got harder to reach on 17 of 45 measures and easier on 12; 13 stayed the same and 3 have no comparable 2026 cut point. Cut points move because CMS sets them each year from how contracts actually scored: when most plans improve on a measure, the bar rises with them.

The 4-star cut point for each measure

MeasurePartWeight4 stars, 20264 stars, 2027ChangeFor plans
C01 Breast Cancer ScreeningC1 7677+1 Harder
C02 Colorectal Cancer ScreeningC1 7075+5 Harder
C03 Annual Flu VaccineC1 6867−1 Easier
C04 Improving or Maintaining Physical HealthC3 7273+1 Harder
C05 Improving or Maintaining Mental HealthC3 85850 Same
C06 Monitoring Physical ActivityC1 5355+2 Harder
C07 Special Needs Plan (SNP) Care ManagementC— 7378+5 Harder
C08 Care for Older Adults – Medication ReviewC1 9396+3 Harder
C09 Care for Older Adults - Functional Status AssessmentC1 —87— New
C10 Osteoporosis Management in Women who had a FractureC1 5352−1 Easier
C11 Diabetes Care – Eye ExamC1 8079−1 Easier
C12 Diabetes Care – Blood Sugar ControlledC3 8789+2 Harder
C13 Kidney Health Evaluation for Patients with DiabetesC1 6272+10 Harder
C14 Controlling High Blood PressureC3 8084+4 Harder
C15 Reducing the Risk of FallingC1 6265+3 Harder
C16 Improving Bladder ControlC1 4947−2 Easier
C17 Plan All-Cause ReadmissionsC3 910+1 Easier
C18 Statin Therapy for Patients with Cardiovascular DiseaseC1 8889+1 Harder
C19 Transitions of CareC1 69690 Same
C20 Follow-up after Emergency Department Visit for People with Multiple High-Risk Chronic ConditionsC1 6772+5 Harder
C21 Getting Needed CareC2 8283+1 Harder
C22 Getting Appointments and Care QuicklyC2 84840 Same
C23 Customer ServiceC2 91910 Same
C24 Rating of Health Care QualityC2 87870 Same
C25 Rating of Health PlanC2 87870 Same
C26 Care CoordinationC2 88880 Same
C27 Complaints about the Health PlanC2 0.320.33+0.01 Easier
C28 Members Choosing to Leave the PlanC2 17170 Same
C29 Health Plan Quality ImprovementC5 0.20.16−0.04 Easier
C30 Plan Makes Timely Decisions about AppealsC2 9998−1 Easier
C31 Reviewing Appeals DecisionsC2 98980 Same
C32 Call Center – Foreign Language Interpreter and TTY AvailabilityC2 97970 Same
D01 Call Center – Foreign Language Interpreter and TTY AvailabilityD2 9597+2 Harder
D02 Complaints about the Drug PlanD2 0.320.33+0.01 Easier
D03 Members Choosing to Leave the PlanD2 17170 Same
D04 Drug Plan Quality ImprovementD5 0.320.23−0.09 Easier
D05 Rating of Drug PlanD2 8887−1 Easier
D06 Getting Needed Prescription DrugsD2 90900 Same
D07 MPF Price AccuracyD1 9499+5 Harder
D08 Medication Adherence for Diabetes MedicationsD3 8991+2 Harder
D09 Medication Adherence for Hypertension (RAS antagonists)D3 9190−1 Easier
D10 Medication Adherence for Cholesterol (Statins)D3 90900 Same
D11 Statin Use in Persons with Diabetes (SUPD)D1 8990+1 Harder
D12 Concurrent Use of Opioids and Benzodiazepines (COB)D1 —12— New
D13 Polypharmacy: Use of Multiple Anticholinergic Medications in Older Adults (Poly-ACH)D1 —7— New

How this is worked out

Each measure's 4-star threshold comes from CMS's cut point tables for the 2027 and 2026 Star Ratings. Part C measures use the Medicare Advantage cut points; Part D measures use the cut points for Medicare Advantage drug plans. Measures are matched across years by their underlying measure, since CMS sometimes renumbers them.

"Harder" means the threshold moved against plans: up for measures where a higher score is better, down for the few where lower is better (such as members choosing to leave). Units are the measure's own, mostly percentages.

Sources

Go further

Related questions