Payer Almanac
About the data Sign in
All questionsFor vendor teamsFor health plansFor providers

Questions › Quality and Star Ratings

What share of Medicare Advantage members are in plans rated 4 stars or higher?

71% of members in rated Medicare Advantage contracts are in contracts rated 4 stars or higher for 2027: 24,833,350 of 34,942,709 people. Four stars is the line for CMS's quality bonus payment, so this is also roughly the share of members whose plan earns the bonus.

Members by overall rating

Overall rating, 2027ContractsMembersShare of members
515790,4542.3%
4.56511,495,70732.9%
410812,547,18935.9%
3.51636,872,26719.7%
31232,950,2218.4%
2.531282,9820.8%
213,8890.0%

The 15 largest parent organizations

Parent organizationRated contractsMembersIn 4+ star contracts
UnitedHealth Group, Inc.549,222,01768%
Humana Inc.307,067,50895%
CVS Health Corporation394,136,63270%
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, Inc.92,077,535100%
Elevance Health, Inc.371,805,36647%
Health Care Service Corporation21876,70413%
Centene Corporation46809,28810%
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Mutual Ins. Co.3622,75499%
Devoted Health, Inc.29488,61679%
SCAN Group4457,60596%
Highmark Health8424,41585%
MHH Healthcare, L.P.2380,66395%
Healthfirst, Inc.4377,2270%
Lifetime Healthcare, Inc.5335,31653%
Alignment Healthcare USA, LLC7302,84925%

How this is worked out

Members are counted in every Medicare Advantage contract that received an overall 2027 rating (506 contracts), using each contract's enrollment in CMS's November 2026 monthly file. Contracts without an overall rating (too new, too small, or rated on Part D only) are left out of both the count and the total.

The rating decides whether a contract earns the quality bonus; how much it is worth depends on the county benchmarks where its members live.

Sources

Go further

Related questions