Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
All questionsFor vendor teamsFor health plansFor providers

Questions › Quality and Star Ratings

Which Star measures do the most contracts score low on?

The measure the most contracts score low on is Follow-up after Emergency Department Visit for People with Multiple High-Risk Chronic Conditions: 58% of the 518 Medicare Advantage contracts rated on it got 1 or 2 stars for 2027. Next is Reducing the Risk of Falling, at 48%.

Measures where many contracts score low are where most plans have room to improve, and where a gain moves a plan furthest relative to its peers.

Every measure, by share of contracts at 1 or 2 stars

MeasurePartWeightContracts rated1–2 stars, 20271–2 stars, 20264–5 stars, 2027
C20 Follow-up after Emergency Department Visit for People with Multiple High-Risk Chronic ConditionsC1518 58%39%20%
C15 Reducing the Risk of FallingC1425 48%47%28%
D08 Medication Adherence for Diabetes MedicationsD3559 45%25%22%
C04 Improving or Maintaining Physical HealthC3291 42%27%34%
C10 Osteoporosis Management in Women who had a FractureC1309 41%44%30%
C03 Annual Flu VaccineC1485 38%35%41%
C06 Monitoring Physical ActivityC1473 36%23%31%
D04 Drug Plan Quality ImprovementD5518 35%17%39%
D11 Statin Use in Persons with Diabetes (SUPD)D1550 34%16%38%
C14 Controlling High Blood PressureC3506 32%20%32%
C16 Improving Bladder ControlC1372 29%39%39%
C25 Rating of Health PlanC2485 29%27%50%
C05 Improving or Maintaining Mental HealthC3289 29%25%41%
C11 Diabetes Care – Eye ExamC1525 28%19%39%
D10 Medication Adherence for Cholesterol (Statins)D3565 27%26%47%
C01 Breast Cancer ScreeningC1482 26%30%44%
C19 Transitions of CareC1510 25%29%47%
C13 Kidney Health Evaluation for Patients with DiabetesC1529 25%13%38%
D05 Rating of Drug PlanD2479 25%28%61%
C18 Statin Therapy for Patients with Cardiovascular DiseaseC1457 23%22%42%
C17 Plan All-Cause ReadmissionsC3467 22%36%55%
C24 Rating of Health Care QualityC2451 22%25%60%
C07 Special Needs Plan (SNP) Care ManagementC—341 22%20%51%
C23 Customer ServiceC2446 22%15%44%
C21 Getting Needed CareC2481 21%25%45%
D09 Medication Adherence for Hypertension (RAS antagonists)D3565 20%20%54%
C29 Health Plan Quality ImprovementC5456 20%12%45%
D13 Polypharmacy: Use of Multiple Anticholinergic Medications in Older Adults (Poly-ACH)D1544 19%—44%
C02 Colorectal Cancer ScreeningC1516 19%10%52%
D12 Concurrent Use of Opioids and Benzodiazepines (COB)D1541 18%—52%
C31 Reviewing Appeals DecisionsC2458 17%19%73%
D03 Members Choosing to Leave the PlanD2510 17%16%57%
C28 Members Choosing to Leave the PlanC2511 17%16%57%
D06 Getting Needed Prescription DrugsD2349 17%13%60%
C22 Getting Appointments and Care QuicklyC2350 15%18%69%
C26 Care CoordinationC2362 14%15%54%
C30 Plan Makes Timely Decisions about AppealsC2459 14%4%76%
C09 Care for Older Adults - Functional Status AssessmentC1334 13%—70%
D02 Complaints about the Drug PlanD2513 10%4%69%
C27 Complaints about the Health PlanC2515 10%4%69%
C12 Diabetes Care – Blood Sugar ControlledC3527 9%7%55%
C08 Care for Older Adults – Medication ReviewC1334 8%6%75%
D07 MPF Price AccuracyD1563 7%6%87%
D01 Call Center – Foreign Language Interpreter and TTY AvailabilityD2622 3%1%79%
C32 Call Center – Foreign Language Interpreter and TTY AvailabilityC2623 2%0%81%

How this is worked out

For each measure, the share of Medicare Advantage contracts with a 2027 rating on it that scored 1 or 2 stars. The prior-year column uses the same contracts' 2026 stars on the measure where they had one. Measures rated for fewer than 50 contracts are left out.

The weight is CMS's: outcome and access measures count more toward the overall rating than process measures. A measure can have many low scores because it is new, because CMS raised its cut points, or because plans genuinely struggle with it; the measure's page shows its history.

Sources

Go further

Related questions