Do smaller Medicare Advantage plans get lower Star Ratings?
Mostly, yes. 81% of contracts with 250,000 or more members are rated 4 stars or higher for 2027, against 26% of contracts with 1,000 to 10,000. Their average ratings are 4.12 and 3.43 stars.
This is a pattern, not proof that size causes it. A small contract's scores also swing more from year to year, because fewer of its members are measured on each measure.
Ratings by contract size
| Members | Rated contracts | Members | Average rating | 4+ stars | Below 3 stars | A CMS letter in the last 2 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 1,000 | 17 | 12,811 | 3.56 | 35% | 18% | 35% |
| 1,000–10,000 | 166 | 775,233 | 3.43 | 26% | 13% | 52% |
| 10,000–50,000 | 192 | 4,598,350 | 3.56 | 33% | 4% | 57% |
| 50,000–250,000 | 105 | 10,580,846 | 3.79 | 51% | 0% | 58% |
| 250,000 or more | 26 | 18,975,469 | 4.12 | 81% | 0% | 73% |
How this is worked out
Medicare Advantage contracts with an overall 2027 rating, grouped by members in CMS's November 2026 enrollment file. Averages and shares count contracts, not members, so each contract counts once whatever its size. "A CMS letter" means at least one warning letter, corrective action plan or civil money penalty in the two years before the ratings came out.
CMS adjusts some measures for the share of members with low incomes or disabilities (the categorical adjustment index), which helps plans serving those members; the ratings here include it.
Sources
- CMS, Part C and D Star Ratings data tables, 2027.
- CMS, monthly enrollment by contract; CMS compliance and enforcement actions.